Gransnet forums

News & politics

What on earth is wrong with the Tory party.

(64 Posts)
Whitewavemark2 Sat 20-Jul-24 16:11:13

I’ve just watched an incident in which Victoria Atkins was told by the speaker that she had behaved abominably. I would tend to agree, but I thought her performance was rather like a screeching fishwife.

Earlier this week I watched Badenoch give a speech that was deeply unpleasant, patronising, and a classless embarrassment.

It would be a massive mistake for the Tories to even begin to consider her as the next leader, not only for her abysmal parliamentary performances, but also for her failure as a government minister.

Although if they want to loose the next election then I would heartily commend her as the next leader.

Whitewavemark2 Sun 21-Jul-24 07:33:58

Apparently more centrist ousted MPs had a meeting in the Carlton this week - including Mordaunt. They are calling for restraint before charging ahead and choosing a right wing leader. They are also hoping to get re-elected asap in the hope of pulling the Tory party back from oblivion if it swings to the right.

ronib Sun 21-Jul-24 08:08:19

Victoria Atkins represents a farming community. I see complaints that Labour had just 87 words about farming and fishing in the King’s Speech. Also something about one billion pounds- is that in lost subsidies?Not forgetting plans for solar panels on farm land which removes acreage from food production.
So why is Victoria Atkins screeching ?

Casdon Sun 21-Jul-24 08:16:28

ronib

Victoria Atkins represents a farming community. I see complaints that Labour had just 87 words about farming and fishing in the King’s Speech. Also something about one billion pounds- is that in lost subsidies?Not forgetting plans for solar panels on farm land which removes acreage from food production.
So why is Victoria Atkins screeching ?

There is no excuse for shouting and screeching in parliament ronib, whatever the circumstances. That is why the speaker admonished her for behaving abominably. I don’t care what party people are from, or what their grievances are, they deserve punishment for that kind of behaviour. You can’t defend it. Please let’s put some dignity back into the commons.

ronib Sun 21-Jul-24 08:16:30

Correction- Labour said nothing at all about fishing in the King’s Speech.
Now why is that?
Starmer is renegotiating fishing rights with the EU I guess?

Casdon Sun 21-Jul-24 08:19:31

Whitewavemark2

Apparently more centrist ousted MPs had a meeting in the Carlton this week - including Mordaunt. They are calling for restraint before charging ahead and choosing a right wing leader. They are also hoping to get re-elected asap in the hope of pulling the Tory party back from oblivion if it swings to the right.

I still think the proposal to put Iain Duncan-Smith in as interim leader is the best option, because it will inevitably take time to find the best way forward. Somebody who has already said they don’t want the leadership long term would be the best broker between the factions.

Joseann Sun 21-Jul-24 09:07:10

IDS is actually a very measured person. He was our MP for many years, DH knew him and his work ethic. Very proactive and a do-er, but not easily ruffled or rude.

Joseann Sun 21-Jul-24 09:10:58

Just as an example, IDS secured funding for our new hospital in East London, and will not allow the project to fail if it's the last thing he does.

LizzieDrip Sun 21-Jul-24 09:50:40

Depends how you define ‘rude’.

IDS was behind the raising of the state pension age for women, causing financial hardship for millions of 50’s born women. He refused to engage with women about their plight.

This from Baroness Ros Altman, who has fought tirelessly for WASPI women:

“As Pensions Minister, I kept trying to find a way to alleviate the unfairness of these short-notice changes. Unfortunately, there was no sympathy for these women. Iain Duncan Smith, as Secretary of State, refused to engage with the 1950s women adversely affected and I was instructed not to speak to them. I was told the women would go away sooner or later.”angry

Grantanow Sun 21-Jul-24 10:12:22

I'm not impressed by IDS. And certainly not by Victoria Atkins who obviously can't get over being in Opposition with the fewer speaking opportunities that entails.

Joseann Sun 21-Jul-24 11:49:39

Depends how you define ‘rude’.
Not screeching and waving fists for a start!

Mollygo Sun 21-Jul-24 12:53:45

IDS was behind the raising of the state pension age for women, causing financial hardship for millions of 50’s born women. He refused to engage with women about their plight.
Yes, and that, like the actions of Gordon Brown are the sort of actions that impacted on millions of people.

Casdon Sun 21-Jul-24 14:11:53

This is a different ball game altogether though, isn’t it? I think that whichever party is in power it needs effective opposition, and the Tories need to rebuild in order to be that opposition now.
I didn’t like much of what Duncan-Smith did, but he’s a serious and effective politician with experience - can you think of anybody else who could do the rebuilding leadership role in the interim period, given the immediate past government leaders have baggage?

Whitewavemark2 Sun 21-Jul-24 14:50:36

If you look at the makeup of parliament at the moment, 2/3rds of the chamber is filled with progressive parties, and only 1/3 composed of the centre right/right/far right opposition which is very weak and divided, this is bad for democracy.