Gransnet forums

Chat

Southport murders *GNHQ has corrected title*

(130 Posts)
Crossstitchfan Thu 01-Aug-24 09:40:24

We are all reeling from the dreadful reports about the stabbings in Stockport. One thing I find hard to understand is why the monster responsible for them cannot be named ‘for legal reasons’. I understand this to be because he is under 18.
In my opinion, if he is old enough to carry out this unforgivable act, he is old enough to be named and shamed. What does everyone else think?
I hope all those affected by this will find peace. My heart goes out to them.

tickingbird Thu 01-Aug-24 16:27:10

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

tickingbird Thu 01-Aug-24 16:29:47

I’ve asked the above to be deleted as no idea what happened. GN is behaving very strangely for me atm. Post disappear when I click post and now copying whole pages.

Galaxy Thu 01-Aug-24 16:32:54

It's ok I understood anyway! GN is currently freezing when i try to post. To be honest it may be a good thing, gives me a chance to think for goodness sake dont say that.

VioletSky Thu 01-Aug-24 16:34:05

It doesn't matter if the name is out there already but I would have preferred his family remained protected until those contributing to violent riots based on false information had calmed

eazybee Thu 01-Aug-24 16:56:08

He has been named by order of the the Judge at Liverpool Crown court, and pictures released.
His name is Axel Muganwa Rudakubana, and he will be 18 on August 7th. He was born to Rwandan parents in Cardiff,

RosiesMaw2 Thu 01-Aug-24 17:37:07

Seeing the pic, he looks little more than a child himself.
Something very wrong there.

Galaxy Thu 01-Aug-24 17:39:19

That's an old photo of it's the one being used by some news outlets.

Galaxy Thu 01-Aug-24 17:40:58

Sorry if it's the one wing used by media outlets.

Galaxy Thu 01-Aug-24 17:41:56

Oh my God. One more try.
It's an old photo if it is the one being used by many media outlets.

Joseann Thu 01-Aug-24 17:46:12

In the doorbell footage of him in a green hoodie he is head and shoulders above the cars, and almost as tall as the front door. His physique isn't that of a child, he is the same height as the police who surrounded the property.
I haven't looked at the older photos released today.

JaneJudge Thu 01-Aug-24 17:48:00

Looks like a tempest photo

Labradora Thu 01-Aug-24 17:49:10

Presumably to diffuse any further trouble-stirring against, presumably , ordinary law-abiding UK citizens who are Muslims, he has now been named apparently three days before his 18th birthday.
Other than this practicality , how does his name help?
It is a tragedy also for his family and friends.
Surely without any shadow of a doubt this person has a severe mental illness , perhaps undiagnosed/untreated schizophrenia ?
How otherwise at close range could someone stick a knife in a defenceless six year old child ?

GrannyGravy13 Thu 01-Aug-24 17:57:20

Photo released vs drawing by courtroom artist

GrannyGravy13 Thu 01-Aug-24 17:59:57

I thought long and hard about posting the photo.

My sympathies lie with the murdered girls, those still lying in hospital critically injured and all of their family and friends.

I have zero sympathy for the mass murderer of little girls 🤬

VioletSky Thu 01-Aug-24 18:00:49

Something went wrong somewhere for every human being who hurts another

This tragedy and trauma will cause more

Joseann Thu 01-Aug-24 18:04:05

GrannyGravy13

Photo released vs drawing by courtroom artist

Well, that's a bit of a difference.

Oreo Thu 01-Aug-24 18:07:47

Labradora

Presumably to diffuse any further trouble-stirring against, presumably , ordinary law-abiding UK citizens who are Muslims, he has now been named apparently three days before his 18th birthday.
Other than this practicality , how does his name help?
It is a tragedy also for his family and friends.
Surely without any shadow of a doubt this person has a severe mental illness , perhaps undiagnosed/untreated schizophrenia ?
How otherwise at close range could someone stick a knife in a defenceless six year old child ?

I agree.He has a diagnosis of Autism but may have had no help in spite of that and could have added mental health problems.

eazybee Thu 01-Aug-24 18:10:17

Knowing his identity stops other people being wrongly identified.
I would trust the judgement of the Judge in releasing the name.

GrannyGravy13 Thu 01-Aug-24 18:11:48

Oreo there are 1,000’s of autistic children in the U.K., my GS is one.

They do not go around stabbing defenceless little girls.

VioletSky Thu 01-Aug-24 18:32:26

To be fair I don't think Oreo was saying anything bad about autistic people there

I am one and work with children/get very passionate about child protection

But we should be careful how we talk about autism after knowing this information, so many people have little understanding or tolerance for autism as it is

GrannyGravy13 Thu 01-Aug-24 18:35:08

VioletSky autism is beginning to feel like a scapegoat diagnosis sometimes, and it upsets me.

GrannyGravy13 Thu 01-Aug-24 18:35:53

Apologies Oreo if I came across as rude, it wasn’t my intention.

VioletSky Thu 01-Aug-24 18:41:17

GrannyGravy13

VioletSky autism is beginning to feel like a scapegoat diagnosis sometimes, and it upsets me.

I understand

maddyone Thu 01-Aug-24 19:18:18

Joseann

I'm sure the judge has a better grip on things than anyone. I trust his words.
By continuing to prevent full reporting at this stage has the disadvantage of allowing others who are up to mischief to continue to spread misinformation in a vacuum. Allowing full reporting will undoubtedly remove some of the misreporting as to the identity of the defendant.

I agree with you Joseann.
The judge has made a considered response and we should all trust in that judgment.

maddyone Thu 01-Aug-24 19:24:23

I have zero sympathy for the mass murderer of little girls

I have the same feelings as you GG. No sympathy for him at all.
My sympathy is reserved for the bereaved parents and the parents sitting by the bedsides of critically injured children.