Gransnet forums

Chat

What do you think of Mary Earps being SPOTY?

(65 Posts)
25Avalon Wed 20-Dec-23 12:07:58

Mary Earps, England Women’s goalkeeper was voted BBC’s Sports Personality Of The Year. A lot have said there were more deserving sport’s people who have achieved more. Also it was an England Women’s player last year. The odious Joey Barton has made some horrible comments on Twitter. Should Mary have got it or is it the ‘woke’ BBC? Personally I think she was voted for so that’s that.

RosiesMaw Wed 20-Dec-23 12:18:14

She got it for being a great sportswoman and an inspiration to girls in any and every sport.
That’s enough for me! 👏👏👏👏

Rosie51 Wed 20-Dec-23 12:27:09

She wasn't my choice although I admire her achievements. I voted for 3rd place Katarina Johnson-Thompson. Having said that Mary was the public's 1st choice so of course she deserves it.

GrannyGravy13 Wed 20-Dec-23 12:28:07

The public voted from a shortlist, Mary Earps is a worthy winner.

Kim19 Wed 20-Dec-23 12:32:00

Fine by me.

Visgir1 Wed 20-Dec-23 12:32:25

I voted for her..

Rosalyn69 Wed 20-Dec-23 12:40:01

Hmph. I thought it was a terrible choice but then I thought the list was poor as well.

karmalady Wed 20-Dec-23 12:40:33

Good result

Purplepixie Wed 20-Dec-23 12:41:34

Mary Earps is a worthy winner! Well done Mary!!!

nanaK54 Wed 20-Dec-23 13:27:23

I am delighted for her!

lixy Wed 20-Dec-23 13:33:24

Well-deserved accolade for a very brave lady. She has inspired several girls I know to take up sport, not just football.

Grannybags Wed 20-Dec-23 13:35:55

RosiesMaw

She got it for being a great sportswoman and an inspiration to girls in any and every sport.
That’s enough for me! 👏👏👏👏

Me too! Really pleased she won

25Avalon Wed 20-Dec-23 14:21:16

“They’ve lost to a big bag of spuds that plays in goal for a girl’s team” tweeted Joey Barton. What a horrible man. Fleetwood and Bristol Rovers where he last managed are well shot. Maybe he wants to stay in the news in the hope of getting another job. He also had a go at women football commentators. Any publicity is good?

silverlining48 Wed 20-Dec-23 14:22:15

I was never that interested in sport, never played as a child, but my goodness why shouldn’t women win twice in succession. It makes up for not winning at all for the last however many years, (for ever.).

If it was a public vote then nothing else to say other than congratulations to Mary. She and her team have inspired many young girls @nd women to take up football and other sport and I am delighted my gc both enjoy it

silverlining48 Wed 20-Dec-23 15:03:47

Never heard of joey Barton. What an odious little man.

NanKate Wed 20-Dec-23 15:34:30

👍Mary. Excellent

However I didn’t like her dress or the dress of the presenter.

BridgetPark Wed 20-Dec-23 15:43:19

Is no one else sick of the self-indulgent nature of these awards, promoted and run in totality by the BBC, for the BBC, in such a self-congratulatory manner, and the fact the the licence payer is funding the whole thing? There are a lot of people who have no real interest in sport, and I honestly think, if it wasn't run and promoted by the BBC, nobody would really miss it. Surely if we are still having to pay a licence fee for the BBC, they should be ploughing the money into good quality programmes.
So would you miss it?

Chardy Wed 20-Dec-23 16:15:08

BridgetPark

Is no one else sick of the self-indulgent nature of these awards, promoted and run in totality by the BBC, for the BBC, in such a self-congratulatory manner, and the fact the the licence payer is funding the whole thing? There are a lot of people who have no real interest in sport, and I honestly think, if it wasn't run and promoted by the BBC, nobody would really miss it. Surely if we are still having to pay a licence fee for the BBC, they should be ploughing the money into good quality programmes.
So would you miss it?

It's an end-of-year tradition to review the sporting achievements of the year. So often one of us would say 'I'd forgotten that' or 'Oh that game/event was so good'.
And we remember those who died this year.
The votes are a small part of the whole thing.

HousePlantQueen Wed 20-Dec-23 16:24:19

BridgetPark

Is no one else sick of the self-indulgent nature of these awards, promoted and run in totality by the BBC, for the BBC, in such a self-congratulatory manner, and the fact the the licence payer is funding the whole thing? There are a lot of people who have no real interest in sport, and I honestly think, if it wasn't run and promoted by the BBC, nobody would really miss it. Surely if we are still having to pay a licence fee for the BBC, they should be ploughing the money into good quality programmes.
So would you miss it?

I don't watch it, have no interest in sport at all, but neither do I watch Strictly Come Dancing; I am happy to accept that others have different tastes, hobbies and interest to me. We all should

Callistemon21 Wed 20-Dec-23 16:24:48

RosiesMaw

She got it for being a great sportswoman and an inspiration to girls in any and every sport.
That’s enough for me! 👏👏👏👏

I missed all this but yes, Mary is a great choice!

Callistemon21 Wed 20-Dec-23 16:30:06

25Avalon

“They’ve lost to a big bag of spuds that plays in goal for a girl’s team” tweeted Joey Barton. What a horrible man. Fleetwood and Bristol Rovers where he last managed are well shot. Maybe he wants to stay in the news in the hope of getting another job. He also had a go at women football commentators. Any publicity is good?

What a nasty, sad little twerp (I wanted to use a different word). Stupid boy.

Never heard of him but I and millions of others have heard of Mary Earps and yes, she and women and girl footballers are an inspiration compared to some of the louts who play for men's teams.

Just looked him up - he's a nasty sexist thug who stabbed a lit cigar into someone's eye. Did he get sent to prison? No, but he should have been.

Grammaretto Wed 20-Dec-23 16:40:41

Of course she should win! Well deserved. It made my DGD very happy. I have a football obsessed DGD who is very fit and now at 15 plays for 2 amateur teams and wants to study sports science or whatever at university eventually. It amazes me!
Lots of people have more than one TV screen now, I believe, so could choose to watch another channel.
😁

henetha Wed 20-Dec-23 16:46:16

I think it's appropriate that once a year the BBC have a programme celebrating sporting achievements.
I'm not a football fan but I think it's wonderful how women's sport has progressed and women's football has achieved so much. So, well done, Mary Earps.

BlueBelle Wed 20-Dec-23 16:57:13

I don’t watch these programmes nor vote on them, I don’t have a lot of interest in sport, but I do know the British girls have achieved a lot and have influenced a lot of young girls, and if this young lady is a good role model then very good luck to her
No idea who Joey Barton is but he sounds a nasty piece 🤮

Labradora Wed 20-Dec-23 17:04:59

Brought up in one of the great northern footballing cities of the UK understanding and watching (men's) football is inextricably linked with my youth. Although I no longer watch football matches any success of my home team always makes me smile.
I have , in my later life, been absolutely astonished by the number of women who want to play football and the number of spectators who want to watch women's football.
This is a wonderful new sporting opportunity for women. Best of luck to players and spectators.