Gransnet forums

News & politics

Israel Committing War Crimes - Israel - Gaza Part 4

(705 Posts)
Magenta8 Fri 25-Jul-25 11:08:56

It is very difficult to understand what is really happening and what are lies being perpetrated by Israel or Hamas. Add to this reporting restrictions and it is surprising we know as much as we do.

silverlining48 Tue 29-Jul-25 09:39:18

I don’t support it but it always goes on and people suffer.

Oreo Tue 29-Jul-25 09:40:04

AGAA4

Maremia Elbit Systems is an Israeli technology company. Clear now why Palestine Action have been proscribed as terrorists.

Don’t be ridiculous.
The Home Office have proscribed this group because they are dangerous in what they’re prepared to do.It’s a wake up call to anyone who thinks they might join in.
Breaking into a military base and causing damage to planes was a step too far.

Oreo Tue 29-Jul-25 09:42:34

silverlining48

No one should blame those who are starving. The black market has always gone on in every conflict,

The ones selling food aid are far from starving.
You can’t eat money.
They are selling it quite brazenly in the market.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 29-Jul-25 09:47:23

Wouldn’t happen if Israel were committing genocide

Whitewavemark2 Tue 29-Jul-25 09:51:25

The danger of the israeli government inflicting genocide on other areas.

“Genocide is the systematic and intentional destruction of a group, and in Gaza we are witnessing this in its most extreme form. Meanwhile, the same government and the same forces are escalating violence in the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, and inside Israel. In all of these areas, Palestinians are being abandoned to escalating violence, forcible displacement, collective punishment, and denial of their human rights – solely because they are Palestinian. Israeli politicians and public figures have repeatedly stated that the destruction Israel is carrying out in Gaza should be extended to the West Bank, and we believe this incitement must be taken seriously and stopped before it is fulfilled.

The genocide is happening now in the Gaza Strip, but any trigger could cause it to rapidly spread to other areas under Israel’s control. Currently, there is no mechanism, domestic or international, that will stop it.”

I think that risk is much higher once the Palestinian state is recognised

silverlining48 Tue 29-Jul-25 09:52:35

But it didn’t happen until Israel took over with its ‘humanitarian’ food aid. 1000 have already been killed while queuing in heat and chaotic conditions fir what little is available after walking for miles in the40 degree heat without water,
The hundreds of Lorries queuing outside are full of food, especially baby formula and can do the job cheaper and quicker than dropping food from a plane, so why don’t they do it? I think we can answer that question.

Oreo Tue 29-Jul-25 09:55:43

A Palestinian State should only be recognised as part of a peace process in which the terrorists, hamas give up hostages and any power they have left.
I believe this is what Starmer and the government think too.

Oreo Tue 29-Jul-25 09:59:46

silverlining48

But it didn’t happen until Israel took over with its ‘humanitarian’ food aid. 1000 have already been killed while queuing in heat and chaotic conditions fir what little is available after walking for miles in the40 degree heat without water,
The hundreds of Lorries queuing outside are full of food, especially baby formula and can do the job cheaper and quicker than dropping food from a plane, so why don’t they do it? I think we can answer that question.

You’re quite wrong, it has been happening there for ages.
Acquiring food aid from any means including looting of aid lorries and storage facilities and then selling it at exorbitant prices.
Israel tried to limit hamas and criminals doing this by setting up GHF but that didn’t work well either.

Anniebach Tue 29-Jul-25 09:59:48

Quote Oreo Tue 29-Jul-25 09:55:43
A Palestinian State should only be recognised as part of a peace process in which the terrorists, hamas give up hostages and any power they have left.
I believe this is what Starmer and the government think too.

I too believe the same Oreo , recognise a terrorist government ? No,no, no

AGAA4 Tue 29-Jul-25 10:06:12

Oreo calling me ridiculous is an attack and goes against guidelines.
My comments are as valid as yours and it seems Elbit were involved in persuading the home office to proscribe Palestine Acton.
What the action group did was criminal damage not terrorism.

Oreo Tue 29-Jul-25 10:10:57

Your remarks were ridiculous, and that isn’t against guidelines to say so.
‘It seems’ isn’t the truth btw on your comments about Elbit.
Parliament doesn’t proscribe groups as terrorists lightly or maybe you think a few GN members know more than they do.

Anniebach Tue 29-Jul-25 10:14:09

Quote AGAA4 Tue 29-Jul-25 10:06:12
Oreo calling me ridiculous is an attack and goes against guidelines.
My comments are as valid as yours and it seems Elbit were involved in persuading the home office to proscribe Palestine Acton.
What the action group did was criminal damage not terrorism.

Terrorism is defined in legislation under the Terrorism Act 2000. Section 1 of the act states that terrorism means the use or threat of one or more of the following actions: serious violence against a person. serious damage to property. endangering a person's life (other than that of the person committing the action)

Maremia Tue 29-Jul-25 10:20:55

Comparing Palestine Action to ISIS is not proportionate.
Letting foreign interests interfere is not in our best interests, but in theirs.

Maremia Tue 29-Jul-25 10:24:24

Thank you AGAA4, so Elbit Systems is an Israeli technology company. Not sure if they should have any influence at all.

AGAA4 Tue 29-Jul-25 10:26:01

I don't agree with criminal damage but it's known that Palestine Action do not harm people.
They are making the point that the UK is sending weapons to Israel to destroy Gaza.

Anniebach Tue 29-Jul-25 10:28:03

Elbit Systems Ltd. is an Israel-based international military technology company and defense contractor. Founded in 1966 by Elron, Elbit Systems is the primary provider of the Israeli military's land-based equipment and unmanned aerial vehicles. It is an important company within the defense industry of Israel.

Maremia Tue 29-Jul-25 10:31:24

Whitewave, I am astonished at how little, or no, comment that has been made about your post at 9.12.49, from a source within the actual State of Israel.
It says almost everything that some of the GNs on this line believe to be true. Most likely the Posters have missed it, because they were in the process of replying to something upthread. To give everyone another chance to read this valuable input, and if you have the time, would you please re-post.

Oreo Tue 29-Jul-25 10:42:57

Maremia
There are many sources and groups within Israel, just as there are here in the UK.
Including those that don’t agree with government decisions.
They are free to say it, Israel is a democratic country.

AGAA4 Tue 29-Jul-25 10:45:46

Thank you Maremia and apologies to Whitewave. Not sure how I missed that. It is good to see that Israelis are beginning to see and understand what this dreadful Netanyahu government is doing.

Smileless2012 Tue 29-Jul-25 10:47:04

Thank you for your post @ 9.12 WWM. As you've said Maremia, it's in line with what many of us have been saying for sometime here on GN, and coming from a source within Israel for me increases its validation.

I agree silverlining. Where there is conflict there are black markets especially when so much of the population is starving and if aid availability and distribution was at the level it should be, because Israel weren't using starvation as a weapon, this wouldn't be as advantageous to those responsible for the black market as it is.

Maremia Tue 29-Jul-25 10:48:16

What did you think of this particular report, Oreo? Anything in it you might agree with. I know you have concerns about events in the West Bank, because you have already said this in a post.

Oreo Tue 29-Jul-25 10:55:40

Yes I agree about the settler situation in the West Bank, the building and taking of land should be stopped.

AGAA4 Tue 29-Jul-25 10:55:47

There are black markets in most countries. If the fault lies with anyone it is with Israel for deliberately using starvation as a weapon of war.

Israel's aim is clear - to 'cleanse' Gaza of all Palestinians in whatever way they can.
Netanyahu is annoyed that other countries are interfering in their plans and tells lies that few believe.

AGAA4 Tue 29-Jul-25 10:59:10

Oreo

Yes I agree about the settler situation in the West Bank, the building and taking of land should be stopped.

So you feel that what is happening in the rest of Gaza is fine? The killing and starvation of those people doesn't bother you.

Oreo Tue 29-Jul-25 10:59:33

Where Action Palestine is concerned, posters need to be very careful on SM what they say, as like it or not they are deemed to be a terrorist group.
GN isn’t a private chat in Costa, it’s a public forum.