Gransnet forums

Religion/spirituality

Do you really believe in horoscopes?

(30 Posts)
Greatnan Tue 20-Mar-12 11:04:27

Apparently, 25% of Britons believe their future is in the stars! What a load of codswallop. Of course, by the law of probability they will sometimes make an accurate forecast, but they are usually so vague that they are meaningless.

nanapug Tue 20-Mar-12 11:07:06

I do when they are good, but think its rubbish when I don't like what they say ;)

greenmossgiel Tue 20-Mar-12 11:14:01

No, I don't believe in them. It put me off when a young friend who had started to work for a local newspaper, had been given the job of inventing/writing the horoscopes each week! hmm

Annika Tue 20-Mar-12 11:25:25

No not at all.
The law of averages will mean that some one on here today will have a correct reading but that would just be a lucky guess. If the future could be seen in the stars all readings in newspapers/ magazines/ on line etc etc would be more or less the same. Also why on earth afer all this time hasn't goverment put such things to the greater good, why waste such power as that.
Its all a load of codswallop.

Carol Tue 20-Mar-12 11:26:43

No - it's a load of old codswallop, but then a Gemini would say that (the old ones are always the best!) grin

Elegran Tue 20-Mar-12 11:29:30

Statistically one in twelve of the population can probably expect this week to have a wonderful day, meet the man of their dreams, have sudden good fortune, encounter problems at work, or hear bad news.

If they also read someone's prediction that one of these things is going to happen, and then it does some of them are going to believe that there is something magical going on. Most people are not so credulous.

Annika Tue 20-Mar-12 11:29:50

Carolgrin

Annika Tue 20-Mar-12 11:30:59

Elegran Thats got it all covered then grin

Annobel Tue 20-Mar-12 11:44:28

Given that the stars in the constellations are hundreds of thousands of light years away from each other and from our solar system, and at the present time they're not even where we now see them, how could they possibly have any influence on anything happening here on this planet?

jeni Tue 20-Mar-12 12:32:39

No way. I am supposed to be a sagittarian which is I believe a fire sign! In fact I am gentle, quiet, retiring, tranquil and shy!

Lastsongster Tue 20-Mar-12 12:39:34

Yeas ago I was a sub-editor of a magazine. The celebrity astrologer lived in the South of France and sent in three month batches of horoscopes at a time. Early on I realised that I had got the sequence wrong. In trepidation I phoned him to let him know, and apologised profusely. "Dear boy," he replied, "don't worry about it, it's a load of twaddle anyway, put it in whatever order you want."

Elegran Tue 20-Mar-12 12:42:59

Pretty unanimous so far.

Annobel Tue 20-Mar-12 13:11:43

Just for fun, I've looked at the Wiki description of the Scorpio character. grin If it were correct, I should have been, at the very least, prime minister or even a dictator!

Greatnan Tue 20-Mar-12 13:19:25

They sometimes get it right though - I am a Libran, calm, peace-loving, generous - altogether a very wonderful person. smile

Elegran Tue 20-Mar-12 14:36:45

We are all wonderful people. They can't go wrong on that.

Annika Tue 20-Mar-12 14:56:38

Greatnan I have been called many things but calm ? no never and I am a Libran (I think).
Jasper Carrott spoke of horoscopes many years ago he said when asked what sign he was he said... hump back bridge ! grin

Greatnan Tue 20-Mar-12 16:15:08

Apparently (according to one site on google) we are the most civilised sign, good looking, exhibiting taste, charm and elegance, and with a strong , analytical mind. That will do me for starters!

feetlebaum Fri 23-Mar-12 16:57:36

Billy Connolly said his sign was Pyrex - he was a test-tube baby!

Annika Fri 23-Mar-12 17:56:22

feetlebaum grin

goldengirl Sat 24-Mar-12 15:40:28

No I don't believe in them - but I still read 'em from time to time; just in case...... grin. I'm a Virgo: pernickety and a pain in the proverbial gringrin

granbunny Sat 31-Mar-12 23:18:54

no, i don't.

i worked for a local paper. we bought ours in from a supplier and printed them randomly. no meaning at all.

admittedly, it was some time ago.

Joan Sun 01-Apr-12 07:51:14

Of course not, but they are just a bit of fun.

feetlebaum Sun 01-Apr-12 13:15:38

The only horoscopes I ever read are those in The Onion -always worth a look!

Aries Mar 21 - Apr 19
One man truly can make a difference, assuming he's willing to drive a loaded schoolbus into the base of a dam.

Anagram Fri 06-Apr-12 23:09:48

Not horoscope-related really, but I've just realised it's a full moon tonight. Could that be why some of us (including me!) are a bit tetchy?

Bronte Sat 21-Apr-12 00:33:13

No, I don’t.

Your future isn’t in the stars - it’s in your head!