Gransnet forums

Religion/spirituality

If you want to ask a question

(272 Posts)
soontobe Sat 10-Jan-15 18:32:19

A thread if you want to ask me a question about christianity. Mine, or in general.

I am getting asked questions about my christianity across different threads.

So if you want to ask me a question, ask here.

If no one does, fine. Great.
But if you do in future, I suspect that gransnet would like it dealt with here rather than questions popping up on other peoples' threads, for the forseeable.
Thanks.

Ana Mon 12-Jan-15 16:36:16

Do you really think that each soul is allocated a mansion of its own in the afterlife, soontobe? Wouldn't that be a bit lonely? I'd have thought they'd have to share.

Lilygran Mon 12-Jan-15 16:28:14

The interpretation I accept is a truth in which I believe.

Eloethan Mon 12-Jan-15 14:47:34

Lilygran Are you saying that the writings regarding such things as creation of the universe, immaculate conception, original sin, Garden of Eden, etc., were used to symbolise things that were difficult to explain and are not to be taken literally? If so, surely there can be many interpretations of these writings and whatever interpretation you accept is a "belief" rather than a "fact"?

jinglbellsfrocks Mon 12-Jan-15 14:40:09

Thank you. smile

soontobe Mon 12-Jan-15 14:35:31

I like your posts jingl.

soontobe Mon 12-Jan-15 14:34:05

God in the OT certainly had a lot of rules. Something like 617 of them?!

Jesus is His son.
Yes, we are children of God. Jesus is the firstborn I think I am right in saying. We are brothers and sisters.

As regards different intreptations, my advice is the NRSV Bible [the one most used in church services], or the King James [personally can barely understand all the olde worlde language, but some people love it], or the Good News Bible is the easiest to understand.

jinglbellsfrocks Mon 12-Jan-15 14:33:10

The Ten Commandments of the Old Testament are pretty good rules for living. To be honest.

jinglbellsfrocks Mon 12-Jan-15 14:31:24

His son was God come to earth as a man. To reassure us. God is spirit. His spirit was in Jesus Christ. The three in one - God the Father,, God the Son and God the Holy Ghost. They are all one. And perhaps a small part of the whole is in every one of us.

Mishap Mon 12-Jan-15 14:25:21

God in the OT was a pretty grim proposition. No wonder they disobeyed.

So he sent his son - who is his son? - how does he come to be so? - most religions say we are all the children of god.

The idea that the world was saved by the arrival of his son rings pretty hollow in this troubled world. Folks are still struggling to understand the meaning of life and their different interpretations are proving somewhat problematical and divisive.

soontobe Mon 12-Jan-15 14:14:30

Sorry. Having a "busy" day today. Didnt mean to abandon this thread.

I have been thinking about souls and mansions jingl.
It too strikes me as odd that a soul is going to need a mansion.
I imagine a soul as something the size of say a pea.

Mishap - I think God tried not to be opaque in the Old Testament. But that didnt work, as in, people just ended up disobeying Him on such a large scale to the extent that there was barely a person left that was not doing evil.
So he had to send His son.
Which has worked better as there are people who worship up to now at least.

God lit the paper for the Big Bang grumppa, though I think that you would expect me to say that!

feetlebaum Mon 12-Jan-15 13:37:54

" The more scientists uncover, by trying to explain the inexplicable, the more the innate order of the universe appears." So, therefore God?

Hardly!

Gerente Mon 12-Jan-15 12:56:02

I’m sorry Lily but that’s not quite true. In quantum mechanics we discover that the entire universe is actually a series of probabilities. Physics advances by accepting absurdities. That the sun is the centre of our universe surprised everybody back then. Quantum mechanics finds that particles can be in two places at once.

Lilygran Mon 12-Jan-15 11:48:57

Some doctrines like predestination, original sin and the Immaculate Conception which some posters have problems with, arise from people at different times trying to understand concepts beyond understanding or beyond the understanding of people at the time they were developed. Trying to explain the inexplicable. And of course you can 'believe' facts. Not all facts are concrete and others we accept because they make sense, or appear to be true. And yes, who did light the touch paper for the Big Bang? The more scientists uncover, by trying to explain the inexplicable, the more the innate order of the universe appears.

rosequartz Mon 12-Jan-15 11:38:54

Arise and go forth! smile

Perhaps God is within us (and Satan)
We needn't look too far
God = good
Devil = evil

Are the words similar in other languages?

jinglbellsfrocks Mon 12-Jan-15 11:04:05

Oh! Lol! grin

I'm out of bed anyway. grin

Ana Mon 12-Jan-15 10:57:23

Well, you didn't say it was your son...smile

jinglbellsfrocks Mon 12-Jan-15 10:55:04

No! He's not my son. confused

Ana Mon 12-Jan-15 10:53:10

You mean Jesus? confused

jinglbellsfrocks Mon 12-Jan-15 10:37:42

But son has told me to embrace staying in bed. Who to listen to? More anguished self searching.

jinglbellsfrocks Mon 12-Jan-15 10:36:34

He is telling me to get up and stop being so bloody lazy.

jinglbellsfrocks Mon 12-Jan-15 10:35:55

He would be seen as a dictator. I don't think God uses a human voice. He has no human form. He is spirit. Speaks to us through our spirit.

Mishap Mon 12-Jan-15 10:25:41

It intrigues me that believers are not puzzled why god has made him/herself so totally opaque that all these centuries of earnest discussion and study needs to take place to understand him/her. What motive might god have to make this as difficult as possible? - seems a bit perverse to me.

Why not "Hello, here I am; this is what you are here for; this is what I require of you." - and the same message all round the universe.

rosequartz Mon 12-Jan-15 10:07:11

Perhaps the Three Kings were Buddhists? They came from the east.

People travelled more than we think.

absent it is a laudable aim.

absent Sun 11-Jan-15 23:44:28

Nelliemoser What an interesting thought but would a fairly primitive society in a small Roman province in the Middle East have access to the ideas of Buddhism a couple of thousand years ago?

Nelliemoser Sun 11-Jan-15 23:38:16

Jingle and anyone else.
This conversation now sounds like a debate about how many angels can sit on the head of a pin.

It generates more heat than light!

You can take the stories in the New Testament as a standard way of teaching ideas and it has some good ethical values which owes quite bit to the ideas of Buddhism. You can choose to think this man was a wise teacher or a divine incarnation.

The old testament is part a catalogue of Jewish history and a group of people trying to get some organisation and basic rules for an ethnic group beset by aggression from other tribes wanting the most fertile bits of land which happened to be the valley of river Jordan.