Gransnet forums

Relationships

Withholding Sex

(64 Posts)
rosecarmel Wed 17-Apr-19 10:18:48

It seems to be the consensus that when a woman withholds sex from her husband she is being manipulative - There couldn't possibly be another reason?

I call BS, but surely I could be mistaken -

What if a wife who had been emotionally manipulated for over a decade and verbally abused gradually reached a breaking point and no longer felt like having sex in that marriage dynamic anymore? Would her disinterest in having sex with him still be considered manipulative?

MawBroonsback Fri 19-Apr-19 22:57:46

Bridgeit gringrin

Bridgeit Fri 19-Apr-19 23:00:01

?

MawBroonsback Fri 19-Apr-19 23:01:38

In case the term “meta-discussion” is not one in your everyday repertoire, I thought a brief exposition might be helpful

The term meta-discussion means a discussion whose subject is a discussion. Meta-discussion explores such issues as the style of a discussion, its participants, the setting in which the discussion occurs, and the relationship of the discussion to other discussions on the same or different topics.
Still awake at the back? grin

Bridgeit Fri 19-Apr-19 23:08:29

Just like a bit of a meaningful natter (chat, gosssip) over the garden fence , a most enjoyable cacophony , most enjoyable MawBroonsback , ?

Bridgeit Fri 19-Apr-19 23:10:40

Especially if trying to withhold sex at the same time ! ?

MawBroonsback Fri 19-Apr-19 23:49:55

Multi- tasking! Every woman’s strength!

Bridgeit Fri 19-Apr-19 23:55:10

Grin

Bridgeit Fri 19-Apr-19 23:55:45

That was supposed to be an emoji ?

Chewbacca Sat 20-Apr-19 00:08:29

I've read this thread from top to bottom. Twice. And I still don't understand...... confused meta discussion? What's that got to do with sex or the lack of it? confusedconfused

MawBroonsback Sat 20-Apr-19 00:12:27

On planet Zog, all things are possible..........

Starlady Sat 20-Apr-19 00:12:59

Ok, let me see if I get this rosecarmel... Your friend is unhappy in her marriage, and so, among other things, no longer wants sex with her husband. The whole relationship "exhausts" her, but she's settling for just stopping he sex because she doens't want to lose him.

If she were deliberately withholding - or providing - sex to get something specific, I would say that was manipulation. But, as others have said, since it's just a matter of her not wanting sex because he is emotionally abusive, etc. then tha's not manipulation. In fact, I would say, she's trying to protect herself from further emotional manipulation or maybe expressing her unhappiness in a non-verbal way. Or perhaps she's punishing him for his abusive behavior by withholding sex, which I wouldn't blame her for. Or maybe she just doesn't feel all lovey-dovey after being verbally abused. I know I wouldn't.

What concerns me more is that she hasn't sought counseling or doesn't just leave him. Why is she afraid to lose someone who has been so cruel to her? I get her refraining from sex, but, imo, it's a poor substitute for getting away from him, altogether, and seeking a happier life. Has she given any thought to divorce? I hope so.

rosecarmel Sat 20-Apr-19 12:39:58

Starlady, they've decided as a couple to make efforts to work through their issues -

FarNorth Sun 21-Apr-19 00:19:59

Great news!
We can all stop worrying.