Gransnet forums

Chat

So who will accept the poisoned chalice?

(156 Posts)
Mollygo Fri 05-Jul-24 11:08:26

Sunak will resign as soon as the leadership race begins.
His was a poisoned chalice, and nothing has changed.

Mollygo Sun 07-Jul-24 15:03:10

GSM
Labour know that the public gaze, whether pro labour or not, will be firmly focused on their ability/inability to solve the problem.

The GBP want to know what solving the problem will mean with regard to the housing problem, school places, food banks etc for people who live here.

Casdon Sun 07-Jul-24 09:22:48

I agree with Germanshepherdsmum regarding Jeremy Hunt saving his seat, credit to him for caring enough to use his own money to help his campaign. As he doesn’t intend to run for the leadership his motives must be assumed to be that he cares enough about his party to want to be involved in determining its future. It will be interesting to see who he backs for the leadership campaign

Germanshepherdsmum Sun 07-Jul-24 09:19:48

Many more than in the past I think. Lord knows how they can possibly be housed or what it will cost to feed them, or how much more their lawyers will trouser out of the meagre legal aid budget. But now that we have lefty lawyers in government …

Aveline Sun 07-Jul-24 09:16:23

How many will pour in in the next two years? And the next?

Germanshepherdsmum Sun 07-Jul-24 09:02:35

winterwhite

Yes I agree, GSM, that JH isn’t dependent on his parl salary but that was largely what I meant. He was chancellor and bore more responsibility than most for the financial situation. To use his own money to augment his own campaign, and then sit at home and not help his party doesn’t look well to me.

How on earth do you know that he sat at home and didn’t help his party? Pure fiction. He has helped his party by retaining a seat they were predicted to lose. Good for him putting his hand in his pocket. He could just have decided not to bother, like many others, but he didn’t.

Callistemon213 Sun 07-Jul-24 08:57:21

We do not have uncontrolled immigration in this country. In 2023, just under 790,000 immigrants arrived in this country legally, and approximately 40,000 illegally

Well, loosely speaking, give or take several hundred.

It is the net migration figure that is important too.
Who are the people who are emigrating from the UK? What skills and professions are we losing and which are we gaining?
Statistics do not give a full picture.

over the past two years net migration has been at the highest level we have seen. Provisional estimates, which provide an early indication of migration, suggest that net migration was 672,000 in the YE June 2023.

Sparklefizz Sun 07-Jul-24 08:41:59

MayBee70

So Hunt has ruled himself out? I need to hope for Tugendhat now.

Didn't Tugendhat vote for Liz Truss back in the day? I don't trust his judgment.

MayBee70 Sun 07-Jul-24 00:24:16

Both Patel and Braverman have been found guilty of wrongdoing. Braverman was taken on by Johnson as Attorney General who wanted someone in that position who had the same attitude towards the law of the land that he had. I’ll never forgive Cleverly for calling Stockton on Tees a s******e. I certainly hope there will be more because, apart from Tugendhat, who seems far too nice to even be considered that list shows how far the party has departed from it’s core values.

Wyllow3 Sun 07-Jul-24 00:10:55

Here is the list of Conservative possible leaders (there may be more)

www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c51y2lqzxl8o?xtor=ES-211-[74854_PANUK_DIV_27_NEW_ElectionEssential30_RET_COHORT.html]-20240706-[bbcnews_whowillreplacerishisunak_newsuk]

Wyllow3 Sat 06-Jul-24 23:03:01

Thank you Monica for the statistics on immigration - largely ignored in all the drama.

MayBee70 Sat 06-Jul-24 22:38:03

So Hunt has ruled himself out? I need to hope for Tugendhat now.

M0nica Sat 06-Jul-24 21:48:27

because GSM controlled immigration is about 20 times greater. The facts, and their sources are all in my post above.

Blinko Sat 06-Jul-24 21:39:35

SillyOma

As long as its not another Theresa May or Liz Truss

I wouldn't mention TM and Liz Truss in the same breath. Theresa May was hard working, serious, tenacious and understood the job; for instance the NI issue caused by Brexit. Whereas Boris declared it was all 'oven ready' and a done deal. It wasn't and he couldn't be bothered with the detail to sort it out. TM knew the problems and tried her utmost to deal with them. Truss was always a complete fool.

winterwhite Sat 06-Jul-24 20:28:13

Yes I agree, GSM, that JH isn’t dependent on his parl salary but that was largely what I meant. He was chancellor and bore more responsibility than most for the financial situation. To use his own money to augment his own campaign, and then sit at home and not help his party doesn’t look well to me.

Germanshepherdsmum Sat 06-Jul-24 15:59:22

The alternative would have been that he lost his seat in all likelihood - it was predicted. He’s a wealthy man and certainly not dependent on keeping his parliamentary salary. He would have been available should Sunak have needed him.

winterwhite Sat 06-Jul-24 15:50:32

There must be many Tory MPs who have never known life in opposition or learned the skills needed to be effective. I hope they make use of David Cameron.

Jeremy Hunt held his seat by putting £kkk of his own money into his own campaign, and spending the whole campaign in his constituency rather than helping the party. A good constituency MP he may be, but those don’t sound like collaborative let alone leadership qualities to me.

Germanshepherdsmum Sat 06-Jul-24 15:38:23

How is the arrival of people on boats without visas anything but uncontrolled immigration MOnica?

Galaxy Sat 06-Jul-24 15:34:56

No she didnt. She had no coherent message which is what the right needs.

growstuff Sat 06-Jul-24 15:29:01

Galaxy

I hope they ignore any advice from the left to be honest. The middle class left tend not to have any understanding of large sections of the population. They would be better listening to some of the 'thinkers' on the right who have emerged recently. Not necessarily politicians.

That's what Liz Truss did. hmm

Pammie1 Sat 06-Jul-24 15:25:31

MayBee70

Smileless2012

I agree that would be the wise thing to do Siope but it's highly unlikely.

KS is being compared to Tony Blair!!! He doesn't have anything like the charisma.

Charisma isn’t exactly what this country needs at this moment in time. Imo

My own opinion is that Blair’s ‘charisma’ was more that of a smiling assassin.

Galaxy Sat 06-Jul-24 15:15:54

I hope they ignore any advice from the left to be honest. The middle class left tend not to have any understanding of large sections of the population. They would be better listening to some of the 'thinkers' on the right who have emerged recently. Not necessarily politicians.

M0nica Sat 06-Jul-24 15:14:42

Witzend

Germanshepherdsmum

I’m not bothered about the economic literacy of those who voted for Reform HPQ as I am not one of them nor do I know any of them. However, Farage will I think be very useful in keeping uncontrolled immigration at the forefront of the issues faced by Labour. It’s not something to be swept under the carpet while they deal with more palatable issues.

Yes. I loathe Farage, and would never vote Reform, but uncontrolled immigration will continue to be a huge issue for many people - as long as we still don’t have anything like enough reasonable, affordable housing for all the people - native and otherwise - already here.

Putting so many new arrivals in hotels costs billions.

We do not have uncontrolled immigration in this country. In 2023, just under 790,000 immigrants arrived in this country legally, and approximately 40,000 illegally www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/populationandmigration/internationalmigration/bulletins/longterminternationalmigrationprovisional/latest
lordslibrary.parliament.uk/illegal-migration-dealing-with-inadmissible-asylum-applications/

In other words, illegal immigration stands at less than 5% of total immigration. Roughly half a million of these visas go to students, who are self financing and the vast majority of whom return home after their studies. Roughly half these students come from China or India, and students prefer to return to their own countries after graduation.

British universities rely on overseas students for up to a quarter of their income. Research has consistently found that international students have a positive economic impact in the UK. migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/briefings/student-migration-to-the-uk/

Now you have the facts, you may like to reframe the discussion.

Germanshepherdsmum Sat 06-Jul-24 14:44:36

Not a move that I will be making.

Wyllow3 Sat 06-Jul-24 14:41:09

Yes - it is a big ask if someone hasn't joined a political party I admit, but it's more effective than sniping on the sidelines.

When we think of the tiny numbers of people in the country who actually "chose" Truss - which had a massive impact, it could be a good move.

SillyOma Sat 06-Jul-24 14:40:24

As long as its not another Theresa May or Liz Truss