Gransnet forums

Chat

Southport murders *GNHQ has corrected title*

(130 Posts)
Crossstitchfan Thu 01-Aug-24 09:40:24

We are all reeling from the dreadful reports about the stabbings in Stockport. One thing I find hard to understand is why the monster responsible for them cannot be named ‘for legal reasons’. I understand this to be because he is under 18.
In my opinion, if he is old enough to carry out this unforgivable act, he is old enough to be named and shamed. What does everyone else think?
I hope all those affected by this will find peace. My heart goes out to them.

Boz Thu 01-Aug-24 12:57:21

The Times reported this boy has worked in theatre - London even, so I have a feeling this attack on a dance workshop, the definite target, was somehow related. Some grievance - real or imagined?

Rekarie Thu 01-Aug-24 13:20:04

Well I live here and had heard a name bandied about, but it was fake.

Now his actual name and photos of him have been released.

Joseann Thu 01-Aug-24 13:23:12

I'm glad he was named before his 18th birthday. This crime was so hideous that exceptional circumstances were called for.

I don't think the comment about working in a theatre and a grievance is helpful. That's just speculating all over again. The bottom line is that he is an evil monster.

westendgirl Thu 01-Aug-24 13:28:51

What difference does it make that you know his name ?

GrannyGravy13 Thu 01-Aug-24 13:31:39

westendgirl

What difference does it make that you know his name ?

It means a lot to some people.

It stops speculation.

It stops innocent people being named.

Those who have lost their daughters and those who are sitting by hospital beds, it makes a difference.

westendgirl Thu 01-Aug-24 13:32:09

By the way Galaxy not everyone had heard the name. I hadn't and I still can't understand why it is so important to some people.

Galaxy Thu 01-Aug-24 13:34:39

No sorry not everyone just everyone on Twitter.

Joseann Thu 01-Aug-24 13:35:01

It stops speculation.
Exactly.

HelterSkelter1 Thu 01-Aug-24 13:37:40

I hope now the police are guarding the street he lives in. Although I expect the family have been moved. Otherwise the ignorant thug element will probably torch houses. And no doubt the wrong house as they are not the brightest of people.

Rekarie Thu 01-Aug-24 13:41:45

The police are guarding the road but the family has gone.

Joseann Thu 01-Aug-24 13:54:33

I'm sure the judge has a better grip on things than anyone. I trust his words.
By continuing to prevent full reporting at this stage has the disadvantage of allowing others who are up to mischief to continue to spread misinformation in a vacuum. Allowing full reporting will undoubtedly remove some of the misreporting as to the identity of the defendant.

keepingquiet Thu 01-Aug-24 13:57:14

The truth is always better than speculation but protocol has to be followed. I understand this young man is 18 in a few days and the judge is not considering a section 25 because of this.

Wyllow3 Thu 01-Aug-24 13:59:50

He has been charged eg deemed fit to be charged.

Axel Muganwa Rudakubana, 17, is charged with three counts of murder, 10 of attempted murder, and one count of possessing a bladed article
He appeared in court in Liverpool today and was remanded in custody

Callistemon213 Thu 01-Aug-24 14:54:37

Wyllow3

He has been charged eg deemed fit to be charged.

Axel Muganwa Rudakubana, 17, is charged with three counts of murder, 10 of attempted murder, and one count of possessing a bladed article
He appeared in court in Liverpool today and was remanded in custody

One week short of 18.

Urmstongran Thu 01-Aug-24 15:01:47

“Russia’s fake news about the Southport stabbings is part of Vladimir Putin’s “grey warfare” against the West, a former head of MI6 has said.

Russian state media were among those who falsely identified the suspect – who was charged overnight – as an asylum seeker who arrived in the United Kingdom in a small boat.

The claims helped to fuel disorder on the streets in Hartlepool and London as well as Southport, where dozens of police officers were injured in clashes with far-Right protesters.

Sir Richard Dearlove said the spread of fake news was a “fundamental tactic” used by Putin’s regime against the UK and other Western nations.

He told LBC’s Nick Ferrari: “What I can tell you is that we’re in a state of grey warfare with Russia – we may not feel that we are, but they certainly think they are.

“The exploitation of that space is a fundamental tactic in their conflict with the West. So if these bots have been used to stir up through social media a violent response, I’m not the slightest bit surprised.”

Source: The Telegraph just now.

Callistemon213 Thu 01-Aug-24 15:05:27

No words I can use on here 🤬

HelterSkelter1 Thu 01-Aug-24 15:16:35

So GNs must be extra careful about linking, and reading, believing and quoting, stuff from random unknown sources.

keepingquiet Thu 01-Aug-24 15:39:35

HelterSkelter1

So GNs must be extra careful about linking, and reading, believing and quoting, stuff from random unknown sources.

Yes.

Wyllow3 Thu 01-Aug-24 15:48:59

Yes - the deleted first Southport thread ran with the rumours as fact:

for at least 2/3 pages before the police said "he's a UK citizen originally from Cardiff".

But as soon as some posters ran the quotes through google it was obvious it was a dodgy SM source.

The SM source had fake "news" from the UK and the USA featured on it.

The thread was deleted as there was far too much heated speculation on it.

JaneJudge Thu 01-Aug-24 15:51:44

it was on the BBC webpage
I know I was accused of pasting incorrect information but I'd just C&P it from the BBC
iirc it ran along the lines of
'arabic name'
asylum seeker
came on boat
housed locally in asylum hostel

JaneJudge Thu 01-Aug-24 15:52:37

btw I acknowledge I posted incorrect information from the BBC news web page

Wyllow3 Thu 01-Aug-24 15:57:38

Not a crime, JJ - its a horrible world out there and bewildering!

VioletSky Thu 01-Aug-24 16:05:16

I think given the riots and injured police, naming him could place anyone close to him in danger so it really isn't a good idea

VioletSky Thu 01-Aug-24 16:06:27

Unfortunately there are people who will continue to believe the untrue rumours despite evidence otherwise

Joseann Thu 01-Aug-24 16:18:59

VioletSky

I think given the riots and injured police, naming him could place anyone close to him in danger so it really isn't a good idea

The Judge felt that not naming him would have little effect in protecting the welfare of his family.
Moreover, the Judge said the balance clearly comes down in favour of the public interest in allowing full reporting of these proceedings.
I think he was right to say this.