Gransnet forums

News & politics

Should any marches around or near the Cenotaph this weekend not be allowed?

(697 Posts)
maddyone Wed 08-Nov-23 09:58:48

Following the defacing of a Cenotaph in Rotherham yesterday, would it be advisable for the police to rule that marches in or around the area of the Cenotaph should not be allowed, this weekend only?
A poppy seller was attacked by people in a huge crowd this week, people who have been marching on previous weekends have committed hate crimes by calling for Jews to be eliminated. Should the sanctity of the Cenotaph and the Remembrance Service be at the mercy of the marchers to choose to do the right thing? Why was a Cenotaph thought to be a legitimate target in Rotherham?
Surely those who live in our liberal democracy should understand why this weekend is particularly special to so many people. Those of us who live in this country, a liberal democracy, should understand that compared to so many people in the world, we are very lucky to live in a country that affords us great freedoms, including the right to protest peacefully. Peaceful protest however, does not include the right to call for the deaths of other people, to attack poppy sellers or others, or to deface public buildings.
Why are the London police refusing to use the laws that are already available to ban any marching around this area for for this one weekend?

* [Typo in the title has now been edited by GNHQ]

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 10-Nov-23 16:43:22

Really Namsnanny ? That’s disgraceful. I hope they wear their medals with pride and aren’t cowed by threats. Medals show that the wearer (or their deceased spouse or other close relative) fought for the freedom of this country and others. They should not be targets for violence.

Galaxy Fri 10-Nov-23 16:48:44

No people are able to make decisions without being described as being in a moral panic. Just because people have different views to you does not mean they are unable to think for themselves. My guess is I have much more experience of masked men on marches than you do.
I do not know of any other minorities whose fears would be dismissed in this way.

Whitewavemark2 Fri 10-Nov-23 16:52:37

Galaxy

No people are able to make decisions without being described as being in a moral panic. Just because people have different views to you does not mean they are unable to think for themselves. My guess is I have much more experience of masked men on marches than you do.
I do not know of any other minorities whose fears would be dismissed in this way.

😄 you have no idea of my experiences, and would probably be surprised if you knew!

I am not dismissing minority fears, but I am dismissing those whose agenda is to stoke these fears, causing moral panic.

Callistemon21 Fri 10-Nov-23 16:55:13

Namsnanny

Veterans have been advised not to wear their medals for their own safety.

Will they take any notice?

I'm sure those I know would ignore that advice.

Galaxy Fri 10-Nov-23 16:57:59

Well that's probably dangerous in itself the figures that I can see show overwhelming support for Braverman, when the majority of the population holds views very different from views held by the majority of the institutions of power, well we are going to end up in a right mess.
I am centre left, the idea that the police, in particular the met police, operate in an unbiased way has been demonstrated for years, long before braverman started spouting about it.

Galaxy Fri 10-Nov-23 16:59:13

Dear God the left in particular never shut up about the inherent bias of the police. It's one of their most familiar chants.

Galaxy Fri 10-Nov-23 17:00:06

Biased rather than unbiased grin

osamabinladen Fri 10-Nov-23 17:08:47

I read journalists, media and the police objects to the ban. Is it any wonder. The journalists enjoys making up stories. The media, newspapers, TVs and other reporting sources wants terrible news like retail stores broken in and items burgled. Then, they want the marches and other hooligans to overturn and burn vehicles, including property damaged. All these happening because Mark Rowdy wants to be sacked and enjoy retirement to approve the march. The police, aaaah the police and Mark Rowdy wants overtime for him and his men. They want the public to appraise their being the heroes, NOT! One more thing, the media faked their stories with polls and found the publish want the march to go ahead. But independent survey by many sources said, 75% or more public want the march banned.

Dinahmo Fri 10-Nov-23 17:10:53

Galaxy

Dear God the left in particular never shut up about the inherent bias of the police. It's one of their most familiar chants.

They are rather biased - against anyone with a dark skin and indeed anyone who look s out of the ordinary because they are bound to be up to no good.

DaisyAnneReturns Fri 10-Nov-23 17:16:13

Anniebach

No other events are expected !

Police guarding the Cenotaph, why ?

Because it's their job to be cautious and there is a very good chance Braverman will have stirred up the far right - just as she hopes to.

DaisyAnneReturns Fri 10-Nov-23 17:22:48

Braverman knows she will loose her chance to become the next leader of the Far-right and the Tories if the court find against her on Wednesday.

This wicked women is acting purely for her own selfish aims. She wants to be proved right so has stirred this up. She h3asn't a diplomatic bone in her body, only those of a selfish, would-be Oligarchs who wants to rule, not serve.

DaisyAnneReturns Fri 10-Nov-23 17:24:56

Whitewavemark2

Those that we are remembering this weekend died for freedom and peace.

I am sure that they would be totally in favour of anyone exercising their freedom of speech peacefully this weekend - particularly the peace March that goes nowhere near, nor ever intended to go near the cenotaph. These peace marches have been entirely peaceful for the past month, there is no reason why they shouldn’t be so tomorrow.

I would certainly have no hesitation in going to London.

First they came for those who would speak out for peace.

GrannyGravy13 Fri 10-Nov-23 17:27:16

Suella Braverman’s husband is Jewish.

Maybe that’s why her sentiments lay with Israel.

(He has described himself in the past as a proud Jew and Zionist)

DaisyAnneReturns Fri 10-Nov-23 17:31:15

GrannyGravy13

Suella Braverman’s husband is Jewish.

Maybe that’s why her sentiments lay with Israel.

(He has described himself in the past as a proud Jew and Zionist)

She is the Home Secretary. If she can't manage her "sentiments" she should resign.

Galaxy Fri 10-Nov-23 17:32:25

Are you joking. Three people on the marches have been arrested for terrorism offences.

DaisyAnneReturns Fri 10-Nov-23 17:33:42

Headline in the Telegraph "Pound shop Enoch Powell’ Suella Braverman has offended ‘just about everyone’"

That's hardly the left speaking.

Galaxy Fri 10-Nov-23 17:36:48

She hasnt though has she. That's the point I was making, if the polls I have seen are correct,that just shows the telegraph is out of touch with the general public. Lets face it, it wouldnt be the first time.

paddyann54 Fri 10-Nov-23 17:36:55

Its a very sad time in my life to see people believe that marching to "commemorate" the dead takes precedence over marching to save lives ...innocent lives.The dead are long gone their families will always mourn them t doesn't have to be a huge commemoration EVERY year .

I come from a family who never wore poppies or visited a cenotaph ,there were 6 uncles and my dad went to war the ones who came back all came home with mental or physical disabilities ,two never returned.
They were all loved but LIFE ,women and babies,innocents ,doctors in hosptals lives are far more important than people who are dead ...or have we learned nothing from war that we still glorify it with this yearly spectacle .
I stand for LIFE not death .I stand WITH Palestine.
Its that old dont bring me flowers when I'm dead thing my mother used to say,do what you can for me while I',m alive

MayBee70 Fri 10-Nov-23 17:41:13

Whitewavemark2

Those that we are remembering this weekend died for freedom and peace.

I am sure that they would be totally in favour of anyone exercising their freedom of speech peacefully this weekend - particularly the peace March that goes nowhere near, nor ever intended to go near the cenotaph. These peace marches have been entirely peaceful for the past month, there is no reason why they shouldn’t be so tomorrow.

I would certainly have no hesitation in going to London.

I would have agreed with you till I read that Tommy Robinson is going to be there. I’m still fuming over the Daily Mail headline which said ‘if you come for Suella you come for all of us’. How dare they assume that everyone in this country country agrees with her? Mind you, Carol Malone echoed that on Sky News last night which got me even madder. But then, she would, wouldn’t she sad. Tomorrow is a day for remembering everyone that has lost their lives through war and that includes the Israelis that died and the Palestinians that are dying now.

Callistemon21 Fri 10-Nov-23 17:42:09

It wasn't Braverman who suggested that veterans should not wear their medals or uniforms in London this weekend.
It was an Army Colonel, I believe.

If the march is peaceful or a vigil, then that should be fine, however, the organisers may find that it could be disrupted by some with different motives.

Jaberwok Fri 10-Nov-23 17:43:57

Annie, I know this is a difficult time of year for you. Just to let you know that I'm thinking of you. flowers

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 10-Nov-23 17:45:38

The marching won’t save lives.

There should be a ‘huge commemoration’ as you put it every year. If those brave men and women had not gone to war you would not have the freedoms you have today. You might not even be here today.

DaisyAnneReturns Fri 10-Nov-23 17:49:46

Of my family, parents, brother and me, I was the only one who was never a member of the forces. They fought for democracy, peace and the freedom to speak out.

This women doesn't care for those we commemorate or those who still serve, she only cares about personal power.

Anniebach Fri 10-Nov-23 17:51:32

Jaberwok thank you so much x

Callistemon21 Fri 10-Nov-23 17:55:56

Germanshepherdsmum

The marching won’t save lives.

There should be a ‘huge commemoration’ as you put it every year. If those brave men and women had not gone to war you would not have the freedoms you have today. You might not even be here today.

Well said, Germanshepherdsmum

We should remember them and the sacrifices they made to fight for our freedom, of speech an the right to peaceful protest.