Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

Putting pedantry in its place

(20 Posts)
absent Tue 01-Oct-13 18:36:20

No point at all Bags. smile

Mamie Tue 01-Oct-13 17:33:16

But then, anno, those letters to The Times should be signed: Disgusted, of Tunbridge Wells.
Ennui means bored, Liz.
Pédante, Calvados.

Lona Tue 01-Oct-13 09:52:20

So simple anno smile

annodomini Tue 01-Oct-13 09:47:17

Bored, of Poynton.

feetlebaum Tue 01-Oct-13 09:22:53

My English master at school was co-author of our textbook, An English Grammar of Function. I hated it! But he told me that as I used the language well, I could write while the others were busily analyzing sentences into seven columns... He was a very gifted teacher, in my not so humble opinion!

LizG Tue 01-Oct-13 09:07:04

'Bored from Tunbridge Wells and what does ennui mean? Can't be bothered to find dictionary!

thatbags Tue 01-Oct-13 08:59:25

mamie grin wink No point sending a sense of humour alert to you, I suppose, absent? Have some wine instead smile

Greatnan Tue 01-Oct-13 06:37:21

I quite agree - most 'rules' of grammar are not set in stone.

Mamie Tue 01-Oct-13 06:34:41

Not that I mind a discussion of pedantry. Just an example. Must go and catch a boat.

Mamie Tue 01-Oct-13 06:21:27

Yes I know that absent. The article used "bored of TW" as the example and people were still objecting to it. Perhaps I should have written "a certain ennui with a discussion of pedantry" to make it clearer.

absent Tue 01-Oct-13 05:56:23

Mamie Don't be silly. The "of Tunbridge Wells" defines you, not your boredom. So you are a person in Tunbridge Wells who is bored by something, but not by the town in which you live.

Mamie Tue 01-Oct-13 05:54:09

I have to leave this lovely place to go back to France today, but I look forward to reading a spirited argument on the subject of why you can be Disgusted of Tunbridge Wells and not Bored of Tunbridge Wells, when I get home.
If you really want to be pedantic it should be Royal Tunbridge Wells.
grin

Mamie Tue 01-Oct-13 05:48:23

So if I were to be in Tunbridge Wells (which strangely enough I am) and if I were to feel a certain ennui (which I certainly do not), according to anno and phoenix, I still could not sign a letter to The Times, "Bored of Tunbridge Wells".
BTW TW is a fab place to hang out.

Anne58 Tue 01-Oct-13 00:44:01

BTW, Do you imagine your craw to be where the crop/croop would be on a chicken?

Anne58 Tue 01-Oct-13 00:42:58

"Bored of" should be made an offence the like of which deserves the sayer being put in the stocks!

As should "different to"

annodomini Mon 30-Sept-13 22:57:15

That's why I said I agreed with most of the article. 'Bored of' sticks in my craw!

Mishap Mon 30-Sept-13 22:29:57

I'm all for language developing - but sometimes I find it so hard to not to cringe at some things - especially bored of!! Don't know why it grates so much.

vampirequeen Mon 30-Sept-13 22:28:23

It's wonderful. I can now split my infinitives with gay abandon lol

feetlebaum Mon 30-Sept-13 22:15:38

"Break any of these rules sooner than say anything outright barbarous."
George Orwell

I'm certainly bored with people saying 'bored of'...

annodomini Mon 30-Sept-13 21:16:11

I have thoroughly enjoyed this article and fully agree with most of it.