Gransnet forums

News & politics

Yvette Cooper / Migrant Watch / Stopping The Boats

(534 Posts)
Nicenanny3 Fri 12-Jul-24 08:30:16

French police stand by and watch the boats leave for Britain. Now you are in charge Yvette Cooper what's your plan after you cancelled the Rwanda deterrent?

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 12-Jul-24 13:25:59

The mass arrival of illegal immigrants in boats seems to me to be an invasion.

Urmstongran Fri 12-Jul-24 13:41:21

As usual the UK government is missing a trick. Send all the illegal imigrants to Glasgow. It might just be as much of a deterrent as Rwanda, its would be completely legal, a lot cheaper and the SNP actually want them! according to news today.

LauraNorderr Fri 12-Jul-24 13:51:37

My son is a member of the RNLI and both as a member and as a human being he will always come to the aid of those in peril at sea.
This is for those saying that the RNLI should not assist.

BevSec Fri 12-Jul-24 13:58:31

That is funny Urms, I have never been to Glasgow. 😊

Wyllow3 Fri 12-Jul-24 13:59:10

LauraNorderr

My son is a member of the RNLI and both as a member and as a human being he will always come to the aid of those in peril at sea.
This is for those saying that the RNLI should not assist.

Good for him!

Wyllow3 Fri 12-Jul-24 14:04:42

maddyone

Maybe the world wide agreements aren’t fit for the situation today.

I doubt our military or indeed the public would want to give up the right to prevent invading countries to enter our land, sea or air space. Its for the protection of all.

Urmstongran Fri 12-Jul-24 14:05:27

To be fair, there was no slight intended against Glasgow! I just meant to illustrate that (a) the SNP really are encouraging migrants and (b) the migrants likely want to be down south, especially London (where the streets are paved with gold they believe).

Nicenanny3 Fri 12-Jul-24 14:13:05

Another 62 arrived on 1 boat yesterday. 546 since Labour were voted in.

Wyllow3 Fri 12-Jul-24 14:15:25

Urmstongran

To be fair, there was no slight intended against Glasgow! I just meant to illustrate that (a) the SNP really are encouraging migrants and (b) the migrants likely want to be down south, especially London (where the streets are paved with gold they believe).

I cant find a source for (a) Urms.

found articles on necessary immigration (ie, jobs, legal) but not migrants.

Callistemon213 Fri 12-Jul-24 14:15:36

LauraNorderr

My son is a member of the RNLI and both as a member and as a human being he will always come to the aid of those in peril at sea.
This is for those saying that the RNLI should not assist.

Well done to your son LauraNorderr.
We never now when we might need their help.

DH pays a monthly donation.

Urmstongran Fri 12-Jul-24 14:27:12

Here you go Wyllow3 from today’s Telegraph:

“ Generous Scottish tax-payers are to spend £2 million on a pilot scheme to give free bus travel to asylum seekers. The largesse is being provided by the Scottish Government and a range of publicly-funded civic society groups who want to demonstrate their support for new arrivals in Scotland, who must hereafter be referred to as New Scots.

The justification? In the words of the SNP’s equalities minister at Holyrood, Kaukab Stewart: “Scotland has a proud history of welcoming those fleeing war and persecution, and we are dedicated to helping them integrate into communities from the day they arrive. It is vital…people seeking asylum…understand their rights and access employment and services to help them to rebuild their lives in Scotland.”

NotSpaghetti Fri 12-Jul-24 14:39:37

Those of us with migrants in our families do know how grateful they are - and how determined to work and do well.

I hope this works to Scotland's benefit and they get New Scots who feel truly welcome there and contribute to their new communities.

Wyllow3 Fri 12-Jul-24 14:41:12

Oh, I found that (I always go to the Telegraph). But I assumed it referred to those who have already been granted asylum seeker status. new migrant arrivals have no status at all before processing.

Why?

You have to have the documents to apply and dont get documents before assessment

its also not new

"Do asylum seekers get free bus passes in Scotland?

It follows an announcement in the 2022-2023 Programme for Government that the Scottish Government would “work with third sector partners and local authorities to consider how best to provide free bus travel to asylum seekers and refugees including displaced people from Ukraine

source, Transport Scotland.

Its the Telegraph making waves again - without either the historical background or the facts about documentation required to apply

Wyllow3 Fri 12-Jul-24 14:46:02

It's also not a Scotland only initiative. Local Asylum seeker support organisation raises funds for bus passes - city in the North of England, so I think we can assume other similar initiatives elsewhere.

If you google
www.google.com/search?client=safari&rls=en&q=england+cities+bus+passes+asylum+seekers&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8

you'll see how prevalent the idea is.

Urmstongran Fri 12-Jul-24 14:52:18

Ah. Thanks Wyllow3 for the fuller explanation and links.
😊👋

Whitewavemark2 Fri 12-Jul-24 14:53:16

France will be keen to see how the Labour government might change things.
The scrapping of the Rwanda scheme came as no surprise, because the French never thought it was either right or effective.
The scheme had shown no clear sign of having a deterrent effect. Numbers kept going up.
The French view remains that the UK should address the pull factors that keep drawing so many migrants, such as the ease of entering the jobs market undetected and the lack of identity cards.
Governments of all stripes in Paris know the Calais problem is perennial, and the most to be hoped for is more effective operational cooperation with London.

Aveline Fri 12-Jul-24 15:07:58

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Urmstongran Fri 12-Jul-24 15:12:07

I wish Labour well in this. It’s in all our interests surely? They’ve had many years to formulate a plan whilst in opposition.
I’m keen to hear of it.
I did think Rwanda would work (expensively) well as a deterrent. Word was getting round. Uncertainty of destination was giving those paying the people smugglers pause for thought.
Now?
Who knows? Yvette Cooper may have a very cunning plan….

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 12-Jul-24 15:39:23

And I’m a Dutchman.

Urmstongran Fri 12-Jul-24 15:39:57

🤣

Nicenanny3 Fri 12-Jul-24 16:37:08

Well there's one pull factor free travel courtesy of a bus pass (free bus to town if you live on the the Bibby Stockholm a lady who lives near there told me she was very angry) and I had to wait until I reached pension age to get my free bus pass and I'd only paid in since I started work at 16 😡

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 12-Jul-24 16:38:35

Oh yes, free travel, no wait for medical or dental treatment.

Nicenanny3 Fri 12-Jul-24 16:39:27

Free phone when you get off the boat, that would be nice wouldn't for us OAPs as well a new phone. What else?

maddyone Fri 12-Jul-24 16:40:10

LauraNorderr

My son is a member of the RNLI and both as a member and as a human being he will always come to the aid of those in peril at sea.
This is for those saying that the RNLI should not assist.

Just to be clear, I didn’t say that the RNLI shouldn’t go to assist migrants, I simply said they do go to assist migrants, because someone upthread appeared to not believe it.

You should be very proud of your son LauraNorderr because it is a very worthwhile charity.

JaneJudge Fri 12-Jul-24 16:41:43

all of this is Yvette Coopers fault