In Memoriam thread - would it work?

ixion

Thank you all, and to Doodle for summarising so well.

I think that if I woke up to one of those 'significant days' and wanted to share, I wouldn't think to go to 'Bereavement', rather a mention in the equivalent of Mick's Good morning thread.
I will report this back to HQ and see if tbere is any movement to be had.

... late to the party, as usual.

Another 'yes' from me.

Thank you all, and to Doodle for summarising so well.

I think that if I woke up to one of those 'significant days' and wanted to share, I wouldn't think to go to 'Bereavement', rather a mention in the equivalent of Mick's Good morning thread.
I will report this back to HQ and see if tbere is any movement to be had.

Totally Yes. Sometimes it would be to remember someone that some of us know, sometimes just a personal remembrance. I totally agree the bereavement thread is not the place for this.

Great for those that it pleases but not for me.l

I think it’s a good idea too I miss Rufus s silly old fashioned sense of humour I think he may well have passed away he was very elderly and had had a few falls and lots of hospital visits
Quite a character

Yes

Yes.

Yes!

I'll give it one more try first, Doodle.
I guess it's not just me who thinks a dedicated Forum is the answer.

If you look at the debate over the Benefits forum, with its final decision to 'tuck' (being polite here) it in to Legal, Money etc Forum, the arguments for this proposed Forum are very similar, as is the decision now to put it in Bereavement.

You wake up in the morning knowing that it is, for you, a special day. It would be great to see a place where you can just pop in a one line post, remembering and sharing the loved one you have lost. Then move on...

What you don't want, in my opinion, is to search within a Bereavement thread, where it seems a lot of ongoing support is given and friendships develop over, possibly, a long time. As happens on the other threads here, fair enough.

I saw this idea as one where you just post a message saying 'today 30 years ago, I lost my lovely mum' . Not necessarily opening up an ongoing conversation over a period of time.

Like an In Memoriam book, where people can leave a little message and feel better for it.

Yes?

I remember Grandmajet too Blossoming . Someone with a really lovely sense of humour despite what she was going through.
How about it Ixion. If GNHQ won’t play ball and start a forum why don’t you start the thread and see how it goes from there. Many people agree with you.

I think this is a lovely idea. Happily I missed the controversial posts on the Phoenix thread, like many I enjoyed her humour and miss her contributions. I know we are not supposed to speculate about previous posters, and this is probably not the place, but I often wonder about GillyBob. We often compared notes on running a small business, I hope they survived the covid lockdowns.

But, back to the original tread; yes a good and kind idea, thank you Ixion

I like this idea. It would have been my beautiful Aunt’s birthday this week and I wept at the birthday cards in the local shop. I so missed buying her one, sending a quirky gift and phoning her. Lots of funny stories about her I thought about.
YES please.

I think it’s highly likely that Rufus is no longer with us BarmeyOldBat. He was in his 90s and in poor health. A definite one off character

Grandmajet is another I remember with fondness, a very brave lady.

I think it’s a great idea, I often wonder about an older man who use to come on here, think he was out in Australia, his remarks really made me laugh. Also having lost my daughter this year I am aware that on her 50th birthday in Oct I shall be emotional and it would be helpful to post something.

I feel at times I am classed as being in a clique, especially with Phoenix. I "knew" her for around 11 years frequently emailing but we never met.

I meet up with 3 GNs monthly for coffee and have done for 5 years. I also meet up with another larger group for coffee frequently until Covid intervened.

I email another GN very frequently so am I in a variety of cliques because I know these people quite well?

Already I am thinking about what will happen to the Phoenix thread on the anniversary of her death. The actions of some people were appalling and totally unnecessary.

It’s a good idea
Like some other posters, I thought about Greatnan, Phoenix and jingles when I read this suggestion. Three posters with quite different styles of posting, each contributed so much to gransnet

Thank you dustyangel.

Yes Greenfinch they are. When I think of the things I complain about, I should be ashamed.

Kate thanks for reminding us of willsandco. I have just done a search of the threads she was on and re read her comments. They are beautiful and truly inspirational. Well worth following up.

* posters who have common experiences or had close connections with other posters are not a clique.
The word is being freely bandied around as an insult*

So true Callistemon.

It’s funny that posters often say they are off out for lunch with their group of friends…so are they in a clique?!

I think the bereavement board is sufficient for general support on the loss of loved ones.
By definition - remembering loved ones can only be done by those who actually knew & remember the deceased.
Remembering, & wanting to talk about past gransnet members is different. Many people will remember the ‘online persona’, which could of course be very different to their real life personality. Plus people come & go all the time on here, so remembering past members ( as time goes on ) will only ever have meaning to a few.

As for cliques - not bothered at all.
People who spend a lot of time on here will make more connections than those of us who post less. There’s a few regular threads on here that will attract the same people everyday & that’s fine. I’m not interested in getting too familiar with anyone on here ( or anywhere online ) but I’m sure these friendship groups ( better than saying ‘cliques’ ) offer so much to many.

Ana was another very funny person ?

MayBee70

I wish I knew what had happened to Ana. She just disappeared. Unlike jingle there was never any sort of update about her.

I miss Ana but I wonder if she was not very well, not sure.

I often wonder about trisher. I crossed swords with her a few times but would like to know she’s ok. It’s a shame that a thread asking about a poster isn’t usually allowed.