Gransnet forums

TV, radio, film, Arts

70 Up

(84 Posts)
silverlining48 Sun 13-Sept-26 11:48:02

In case anyone has followed this interesting documentary over the years, or is interested, the final programme will be ITV this Tuesday evening.

Sago Fri 16-Oct-26 08:41:01

We have just finished 49, we will save the rest for next week as we have a friend staying this weekend.

I am just loving Bruce and his family, how kind it was of him to help Neil.

Lynn Johnson was an impressive woman, she was such a dedicated librarian and school governor, for a girl who wanted to work in Woolworths she did very well!
She died far too young but certainly left an impression.

Sarnia Fri 16-Oct-26 07:44:10

Sago

I am a bit late to the party on this but I have started watching from the beginning.
We are currently half way through 35.

It is such an incredible documentary, I would love to know if any of the participants feel that taking part has had any influence on their lives.

I loved Paul’s thoughtful little face when asked anything and his concern for a future wife making him eat his greens.

The scene from Bruce’s prep school, as the boys are doing their morning exercises brought a lump to my husbands throat, he is the same age and was away at a rather brutal prep school from 7 and had a similar regime supervised by an older pupil (usually a bully).

Of all the children shown I think Bruce is the one who fits the adage the best.

So far I would agree to a large extent that St Iganatius Loyola was right when he said show me the child at 7.
Our sons had a Jesuit education and our eldest says the actual phrase was a rather more sinister “give me the boy at 7 and he is mine for life”

I am so looking forward to the rest of the story.

I felt the need to start at the beginning too.

You will eventually find out what they thought about being a part of this programme.

It made me sad at times, to see how life had panned out for some of them but there were plenty of laughs too.

The 3 little lads, Charles, Andrew and John at a posh prep school had me in fits when they were discussing newspapers.
Andrew read the Financial Times because he had shares in it, at the age of 7! The East End children would have thought themselves lucky to have a second hand Beano.

A very interesting longitudinal study. Enjoy the rest of it and keep some tissues handy.

Sago Thu 15-Oct-26 13:44:16

I am a bit late to the party on this but I have started watching from the beginning.
We are currently half way through 35.

It is such an incredible documentary, I would love to know if any of the participants feel that taking part has had any influence on their lives.

I loved Paul’s thoughtful little face when asked anything and his concern for a future wife making him eat his greens.

The scene from Bruce’s prep school, as the boys are doing their morning exercises brought a lump to my husbands throat, he is the same age and was away at a rather brutal prep school from 7 and had a similar regime supervised by an older pupil (usually a bully).

Of all the children shown I think Bruce is the one who fits the adage the best.

So far I would agree to a large extent that St Iganatius Loyola was right when he said show me the child at 7.
Our sons had a Jesuit education and our eldest says the actual phrase was a rather more sinister “give me the boy at 7 and he is mine for life”

I am so looking forward to the rest of the story.

Curlywhirly Thu 24-Sept-26 19:48:35

NotAGran55

Curlywhirly Charles Furneaux dropped out after 21 UP, provided an update at 70 plus a few photos, but wouldn’t appear on camera.

Ah, thanks for that, I hadn't noticed that it was him that was missing from the final photo.

MayBee70 Thu 24-Sept-26 16:39:57

I hadn’t realised that Michael Apted had gone on to be a Hollywood director. I had assumed that Nick had been interviewed recently and was saddened to realise it was over two years ago; although he did live longer than the original prognosis. There is an extended utube documentary about Neil. He actually lived with Bruce for a while who found him quite a difficult house guest but, being Bruce ( what a dear man) wouldn’t dream of not allowing him to stay for as long as necessary.

NotAGran55 Thu 24-Sept-26 16:32:05

Curlywhirly Charles Furneaux dropped out after 21 UP, provided an update at 70 plus a few photos, but wouldn’t appear on camera.

Curlywhirly Thu 24-Sept-26 16:25:59

Loved watching this through the years. Initially didn't it say that they had 20 children? Yet there were only 11 in the final picture of them all. Counting the 2 that had sadly died, it appears that there were only 13 that took part regularly, can anyone remember who was missing?

MayBee70 Wed 23-Sept-26 19:57:24

Justwidowed

70 UP The Victorians was on ITV 1 on Tuesday.There is another programme on tonight at 7.30 on ITV 1 called 7 UP The story which gives many more details of the making of the series.

Thanks. Just watched it. Now going to watch the final episode. Crikey, this programme has made me so emotional. Got the tissues ready…

Justwidowed Wed 23-Sept-26 13:31:06

70 UP The Victorians was on ITV 1 on Tuesday.There is another programme on tonight at 7.30 on ITV 1 called 7 UP The story which gives many more details of the making of the series.

Dolly17 Wed 23-Sept-26 12:50:01

I was also reminded of Victoria Wood Bellas some of her spoof sketches were similar in style to the earlier 7Up episodes (remember Chrissie the channel swimmer?)

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Wed 23-Sept-26 12:19:15

My dear old dad used to say “no education is ever wasted”.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Wed 23-Sept-26 12:15:23

MrsQuigley

The retired QC was John FGT2.

Thanks you of course it was!
Lovely man
I just got muddled up. 🤭

Luckygirl3 Wed 23-Sept-26 12:06:12

It is interesting that as well as social history it encourages us to ask what constitutes success or happiness. And for me that leads on to asking about our education system and what exactly children are being educated FOR.

I don't think that question is asked often enough and I feel it should be at the forefront of education planning, especially in our rapidly changing world.

rafichagran Wed 23-Sept-26 12:03:22

I think Jackie and John the KC were very vocal about the intrusive questioning by Michael Apted.
John also said he did not like Michael Apted as he wanted to portray him as the posh boy. John went on to help children affected by the Chaucescau regime, he them helped alot of people get their pensions back in his position as KC.I really liked him.
I also admired Jackie as well as she was not prepared to be questioned like that.
I am a year younger than the people who took part in this programme and I remember my Mum letting me watch it when I was six while she done her knitting. It brings back memories and I have enjoyed the programne.

Luckygirl3 Wed 23-Sept-26 12:02:51

Apted himself on the programmes:

""What can I say? I mean, it's the favorite thing I've ever done, the thing I'm most proud of. It's nerve-wracking, because you think you're always going to blow it and you'll wreck the whole thing. It seems fragile, and I've learned a lot of lessons about it. I've made mistakes on it and had to correct those mistakes. You know, particularly I got into a situation, I think, early on where I became judgmental about people — that if they didn't agree with my standards of success, failure, happiness, whatever, then I would feel they were the lesser for it. And also I try to play God. I try to predict what might happen to people, and sort of set it all up for that. And I did that, and that was an embarrassing mistake. And I think what I've learned all the way through is the less I do, the better."

It is interesting that as he himself aged, Apted reflected on the flaws and what he could have done better.

Luckygirl3 Wed 23-Sept-26 11:47:50

One of the participants (can't remember which, but not from a privileged background) related a filmed scene with a teacher who was talking with them in an academic way. The teacher told them that this scene would be cut as it did not fit the brief - it was.

Charles Furneaux had the agenda sussed by the third programme and would not take part.

I found some of the questioning unnecessarily intrusive and was pleased to see some of the women kicking back on that.

Michael Apted did however acknowledge that there were flaws in how he approached it all and that his fixed assumptions might have got in the way.

MayBee70 Wed 23-Sept-26 11:46:59

Justwidowed

Did anyone watch 70 UP The Victorians which was shown for the first time last night since 1965.The team interviewed people aged about 79 born under Queen Victoria's reign.It was fascinating and reduced me to tears at times.How lucky we are now.

What channel was that on? I’ve always been interested in oral history from the perspective of ordinary people after reading Melvyn Braggs book ‘ Speak for England’.

fancythat Wed 23-Sept-26 11:09:53

I havent watched it yet.
Glad it seems to have got a better reaction than last week's episode.

MartavTaurus Wed 23-Sept-26 11:04:36

The reason the TV programnes only scrape the surface, and don't get followed through, is due to money.
For example, the survey part of UK Research and Innovation (UKRI) provides millions to analyse the NCDS findings, (UCL carries this out), and participants are assessed by doctors, psychologists etc over a variety of areas over 70 years. It costs a fortune. TV companies have only a limited budget with which to please everyone.

Bellasnana Wed 23-Sept-26 10:47:14

Being the same age as the participants I have loved watching this incredible documentary. Very emotional last episode.

Did anyone else think Jackie had a look of Victoria Wood in her 30’s? I also thought Suzy at 70 was a dead ringer for Jenny Agutter.

Chocolatelovinggran Wed 23-Sept-26 10:43:52

I watched the first two as an undergraduate. Our tutors encouraged us to keep watching over the years.
I recall later programmes - one called A Child of Our Time, possibly started in the year 2000, but these seemed to have not been followed through .

MrsQuigley Wed 23-Sept-26 10:33:44

The retired QC was John FGT2.

MrsQuigley Wed 23-Sept-26 10:32:39

I have watched every episode from the start in 1964. Over the last week I have re-watched the earlier programmes and finished 70Up last night. The programmes are a remarkable social history in themselves, even before adding in the individual children/adults. So much has been written about the series over the years and especially around the time of 70Up.
What genuinely strikes me is how few posts there are on here about the series. Are people really not interested in social history or is there so much better stuff on TV just now? (Obviously what interests me on TV has no bearing on what interests others, a fact brought vividly home to me recently on GN).

MartavTaurus Wed 23-Sept-26 10:29:07

He realised early on that the producer had a fixed agenda and wanted to fulfil it by shoehorning them all into his perceived roles for them.
I think you've hit the nail on the head there, Friedgreentomatoes. This was tv, not a social experiment at all. You need tens of thousands of participants to extract any meaningful results. The NCDS survey has around 180,000 children, now approaching 70 years old, all born in the same week.

Justwidowed Wed 23-Sept-26 09:28:38

Did anyone watch 70 UP The Victorians which was shown for the first time last night since 1965.The team interviewed people aged about 79 born under Queen Victoria's reign.It was fascinating and reduced me to tears at times.How lucky we are now.