I have read all of the books, and love them. The TV series is significantly different - even from the beginning, but especially now. I knew an 'activist vicar' from that era quite well, and am sure that the events in the books are based on Robert & Rosalind Runcie's life in those times.
They are less good on detection, much better on characters and stories, but well worth searching out.
I find the TV series a bit irritating with storylines rather shoe-horned in, and why on earth are a clergyman, detective and secretary doing a post-mortem? Can't they afford an actor to play a pathologist?
But there is some excellent period atmosphere, and they do touch on issues current at the time, which are not always remembered. I rather think someone has been leafing through old women's magazines!
I don't want to spoil the books by disclosing too much, but Sidney follows a different personal path than in the TV series.
Gransnet forums
TV, radio, film, Arts
Join the conversation
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join the discussion, watch threads and lots more.
Register now »Already registered? Log in with:
Gransnet »




