Great film. I went with the local U3a cinema group which joins a U3a group from another town to swell the numbers.
I don’t think there was a seat left in the cinem it was so popular.
Alphabetical Fauna (mammals, birds, reptiles, fish, insects etc.)
I can honestly say it was one of the best films I have ever seen and the two lead actors will definitely win awards.
Don’t miss it.
Great film. I went with the local U3a cinema group which joins a U3a group from another town to swell the numbers.
I don’t think there was a seat left in the cinem it was so popular.
OH and I saw this last week. A perfect film we both agreed. At the very least Andrew Scott must get an Oscar nomination.
Mamie
I watched an excellent documentary about Stagg in the run up to D Day some time ago and have read the major historical accounts (inevitable when living in Normandie).
I am hesitating about watching the film, as I gather there are considerable historical inaccuracies.
I understand it does not make clear that Stagg and his team had been embedded in the planning of Operation Overlord for months, taking regular weather readings well in advance and that Eisenhower trusted and respected Stagg's opinion. I also gather Montgomery's reaction is misrepresented.
We saw this film when it came out. Yes, the film was not entirely accurate but, I saw the film as being an impressionistic film in the art movement sense.
It changed things slightly, like looking through water, so that it created the raised emotions and tensions of all involved as this immense military operation was planned and how its success or failure hung by a thread in so many ways, of which the weather was one key element.
Things I noticed included how physically big the actor was, who played Eisenhower. He dominated every scene he was in. In fact he was of average height, but his size in the film reflected his dominance in leading the D day invasion.
The film is a story told from a viewpoint. It is not a documentary and in engendering the tensions around planning D Day and how it could success or fail on something as simple as a weather forecast is brilliant. It finishes by showing D Day itself. Of those who took part and died on the beaches. Reminding us of what happened when the event took places that had hung on the thread of a weather forecast.
Go and see it and judge for yourself.
I’m glad you enjoyed the filmLauraNorderr 👍
Barbadosbelle
albertina
Do go and see it. By adding your support to something like this you help ensure that people like your Uncle aren't forgotten.
If everyone thought like you and so didn't watch such films and documentaries then they wouldn't be made and all the brave and heroic men and women would all soon be forgotten.
..
She can support it without actually watching it if she would find it traumatising.
Watched this a couple of weeks ago. Thanks NanKate for the recommendation. Thoroughly enjoyed the film, learned things I hadn’t heard before and shed a tear or two.
So many brave folk, we have much to be thankful for.
I found it tense, very well acted and moving.
Finally got around to watching it with my grandson.
Brendan Fraser and Andrew Scott give stellar performances and gave me an insight into the importance that the weather played in the D-Day landings.
Tissues at the end at the futility of war and the happy ending for James Stagg. (Scott's character).
Thoroughly enjoyed it and nearly shed a tear at the end.
Milest0ne
I will have to watch this film.
I have a letter from my Dad, written on the eve of D-Day , sent from his ship as they were getting it ready to take soldiers off to France.
That is so poignant. We can never really understand what people went through.
I saw it yesterday too and thought it very enjoyable. Such an unusal subject...the weather... for a film to be made about.
A few tears were shed at the end.
The trailer looked rather boring, but I went to see it yesterday, and loved it. Great acting, so moving, and just about the best film I've seen in ages. Andrew Scott is wonderful.
I went to see it yesterday. It was very good.
I think some of the arguing was hammed up a bit too much, trying to show the tension. I'm sure they had their disagreements, but I think they'd be too professional to have such a dramatic shouting match.
Was listening to the radio about this film, John Stagg’s grandson actually worked on this film and didn’t realise for some time that it was about his grandfather. Amazing coincidence, can’t remember if he is an actor or part of the filming bit.
I will have to watch this film.
I have a letter from my Dad, written on the eve of D-Day , sent from his ship as they were getting it ready to take soldiers off to France.
I agree its an excellent film we thoroughly enjoyed it.
Barbadosbelle
albertina
Do go and see it. By adding your support to something like this you help ensure that people like your Uncle aren't forgotten.
If everyone thought like you and so didn't watch such films and documentaries then they wouldn't be made and all the brave and heroic men and women would all soon be forgotten.
..
They are never forgotten in the towns, communes and villages of Normandie. Every year there is a Bank Holiday and ceremony of remembrance in churches and churchyards on May 8th, with the local children playing a large part in the commemoration. Older people shared their memories of lived experience.
Films should stick to the facts.
I watched an excellent documentary about Stagg in the run up to D Day some time ago and have read the major historical accounts (inevitable when living in Normandie).
I am hesitating about watching the film, as I gather there are considerable historical inaccuracies.
I understand it does not make clear that Stagg and his team had been embedded in the planning of Operation Overlord for months, taking regular weather readings well in advance and that Eisenhower trusted and respected Stagg's opinion. I also gather Montgomery's reaction is misrepresented.
Saw it last week and thoroughly enjoyed it, hope it does get some awards. The only thing that slightly bothered me with Ike and Monty was that they seemed so big and well fed!
Would recommend
Farmor,
Thank you for all that information.
I find it fascinating that the skill of a 21 year old young woman had such an important influence on the success of D-Day.
I must go and see this film asap.
I watched it yesterday it was brilliant.
Excellent film,.
Barbadosbelle
albertina
Do go and see it. By adding your support to something like this you help ensure that people like your Uncle aren't forgotten.
If everyone thought like you and so didn't watch such films and documentaries then they wouldn't be made and all the brave and heroic men and women would all soon be forgotten.
..
Well said.
albertina
Do go and see it. By adding your support to something like this you help ensure that people like your Uncle aren't forgotten.
If everyone thought like you and so didn't watch such films and documentaries then they wouldn't be made and all the brave and heroic men and women would all soon be forgotten.
..
I can't watch anything to do with the D Day landings because of what happened to my beloved Uncle. He was rescued off the beaches at Dunkirk by the brave folk in the little ships, and suffered physical and emotional problems because of it. He was a brave man and returned with his unit on D Day. I remember him as a lovely, gently man who hated war but did his bit.
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join the discussion, watch threads and lots more.
Register now »Already registered? Log in with:
Gransnet »Get our top conversations, latest advice, fantastic competitions, and more, straight to your inbox. Sign up to our daily newsletter here.