Gransnet forums

News & politics

Trump shot at rally - just caught his ear.

(350 Posts)
NotSpaghetti Sat 13-Jul-24 23:53:50

Breaking news.
3 shots.
He's apparently fine.

Syracute Sun 14-Jul-24 19:28:47

But no where does it say he was a left wing fanatic who was taught to hate by left wing liberals etc Freya’s incendiary remark .

Callistemon213 Sun 14-Jul-24 20:19:54

Wyllow3

Syracute

What are you talking about ?
This is just divisive claims based on no fact .
He was a registered Republican.
It sounds like he was a disaffected young man most likely influenced by online rhetoric .

There's a very good summary of what we know about him, where he got the gun, that he had explosive devices in his car and the means to detonate -

and the usual, "he was always nice and friendly"

www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c3gw58wv4e9o

and the usual, "he was always nice and friendly"

Oh yes: 'Lovely young man, kind to his mother and his elderly Granny, chatted in the corner shop, loved Baseball etc etc etc'.

Dickens Sun 14-Jul-24 20:25:48

Iam64

Freya5

Bea65

Am also not surprised by this attempt to be rid of this man - my thoughts are with the spectator that has died & the 2injured people😥

My thoughts are with everyone affected by this horror. A left wing fanatic, who was taught to hate by left wing liberals, including the Democratic Party, of which he was a member.

Where is the evidence to support your post?
Who has proved the shooter was a left wing fanatic, who was taught to hate by left wing liberals, including the Democratic Party, of which he was a member
What is your definition of a left wing liberal?
What is your analysis of Trump’s insurrection

Thank you Iam64.

Posters who make inflammatory comments like this need to be held accountable.

To infer that Democrats, or those holding liberal / left-wing views are responsible for this man attempting to murder Trump are completely indefensible.

Fanatics, extremists, militants, come in all hues, and they are not limited to the left. In fact they are frequently found to be unstable mis-fits who don't posses any ability for rational political thought.

Quite a few posters dislike Trump - and I'm one of them - but I'm appalled that an attempt was made to assassinate him. And whatever my feelings about the man, I'm mindful of the fact that he has a wife and teenage son (apart from the remainder of his family) who will be hugely impacted by this attempted murder.

There appear to be so many deviants in possession of various types of guns in America, and that is the problem. Not left-wing-liberals.

Callistemon213 Sun 14-Jul-24 20:27:32

Well said Dickens.

The gun culture in the USA is truly terrifying.

sukie Sun 14-Jul-24 20:37:56

Ditto everything Dickens has said (and I'm in the USA).

Syracute Sun 14-Jul-24 20:54:18

Exactly this !!!

maddyone Sun 14-Jul-24 21:00:40

I agree with Dickens too.
I’m only posting because it’s half time in the football ⚽️

flappergirl Sun 14-Jul-24 22:26:21

"A left wing fanatic, who was taught to hate by left wing liberals, including the Democratic Party, of which he was a member."

Don't be ridiculous Freya. Firstly, the shooter was a member of the Republican party. Secondly, the Democratic party is hardly a seething hot bed of anarchy, hatred and insurrection. I don't think even Trump would accuse them of that. In fact, if you cast your mind back, it was Trump supporters that came dangerously close to fanaticism when they stormed the White House and drew innocent blood.

Lastly and much more to the point, America is full of gun toting lunatics (especially young men it would seem) who need no excuse or affiliation to kill or cause mayhem. The whole world is quite aware of this and I'm perfectly sure you are too.

Callistemon213 Sun 14-Jul-24 22:42:21

Freya5

Bea65

Am also not surprised by this attempt to be rid of this man - my thoughts are with the spectator that has died & the 2injured people😥

My thoughts are with everyone affected by this horror. A left wing fanatic, who was taught to hate by left wing liberals, including the Democratic Party, of which he was a member.

I think the USA Democratic Party is not as far left as you say, Freya5

American politics generally would seem to be further to the right than here or many other countries and the Democrats are more of a centrist party.

Some Republican supporters would seem to be more fanatical, as evidenced by their storming of the Capitol.

maddyone Sun 14-Jul-24 23:47:13

For what it’s worth I think that this shooting happened because the young man was in some way mentally unstable. Nothing to do with this party or that party, much more to do with the failure in his life and his personality. Watch this space, it’ll be announced soon that he had few or no friends, never had a girlfriend, was a loner, had a dysfunctional family life. Probably no job. Possibly mental health issues sick as bipolar or autism.
And crucially, his father bought the gun apparently, and obviously he had access to it.

Mollygo Sun 14-Jul-24 23:53:32

Not even an attempt on his life and the death and critical injury of some of his supporters will make Trump try to do something about guns in the USA.
Firstly itv would be almost impossible and also, it would lose him votes.
It’s a sad world.

Whitewavemark2 Mon 15-Jul-24 02:59:10

I think this incident has brought into sharp relief the difference between American and European culture.

We have recently had two big elections in Europe in the U.K. and France, and both were achieved with the peaceful transfer of power by voters who were willing to transfer their vote rather than remain with their so called tribal loyalties.

Neither appears possible now in the USA.

The USA is completely divided between the two big political parties with only very few people willing to change their vote.

The rhetoric of hate and division is growing to such an extent that even as the gun residue was blowing away, American politicians were blaming the other side without a modicum of evidence using the sort of hate filled language that is becoming normal.

We, in Europe must take note and never allow our politicians to lead us down this path of hate filled divisive rhetoric, because that way lies open to violence and ruin.

NotSpaghetti Mon 15-Jul-24 07:20:23

Something went wrong at this rally in terms of security.
The gunman shouldn't have got in - or got so close.

Security starts with a site survey by the secret service weeks in advance apparently and getting him out was slow. He did seem to be fixated on his shoes - why did anyone even listen to him about that - just get him away!

If there had been a second gunman they would have had a second shot at him as he was so exposed while he was waving his arms about.

Whitewavemark2 Mon 15-Jul-24 07:25:41

This

Ian Dunt

There is a significant problem with calming the rhetoric against Trump. The problem is that he is a threat to democracy. He is a threat to European security and freedom against Russian imperialism. And these things do not cease to be true because some nutter tried to kill him

Callistemon213 Mon 15-Jul-24 07:37:24

NotSpaghetti

Something went wrong at this rally in terms of security.
The gunman shouldn't have got in - or got so close.

Security starts with a site survey by the secret service weeks in advance apparently and getting him out was slow. He did seem to be fixated on his shoes - why did anyone even listen to him about that - just get him away!

If there had been a second gunman they would have had a second shot at him as he was so exposed while he was waving his arms about.

The gunman was outside the actual venue and not that close.
The gun was an AR high velocity rifle, owned by many Americans. Trump was lucky to just have a graze, others were not.

As someone else mentioned, why were drones not used to survey the whole area?

Galaxy Mon 15-Jul-24 07:46:45

I dont know what I feel about criticising the security. My first thought on seeing them was arent people amazing, to without thought give up your own life to save someone else. I couldnt do that. There will he time to analyse any 'failings'.

Callistemon213 Mon 15-Jul-24 07:51:17

Galaxy

I dont know what I feel about criticising the security. My first thought on seeing them was arent people amazing, to without thought give up your own life to save someone else. I couldnt do that. There will he time to analyse any 'failings'.

I certainly couldn't do what the security people around Trump did, put themselves between him and a gunman.
Unless, of course, it was my child or grandchild.
That is what the man who died did, threw himself on top of his family.

The police outside were, I think, police not security.

NotSpaghetti Mon 15-Jul-24 08:05:16

Ian Dunt is right WWM

As regards comments about security, clearly something went wrong. The nearby buildings would have been assessed weeks if not months ago and security provided according to need. Something clearly went wrong.

And yes, people are amazing - but security have chosen this - as a career - just as police/soldiers/firefighters do.
They know what they are signed up for.

Joseann Mon 15-Jul-24 08:09:25

Trump has said, just wgat dome of us said yesterday,
I wanted to keep speaking - I wanted to keep speaking, but I just got shot. *It's a very surreal experience, and you never know what you're going to do until a thing like that happens*.

Joseann Mon 15-Jul-24 08:10:06

*just what some of us

Freya5 Mon 15-Jul-24 08:37:13

Syracute

But no where does it say he was a left wing fanatic who was taught to hate by left wing liberals etc Freya’s incendiary remark .

Have you even read or viewed the hate speeches re Trump from both American and British politicians. Perhaps you should listen to the American views , and see the shooters video. See the cartoon, sick, of Pelosi on a roof, doing what she said she would. Do you not think those words are incendiary. Feeding a loner, which he was, so it's reported, in America . By the way don't listen to the BBC propaganda, it was a pop. Apparently from a British Journo actually there, who has reported from the Middle East, that what a gun shot sounds like.
The truth, you don't like it, tough.
I will comment no more on this , because it will be twisted to your own agenda.

Iam64 Mon 15-Jul-24 08:41:46

Information about the young assassin is sparse so far. I’m sure maddyone’s predictions about what is likely to emerge are accurate. The DM quotes one of his fellow students as saying he was very badly bullied at school.mm

nanna8 Mon 15-Jul-24 09:17:40

It seems the shooter was just a nutjob ,an outsider who likely had serious mental problems. Sad that the security didn’t pick him up beforehand and save the lives of the onlookers. Looking at a picture of him, he looked younger than his years. How ridiculous that people like him are even allowed to own high powered rifles. They are very different in that country.

eazybee Mon 15-Jul-24 09:44:48

'just a nutjob' ?
The rifle was purchased by his father.

I would think that a former President refusing to accept the result of a legitimate election, inciting his supporters to storm the seat of government and terrify and harm its occupants, and repeatedly declare himself above the law, has something to do with the incendiary state of affairs.

Wyllow3 Mon 15-Jul-24 09:47:37

There are appalling words of hate from all sources, which may or may not have affected the young man.

To date, the FBI have found no connections with anyone else and concluding he acted alone.

He did have a job as a cook in a care home, but since the T shirt he wore from Demolition Ranch was gun and macho obsessions one can only guess why he chose to die in the most dramatic way possible.