Had a lovely teatime with DS and his wife and two boisterous little boys aged 4 and 2.1/2. When time to put their PJs on they were playing their mother up. I was shocked when she suddenly bellowed (yes bellowed) STAND STILL AND PUT YOUR PYJAMAS ON NOW!!! The child looked near to tears and it was totally uncalled for. I had noticed that she also raised her hand as if to hit him but thought better of it. I just wonder what she is like when we are not there. I have never heard anyone shout at a child in that way. My son also threatens to 'smack' them. I know they do get smacks because my little GS said last week while out with us when I told him what a good boy he was "I am not always good grandma, daddy and mummy say I am bad and naughty and I get a smack" I asked how he felt when he was smacked, either sad or cross, he replied "I feel that I am naughty". it is so sad.