Jimmy Carr. Loathsome A***

I can’t see anything educational about it. It is in extremely poor taste and obviously offensive. I appreciate that humour is a personal thing, but I can’t understand why anyone would find his ‘joke’ funny. There is no wit involved at all.

I honestly don’t think that I’ve despised a person more.
He has such a high opinion of himself.
James O’Brien recently did a podcast interview with him.
I hope that he has removed it.

In the days when I was much younger and physically able I visited a joke club in London where most of the artists have since become very famous. Unfortunately I was so embarrassed and seriously offended by some of their humour which I didn’t in the least find humorous and I had no idea why the majority were laughing I suppose it takes all sorts that was the first and last time I visited any other clubs of this sort and said never again

He reckons that the other victims of the Holocaust aren’t taught about in schools.
Which is out and out bull**
They absolutely are.
But he seems to think that he is an expert on all manner of stuff

I’ve been to loads of comedy clubs, especially due to a sort of friend who is now famous, being the compère.
I have never heard anything so disgusting.
He seems to think that it’s acceptable because he is high-minded.
If Jim Davidson had said it, well, can you imagine

He would have done better if he had tried to defend himself by claiming that his ‘joke’ demonstrated how widespread and still tolerated anti-GRT prejudice really is.

I heard want he said and what stuck out to me was when he said holocaust the audience started laughing even before he told his "Joke" why was that funny. Awful man awful audience.

Dreadful man, he’s always been nasty. Surely there must be a law about inciting hate somewhere, that could prevent him spouting this. What sort of audience goes to see such a man?

I simply don’t and have never appreciated so called “dark humour”.

He gives me the creeps.

Good point Allsorts
He’s certainly inciting hate in me

Could it be taken as a way of raising awareness of prejudice against Gypsy, Roma, and Traveller people? Having read his trigger warning before the show, I suspect that might have been his intention.

I agree what he said was shocking but that, surely, is the point – get it out there; make people think about this.

I'm not sure hating him and wishing him ill is any better than the hate he's accused of. Yes, be outraged, but focus the outrage on how GRT people are often portrayed. Before farming began we were all travellers, roamers, shifting hunter-gatherers.

Baggs

Could it be taken as a way of raising awareness of prejudice against Gypsy, Roma, and Traveller people? Having read his trigger warning before the show, I suspect that might have been his intention.

I agree what he said was shocking but that, surely, is the point – get it out there; make people think about this.

I'm not sure hating him and wishing him ill is any better than the hate he's accused of. Yes, be outraged, but focus the outrage on how GRT people are often portrayed. Before farming began we were all travellers, roamers, shifting hunter-gatherers.

Yes that is exactly what “dark humour” is supposed to do, but I honestly think that regardless of what he says it isn’t educational. You need a certain level of education to appreciate his humour.

The Roma are the most persecuted people on Earth.
They had to travel as they were driven out.
I feel more than ‘outraged’ Baggs. It’s ridiculous to say that he is ‘raising awareness’.
He said that their death at the hands of the Nazis was ‘a positive’ of The Holocaust.
That is literally what he said.

I don’t think it’s a lack of education that stops me from appreciating that ‘joke’.

Hes not raising awareness that's his get out of jail free card bless him. I dont think he should be banned though, I don't trust anyone to make that judgement.

You need a certain level of education to appreciate his humour well on this occasion I'll be happy to regard myself as uneducated.

It wasn't even humour, it was plain prejudiced and nasty

I wrote a dissertation about the Roma and the historical reasons behind their educational underachievement.
I don’t think that my knowledge is at fault here either.
I think that I could teach Carr a thing or two.
He’s just an arrogant posh boy being a racist bastard.

Perhaps this man from an Irish Traveller family could have a word with Carr?
Perhaps he isn’t educated enough either to ‘get it’

(A joke. Sort of)

FannyCornforth

The Roma are the most persecuted people on Earth.
They had to travel as they were driven out.
I feel more than ‘outraged’ Baggs. It’s ridiculous to say that he is ‘raising awareness’.
He said that their death at the hands of the Nazis was ‘a positive’ of The Holocaust.
That is literally what he said.

I’m totally with you FannyC

Carr has been telling jokes about raping women for years, if I remember rightly there were a few about murdering women as well. I am not sure how anyone is surprised by this. Hes shown who he is for years.

Very well said FannyC I couldn't agree more

To be honest up until now I’ve always avoided him as I have never liked him, so I don’t really know what he has said in the past.
I always had an inkling that he was getting away with stuff because he is perceived as being clever.
There’s a lot of it about with those posh boys, eh Galaxy

I can see where he's coming from in a way.

There's a certain hypocrisy with those that shed tears about the Holocaust but would happily see Roma people banished from the UK, particularly if they were migrants from the EU.

Aren't we all a teensy weensy bit irritated, to say the least, with Travellers in the UK who often seem to be a law unto themselves with their illegal camps and not properly educating their children.

I think maybe Carr hit a raw nerve.