Gransnet forums

Relationships

siblings falling out

(70 Posts)
eddiecat78 Fri 07-Jul-17 09:06:14

I don`t get on well with my brother. My DH has a very tricky relationship with his sister. Thinking about it I realised that almost all of my friends have difficulties with at least one of their siblings. And yet, we are all very upset and surprised when our own children fall out with each other.
Perhaps we should just accept this is what happens when people grow up?

vampirequeen Sat 08-Jul-17 19:17:06

My family have a tradition of the vultures arriving when someone dies who strip the house. The vultures may not have been that close to the deceased in life but they sure as hell know what they want after the death. So my mam has made a will that says my sister and I can only choose one thing each from the house then it will be closed up and everything will be sold and the money divided. The value of the item chosen will be taken into account when the money is divided.

She's also bought a prepaid funeral so that no one call tell us what she wanted because she's laid it all out.

Believe me with my family it's the best way.

eddiecat78 Sat 08-Jul-17 19:30:03

Watching "Long Lost Family" I often see people desperately searching for a missing sibling, or being delighted when they discover a sister/brother they didn`t know they had because "I always wanted a sister".
Being a pessimist/realist - I `d like to catch up with them a few years later and find out if things are working out as they expected!

Caro1954 Sat 08-Jul-17 20:30:26

My brother is eight years older than me and we haven't spoken for seventeen years, the day of my mother's funeral. I have no idea why. He has shown no interest in my children (one of whom is his godchild) or my grandchildren. He was a sad and bitter man before this so I can only think he is more sad and bitter now but I honestly hope he feels happier now than he would have to have had contact with his only sibling.

Sweetness1 Sat 08-Jul-17 20:51:27

The death of parents seem to be a common thread here for siblings to fall out. I've had similar experiencewhen our mum died. On the whole though have always got on with my 3 brothers and families when our children were growing up. Problem now seems as we have grandchildren and so busy there's no time to catch up with each other ...our own families come first so our sibling bond is disappearing!

marionk Sat 08-Jul-17 21:07:13

I was an only and witnessing the arguments and antagonism amongst my friends families I was always glad! The only time I wished for a sibling when my mother was suffering with dementia, but I recognise that this was a selfish desire on my part as I would rather have had someone to share the burden at that point.

Silversands Sat 08-Jul-17 21:26:39

Sorry Eddiecat and Bluebelle I probably didn`t put my point of view across correctly what I mean is many people appear not to be interested in keeping contact with their siblings, having the attitude "I don`t need them" not dreaming that one day they just might need them should a dire medical emergency occur and then they suddenly find the ability to `mend that fence` they had created, suddenly those unsurmountable relationship problems are not so unsurmountable afterall. A friend experienced just such a dilemma in her family .... there was so much regret at the wasted years but only AFTER the kidney was gifted, and so much guilt that it took a dire emergency for them both to see sense..... unfortunately too late for the elderly parents who died broken hearted.

trendygran Sat 08-Jul-17 21:31:40

Totally agree with you Tessa 101 .

trendygran Sat 08-Jul-17 21:32:33

Totally agree with you Tessa101.

gagsy Sat 08-Jul-17 22:57:57

My brother is 10 years younger than me which was a big difference when we were young but nothing now and we're very close. I like all my relatives so I am very lucky!

Chris4159 Sun 09-Jul-17 00:31:49

We are a family of 4 siblings 3 girls 1 boy. All got on great had fab times. Until he married to a woman that had no siblings and was extremley jealous of our relationships and laughs we had together. She told another family member she would put a stop to it. Finally got her way after 25 years. None of the family now have contact with our brother because of one very nasty bitter person.

Jangran99 Sun 09-Jul-17 08:22:33

I have 2 sisters and 3 brothers.Our youngest brother lives in California but we are all in regular contact, in fact his son is here at the moment with his own young family to see us all.We meet regularly in different combinations but have a pact to meet 4 times a year together to mark our beloved parents birthdays and the anniversaries of their deaths. This includes all our husbands/wives. Our children are friends too.This keeps our bonds strong and we know that this is what our dear parents would have wanted. I am not saying we never have differences- the Waltons we are not- but we value our family and have managed to overcome disagreements.I feel so sad for all who suffer the loss of this support through no fault of their own.

Kim19 Sun 09-Jul-17 08:59:42

As an 'only' who likes the idea of siblings, you ladies are causing me to have a re-think. However, fantasy anyway....... I do have a very happy and healthy relationship with my cousins so maybe this is compensatory.

pollyperkins Sun 09-Jul-17 20:04:11

I too have always got on well with my siblings, and all my 'children get on pretty well and are in regular contact with us and wih each other, more so since they all had children and the grandchildren love to see their cousins. Of course there are disagreements and gripes but never anything serious. We are very lucky I suppose!

maryhoffman37 Sun 09-Jul-17 20:49:44

How sad that so many of you don't get on with siblings! My oldest sister died when I was eight and two and a bit years ago my nest oldest had a devastating stroke, which has left her semi-paralysed, with vascular dementia and in a nursing home for the remainder of her life. I would give anything to have my sister back.

paddyann Sun 09-Jul-17 21:24:07

maryhoffman37 believe me its not MY choice ,my sister made the decision to cut herself off from her whole family ,and repeated attempts in the first few years were ignored.I lost my oldest sister just months after my dad died and it was very hard for my mum when her youngest stayed away .I dont know why she is the way she is ....I doubt I ever will.Sometimes you just have to let go and get on with your own life

vampirequeen Mon 10-Jul-17 07:54:13

It wasn't my choice. My sister decided for some reason to cut all contact. As she lives in Australia and I don't have her address or phone number the only way I can contact her is through email. I've tried many times but she ignores my emails.

Lewlew Mon 10-Jul-17 11:06:31

This was in yesterday's Sunday Express magazine (yes I know it's the Express... it's my Sunday 'comic')

www.express.co.uk/life-style/life/826688/How-to-avoid-sibling-war

Older and wiser? Tips to avoid sibling war

CARING for elderly parents when illness strikes can create friction between brothers and sisters. Our writer finds out how sibling war can be avoided.

eddiecat78 Mon 10-Jul-17 11:38:13

Re the article - the friction that has arisen between me and my brother since our father became frail is not because brother disagrees about what should happen to father - it is because brother has pretty well opted out of doing anything to help and appears to be totally uncaring about the level of stress it is placing on me and my husband (despite knowing that I am not in great health myself)

Aslemma Tue 11-Jul-17 14:07:35

My sister and I are both adopted and she is the younger by 13 years. I am sure we are both fond of one another and keep in touch with occasional phone calls but we are very different and live entirely different lives, though we do meet up occasionally, especially when my eldest son gives a party.

I am lucky enough to have 4 sons and a daughter, all of whom live fairly close and get on well, apart from the odd niggle. One of my sons had a wife with different ideas and resented her husband spending time with his family but they divorced some years ago and he is now with a lovely lady. As I 've got older, with a few health problems it has been lovely that it hasn't been left to just one to help out when there has been a problem, which was the situation I was in with my parents in their last few years.