Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

Ch 4 Game of Wool. Britain’s Best Knitter

(211 Posts)
Primrose53 Mon 03-Nov-25 11:07:21

Anybody see this last night?

I watched and although it was good to see something other than detective thrillers or reality programmes, I was rather disappointed.

I know some fantastic knitters and a couple of knitwear designers yet two tired looking elderly ladies were judges! Never heard of either of them and their comments were most odd.

The contestants seemed a nice crowd and clearly quite talented. Their first challenge was to knit a fair isle Tank Top in chunky yarn. Some really good designs and colour choices but a couple of people needed a bit longer to complete.

The second challenge was, as a group, to cover a sofa in knitting which should have the “wow factor”. Sadly that went down like a lead balloon. One group managed it but it was very dull. The other group’s effort was a disaster and looked an absolute mess. The two old dolls didn’t know what to say about that one. đŸ€ŁđŸ€Ł

Tom Daley as presenter was OK but draped in an assortment of multi coloured knitted adornments and a white skirt or kilt looked bizarre but that was probably the aim.

There was a very nice young woman in a pale green top who won Top Knitter last night and I predict she will win the contest eventually. Very talented and very modest. 👍

Pleasebenice Mon 15-Dec-25 07:20:13

I think this lacked a strong anchor. A skilled presented might have gently mocked the silliness of this and made it watchable.

J52 Mon 15-Dec-25 07:43:08

Holgar’s bag was attractive, but he lined it with fabric so of course it wouldn’t sag. The weight was held by the fabric.
Poor Isaac, he really wasn’t a time keeper.

Sarnia Mon 15-Dec-25 09:07:07

No complaints about Isaac going.
The best 3 knitters in the final and I don't mind who wins. If this programme gets a second series it needs a drastic overhaul on presenter and knitting challenges.

NotSpaghetti Mon 15-Dec-25 09:23:13

Why is anyone bothered about what the knit designers look like?
It makes no sense!

Allira Mon 15-Dec-25 10:13:20

NotSpaghetti

Why is anyone bothered about what the knit designers look like?
It makes no sense!

Because they are supposed to inspire us, not put us off 😀

Nothing they have worn so far has inspired me to take up my knitting needles again.

As for that one's hair - beyond words 😂

NotSpaghetti Mon 15-Dec-25 10:55:21

My point is that they are actually (I assumed) there for their design skill - not their looks, grooming or clothes choices.

Allira Mon 15-Dec-25 11:01:37

NotSpaghetti

My point is that they are actually (I assumed) there for their design skill - not their looks, grooming or clothes choices.

But surely people with design skill should display that in the clothes they themselves wear?

They need some lessons in blocking, for a start.

Millie22 Mon 15-Dec-25 12:13:48

I have been watching some old Kirstie Christmas programmes and last week one was the Christmas jumper challenge.

The judge was called Erica Knight. I think that was her name. She was brilliant and inspiring. A total contrast to the two sloppy dishevelled women on this programme.

Primrose53 Sun 21-Dec-25 21:21:59

Well that’s it! Not sure if there will be another series.

All 3 hats were really good but, as usual the judges just had to pick faults with them.

Sarnia Sun 21-Dec-25 22:50:46

Lydia's figure of Di made me laugh. Spot on, especially the hair and 'washing line' adornment she sported recently. Looked like Di had a pink ring doughnut on her head tonight. Either that or she is in the process of making a large pompom and stuck it on her head until she has time to finish it.
Worthy winner. Consistently good every week.