Gransnet forums

News & politics

Why are we leaving?

(390 Posts)
yggdrasil Thu 05-Oct-17 08:49:38

This vid says a lot. Especially why the EU finds our government's attitude so incomprehensible

www.youtube.com/watch?v=kgu6pFz5oxA

(it is about 8 mins long)

durhamjen Tue 10-Oct-17 21:57:13

www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/brexit-no-deal-customs-white-paper

Not ready for a no deal.

durhamjen Tue 10-Oct-17 21:59:10

Hammond might want to be sacked - it will get him out of a problem.

www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/blog/headlines-pile-pressure-chancellor-pre-budget-public-services

mostlyharmless Wed 11-Oct-17 12:25:53

I see farmers' incomes are likely to be halved unless there is a free trade agreement with the EU as part of Brexit.
www.ft.com/content/cd9323b8-ad0e-11e7-beba-5521c713abf4
Farmers in my area were surprised by the "remain" posters in our windows before the referendum, as they were all convinced we should leave. I imagine most will be regretting it now. They (mainly small dairy/beef farms) have been struggling for years anyway.

Tegan2 Wed 11-Oct-17 12:59:16

Huge 'leave' posters in farms all over Yorkshire when we were there. Seems we are going to export a lot of tea, cakes and jam confused but wondering where, in this country, we grow tea confusedconfused....

JessM Wed 11-Oct-17 13:27:18

I think the Welsh hill farmers were not so convinced of the benefits of leaving. Ceredigion and Gwynedd both voted to remain. However they do both have a university town on their patch so that might have swung it.

whitewave Wed 11-Oct-17 13:46:29

So how will UK farming subsidies sit with countries like the USA NZ Argentina etc?

Customs checks to take place inland says Hammond. Does he know what he is talking about?! So illegal immigrants will have perhaps 5 miles to get off the lorry before border checks. Illegal goods/smuggling has the opportunity to off load the goods before the checks. On and on it goes. 16000 trucks a day just through the two docks, paperwork at present taking roughly 20mins. The tunnel has about half that amount with paperwork taking about the same. If there is a problem then it can take hours or days. That is what is seen as a seamless system before Brexit and all the accompanying bureaucracy and cost.

Someone needs to carry out an audit as to the cost of this foolish enterprise.

Tegan2 Wed 11-Oct-17 14:53:09

Why doesn't the Daily Fail print threads like these I wonder?? C'mon Daily Fail...I know you're watching. I DARE you to print this one....

MaizieD Wed 11-Oct-17 15:39:01

This was a trifle ironic, I think:

James Forsyth‏Verified account @JGForsyth Oct 1

Tories have sold conference advertising to the Port of Dover which is using it to warn of 17 mile queues there if there's no Brexit deal

twitter.com/JGForsyth/status/914456504425738240

MaizieD Wed 11-Oct-17 15:41:10

When I asked our NFU rep about farmers' votes in our area he said it was about 50/50 Leave/Remain.

I know that the few farmers I know all voted to Remain.

durhamjen Wed 11-Oct-17 17:01:23

Someone has carried out an audit, whitewave. Those are the papers that the government will not let us know about.

Tegan2 Wed 11-Oct-17 17:16:55

There is a petition asking for us to be told the results of that audit.

whitewave Wed 11-Oct-17 17:54:17

Twitter

Labour will vote against a no deal. So I don’t think the government will get it through?

Any ideas anyone?

whitewave Wed 11-Oct-17 18:06:51

Good grief this trashy government doesn’t hold back does it?

JRM disgracefully criticising the civil service- something that parliament never does. Crass and dishonest.

MaizieD Wed 11-Oct-17 18:16:41

There is a petition asking for us to be told the results of that audit.

Here:

petition.parliament.uk/petitions/200634

whitewave Wed 11-Oct-17 18:19:59

Signed

whitewave Wed 11-Oct-17 18:43:19

Just watching the (no)plans for the customs station and lorry park on the M20 on local television. If you didn’t laugh you’d get hysterical.

blossom14 Wed 11-Oct-17 18:46:16

Signed

durhamjen Wed 11-Oct-17 19:26:09

www.theweek.co.uk/house-prices/61987/london-house-prices-fall-for-first-time-since-financial-crisis

People getting ready to leave the sinking ship.

berdie Wed 11-Oct-17 22:21:54

Farmers will vote to remain, if I was receiving the subsidy that they are, I'd vote to remain. However i voted to leave, along with seventeen and a half million other souls, who aren't receiving subsidies. If you want an example of Europes reliance on the UK, go to Immingham docks and see the number of Volkswagen vans imported, bearing British Gas logo's, or the BMW's etc, coming into this country on a daily basis. We need to support UK, wether we we voted yea or nay, I cannot understand this adoration for Juncker, Verhofstadt et al, we need to be a sovereign country again, with control of borders, trade etc.

Tegan2 Wed 11-Oct-17 22:29:51

It isn't just farmers that receive subsidies etc. If you look around you, you will see signs everywhere of things that the EU have helped to fund [usually in places that central government want to forget exist] The Eden Project is one example.

durhamjen Wed 11-Oct-17 22:47:51

Obviously those who voted to leave didn't realise where are borders are, this side of the channel, North Sea, etc.
Controlling our borders causes chaos; but you go ahead and cause chaos.

MaizieD Wed 11-Oct-17 22:53:52

Farmers will vote to remain, if I was receiving the subsidy that they are, I'd vote to remain.

I think you've missed something there, berdie. If my part of the world is anything to go by farmers voted more or less 50/50 Leave/Remain. So clearly the subsidy wasn't always a deciding factor. Of course, a huge number of farmers will go bust without the subsidy and there's absolutely no guarantee that the UK government will be able or willing to match it.

We need to support UK, wether we we voted yea or nay,

And how are we supposed to do that? Seriously, I'd really like to know...

durhamjen Wed 11-Oct-17 23:01:12

120 MPs have called for the Brexit impact reports to be published. It might be even more now.

Welshwife Wed 11-Oct-17 23:03:23

There maybe lots of BMW and VW cars on the docks and driving around with the logos but it is only a small percentage of the output of these companies. That is the bigger point rather than numbers. UK no longer really manufactures cars - Jaguar /Land rovers etc are not really the cars of the masses. Ford assembles most if not all of their cars on the continent - our one came from Belgium.
Not too much manufacturing going on in UK now and even when there is the chance the Govt allows or brings in foreign countries to make/run the companies.
Somewhere in Mid Wales I think it is there is a company setting up to make what is in effect houses which are prefabricated - but a far cry from the prefabs erected after the war. Indeed Has homes in Germany are luxurious things. Instead of having a British company doing this it has gone to a Chinese one - with presumably a British work force. I saw the item on local Welsh news about a year ago and was disgusted that the Govt did not support a UK company to build these homes.

MaizieD Wed 11-Oct-17 23:04:54

Obviously those who voted to leave didn't realise where are borders are, this side of the channel, North Sea, etc.

I've often thought that it was most unfortunate (part of that 'perfect storm' really) that the EU ref. was happening at the height of the migrant crisis; making it very easy for people to confuse Freedom of Movement for EU nationals with the absolutely non-EU migrants trying to desperately enter the UK. I think they thought that if they voted Leave the migrants would disappear... As it is, it seems to me that the French will promptly return our border to Dover (at present we do border checks in Calais) and wave migrants onto the channel ferries with a merry 'Bon Voyage' to speed them on their way.

Not only will Dover become a vast lorry park but we'll have a 'Dover Jungle' of our own...