Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

Is Naga Munchetty a TV turn off?

(89 Posts)
Sarnia Sat 20-Mar-21 12:12:06

I am finding Naga Munchetty increasingly rude. She asks a guest a question then doesn't always have the manners to allow them to reply. She butts in or shouts over them. Her comments and tone of voice are often patronising. Her latest performance was to poke fun at Robert Jenrick's Union Jack flag and the photograph of our Queen. She even went the extra mile by liking tweets about it. Her lukewarm 'apology' is clearly not made from her own conscience but from a ticking off she has received from her bosses.

Firecracker123 Sat 20-Mar-21 13:21:37

12:30Galaxy

People should be able to mock anything. The queen anything, I dont want to live in a country that doesnt have that freedom. It's actually part of what I love about this country.

The BBC (Britain Broadcasting Company) is supposed to be impartial and so are its presenters.

You as an individual can mock all you like within reason but more is expected from the BBC and public figures.

Alegrias1 Sat 20-Mar-21 13:24:54

Pantglas2

I hope all who mock the displays of flags in people’s homes don’t visit Spain, you’ll all be pearl clutching and having attacks of the vapours!

I can’t think of any property in the Andalusian town where mi Casa is situated that doesn’t have the ??Spanish flag up, including mine (along with ??????? of course!)

I visit Spain a lot. Or used to sad I know they have the flag everywhere. But not on 9 foot flagpoles in their living rooms, co-incidentally next to a picture of their King. grin

Oldwoman70 Sat 20-Mar-21 13:31:15

Ilovecheese

It was the male presenter who made the joke, and the huge flags do look silly. No one said anything about the photo of the Queen.

She actually mockingly said "and he has a picture of the Queen".

The only people bringing her ethnicity into the argument are those defending her actions. The complaints against her, and her fellow presenter, have been about the comments made

Galaxy Sat 20-Mar-21 13:38:50

The BBC presents endless coverage in favour of the queen. It is fine to mock the queen whether you are public figure are not. Trying to control others language and the tweets they like is about as unpatriotic as it gets.

Namsnanny Sat 20-Mar-21 13:39:41

I dont think the French or Americans mind showing allegiance to their respective flags.
The fact that it can be used as a source of derision in this country is the nub I think.

TV presenters and the like should be more professional and keep their views to themselves when doing their job.
Outside of that they can hold whatever views they wish, just as the rest of us do.

She's probably grandstanding to get her more publicity, and it's worked!

Casdon Sat 20-Mar-21 13:41:58

The Huw Edwards flag was to support Wales in the rugby today, nothing to do with him being a white, or interrupting, shouty man (he’s always courteous). The English including the BBC hierarchy are very miffed about Wales beating them, how dare they!
On the subject of news people though, my absolute favourite is George Alagiah, he’s so unbiased in the way he presents, and I love the way he smiles at you/the camera after the broadcast and says and Now for the news where YOU are - is that just me?

Smileless2012 Sat 20-Mar-21 13:44:41

It was sometime ago and I don't remember who she was interviewing but she spoke over him saying "I don't mean to interrupt" so he responded with "well don't then"grin

Namsnanny Sat 20-Mar-21 13:45:49

Oooo pantglas2!!! Andalucia....one of my favourite places in the world. smile

Galaxy Sat 20-Mar-21 13:46:15

I have come to the view that no public figure, should be sacked or reprimanded for a comment they make (obviously incitment to violence and criminal offences not included), the path this leads you down has been proved time and time again to be dangerous. This includes Naga and Piers Morgan, it applies to everyone whatever their political persuasion. Noone should be given the power to decide what words are acceptable.

Rosalyn69 Sat 20-Mar-21 13:46:26

Charlie made the deadpan comment. I thought it was hilarious. I like Naga. Her and Charlie are good together.
I do find the flag in the corner quite ridiculous. It’s not mocking the flag it’s mocking the people who have it on display so ostentatiously.

Deedaa Sat 20-Mar-21 13:52:33

I love Naga in spite of her playing golf! She is clever and funny and wears wonderful clothes - and she has two siamese cats.
I watched Saturday Kitchen (which has got very boring) precisely because she and Charlie were on. I thought it would be fun, and it was. Matt gave as good as he got, what's not to like?
As for this idea that Tory MPs must always appear with at least one large flag!!! What sort of banana republic are we becoming? The last person to have a picture of the Queen on his wall was Alf Garnett. That bodes well for the future. How long before our children are being taught to pledge allegiance to the flag?

tickingbird Sat 20-Mar-21 14:06:19

Galaxy
People should be able to mock anything.

So it was ok for Donald Trump to mock the disabled reporter then?

Grandma70s Sat 20-Mar-21 14:09:39

I dislike the display of flags, and the American way of pledging allegiance to the flag (I’m not sure exactly what they do) in schools makes me really queasy. Nationalism is such a potentially dangerous sentiment.

I always enjoy Charlie Stayt and Naga..

suziewoozie Sat 20-Mar-21 14:09:51

Casdon

The Huw Edwards flag was to support Wales in the rugby today, nothing to do with him being a white, or interrupting, shouty man (he’s always courteous). The English including the BBC hierarchy are very miffed about Wales beating them, how dare they!
On the subject of news people though, my absolute favourite is George Alagiah, he’s so unbiased in the way he presents, and I love the way he smiles at you/the camera after the broadcast and says and Now for the news where YOU are - is that just me?

I didn’t say he was shouty. And I think his Welsh flag was making a point re Naga- his second tweet with the BBC flag was very witty. He’s got form (good on him) for poking fun at BBC management ( or as it’s better known now, the field office of Conservative HQ).

suziewoozie Sat 20-Mar-21 14:10:22

tickingbird

Galaxy
People should be able to mock anything.

So it was ok for Donald Trump to mock the disabled reporter then?

Is that a fair comparison ?

Katie59 Sat 20-Mar-21 14:14:21

The BBC equivalent of Piers Morgan, not my favorite presenter.

Galaxy Sat 20-Mar-21 14:15:06

It doesnt matter suzie it's a fair question. And I am coming to the conclusion that controlling language is more dangerous than things that might happen if we dont control it.

Kamiso Sat 20-Mar-21 14:15:12

Riverwalk

All these politicians with a flag in the corner remind me of those who wear a Remembrance Day poppy way ahead of time.

What's it called - virtue signalling?

Pillocks.

I’ll have to remember to check in with you to find out when you will allow me to wear the poppy that I paid for!

suziewoozie Sat 20-Mar-21 14:24:13

Galaxy

It doesnt matter suzie it's a fair question. And I am coming to the conclusion that controlling language is more dangerous than things that might happen if we dont control it.

Hummm that’s a jump I feel from mocking an individual who through no choice of their own has a disadvantage to mocking a group of (supposedly) grown up men and women who have chosen to put a flag ( picture of the Queen whatever) in the corner of their living room for political reasons. Being mocked for your disability ( as I have been ) can be very damaging and bears no comparison in terms of freedom of speech when mocking someone’s political views or actions which are freely chosen.

SueDonim Sat 20-Mar-21 14:25:58

The BBC (Britain Broadcasting Company) is supposed to be impartial and so are its presenters.

There’s not much impartiality going on in the Scottish Covid Briefings, which are being used to talk about the Sturgeon/Salmond business. Just because a reporter asks a question about it doesn’t mean the person leading the briefing has to answer. They should be replying ‘I’m here to talk about Covid and nothing else. Next question, please.

Pantglas2 Sat 20-Mar-21 14:26:56

Is it an upbringing thing? My mam would’ve slapped me if I’d commented on either!

Moogalmum Sat 20-Mar-21 14:28:51

Love Naga Intellegent classy lady.

Namsnanny Sat 20-Mar-21 14:34:11

I disagree

Bridgeit Sat 20-Mar-21 14:41:38

Nooooo it’s just because they haven’t decorated their rooms recently & they don’t want to us to see that........quick resolution display our Flag, phew saved by Rule Britannia ?

Kandinsky Sat 20-Mar-21 14:43:32

I can’t stand her.