Gransnet forums

News & politics

The Last Days of Mrs May?

(582 Posts)
trisher Wed 12-Sept-18 11:42:36

So 50 MPs met to discuss getting rid of her, should we be counting the days? Or will she simply stay because there's no other suitable candidate and no one wants a poisoned chalice?

paddyann Fri 21-Sept-18 20:52:12

and there are still people here who believe all the "Great" Britain nonsense,Britain isn't and hasn't been a major player for decades and its time some understood that.The Westminster government are making a total mess of the whole Brexit situation.TWO years plus and no further forward!!.Couldn't run a piss up in a brewery .I am fizzing at this farce .This will destroy the Scottish economy ,not to mention the rest of the disunited "kingdom" who in their right minds walks away from 500MILLION potential customers?

MaizieD Fri 21-Sept-18 22:32:57

^ No country in the EU is going to go against the Brexit line, not when their financial wellbeing depends on the goodwill of those who distribute the cash! They deviate at their financial peril^

Where do you get this nonsense from, nellie?

As paddy points out, who in their right minds passes up a market of 500million people? Countries stay in the EU because it offers them a huge market on their doorstep which is easy to trade in. (In our case it is reckoned that for every £1 we pay to the EU we get £10 back in trade). Plus advantageous trade deals with non EU countries because that enormous market is very attractive to them.

MargaretX Fri 21-Sept-18 22:35:42

There is a lot which will be missed when Great Britain leaves and it is often discussed in Germany but it does not alter the situation that it is the wish of Britain to leave and that has been accepted here. Most people I meet at Bridge Club etc just shake their heads and ask me why they are leaving to which I reply I am not for Brexit - no way!

I am back in the Uk soon for a family visit and am not meeting up with an old school friend, because I dont want to sit over lunch and listen to all this Brexit nonsense.
My DD2 who works in science says they have several UK PhD students who are so anxious to get their thesis finished and face a dismal future which they did not vote for.

Most of the expats I know have applied for German citizenship but need to have been in Germany several years.
There is a strange unreal feeling about it all, alot of us travel via Calais by car when we visit the Uk and wonder if that is going to be still possible. I have renewed my passport and DD1 also and she has applied for my grandson as well. Better do it now before chaos breaks out.

petra Fri 21-Sept-18 23:00:55

MargaretX
Well all those continental lorries are going to have a problem 'when' they shut Calais.

Diana54 Sat 22-Sept-18 07:24:01

I don't think Brexit will happen, but if it does it will be the young, the vulnerable, the expats that will be most affected, because the future will be very uncertain. I really don't see any end to austerity if we leave, and it may get tighter due to less money in the economy.

A lot will depend on what Corbyn hatches up next week, if as has been mooted he gets a mandate for a second referendum, that will be a real problem for TM.

MawBroon Sat 22-Sept-18 08:56:27

– How rude of Donald Tusk, the president of the European Council, to put on Instagram that there were “no cherries” for Mrs May. How completely contradictory of EU behaviour too.
The 1992 Maastricht Treaty set out the financial principles for eurozone members, and the subsequent Stability Pact enjoined fines for members who break them. Budget deficits should have been no greater than 3 per cent of GDP, and total government debt no more than 60 per cent. Another provision permitted no bailouts of member states. Just about every member state broke these debt rules, and no fines were levied. There have been six individual bailouts.
The Schengen Agreement, which supports free movement of people, is currently suspended by six member states.
“Core” principles, apparently inviolate when it comes to Brexit, are ripely cherry-picked when it suits the EU.

lemongrove Sat 22-Sept-18 09:05:43

Absolutely Maw the EU is being so intransigent only because it fears any other members breaking away, not because of any precious rules!
I think there is an element of misogyny re Tusk and others they think they can get away with being like that with a woman PM. Regardless of gender though, to post a silly caption with a photo just after such a serious meeting is all part of the EU playing games.Thank God we are leaving.

petra Sat 22-Sept-18 09:25:15

MawBroon
Thank you for pointing that out.
I would like to add that 3 of the worst rule breakers are 3 of the 6 founding members: France, Germany, Italy.

MaizieD Sat 22-Sept-18 10:18:43

So, plunging the UK into economic catastrophe and reigniting The Troubles in NI are a worthwhile price to pay for leaving the EU?

To think that Remainers are accused of being unpatriotic.shock

You Leavers appal me

Anniebach Sat 22-Sept-18 10:25:40

So those who voted leave did so in the hope of reigniting the troubles in Northern Ireland ?

nigglynellie Sat 22-Sept-18 10:39:02

There are other Ports apart from Calais MargaretX, who by all reports are preparing for a surge in business. In any case lorries piling up the other side of the channel can't be a particularly attractive prospect for Calais either!!
Interesting post MawBroon but not surprising! So much hypocrisy-quite takes your breath away!! While I'm sure the EU considers itself a community of equals, but as we all know, some are more equal than others!!! Rules can be bent and broken if it suits by the more powerful who do hold the purse strings, look at Greece, a salutary warning to all you countries desperate to join these band of crooks, be careful what you wish for!

Smileless2012 Sat 22-Sept-18 10:55:18

Excellent post MawBroon, I read it out to Mr. S., he thought it was excellent too and he voted remain.

Diana54 Sat 22-Sept-18 11:35:49

Tusk, misogyny it's easy to throw sexism into the ring, not justified in this case TM is every bit as tough as any man, probably a tough as Thatcher, not that I'm applauding her.

I thought the cherries quip was funny but I understand why the Brexiteers didn't, in my view it reinforces the EU determination not to allow any deal that other states don't get. In the past there have been other special bailouts or refunds, they have been negotiated and allowed by agreement. The U.K. Does not seem to have any other countries supporting us, not one, so it's hard to be optimistic about the EU changing tack

MawBroon Sat 22-Sept-18 11:40:51

Sadly it seems Trump is not alone in government by Twitter.(add in Instagram)
Shame that a “Bon mot” and not even a particularly funny one should be Tusk’s apparent ambition. I thought things were a tad too serious for that.
Leave that sort of thing to the political cartoonists or Matt who never puts a foot wrong.

nigglynellie Sat 22-Sept-18 11:51:21

Of course other countries don't support us, they value their financial well being far too much!
The cartoon was just childish and not really worth reacting to! Government by Twitter? Well, I suppose being trendy is all important, but doesn't seem very statesman like to me!

paddyann Sat 22-Sept-18 11:53:02

conservative ( not a word that I like to use) estimates say Scotland will lose 80.000 jobs and £12.5 BILLION off the economy .Well done to those who want to go back to a world that never existed in the first place .Contary to the usual guff we're fed about our exports England is not the main trading partner and 52% of all Scottish exports are to the EU .Add that to the exodus of foreign nationals and watch the decline in the NHS etc .THIS country says get this mess sirted and if Mrs May is as incompetent as she appears to be then let someone else do the job .The court of Sessions is now sending the case for Scotland staying in the EU to the European Court of Justice .With a (forlorn) hope we can stop this farce before our economy is decimated .

MaizieD Sat 22-Sept-18 12:04:54

In the past there have been other special bailouts or refunds, they have been negotiated and allowed by agreement. The U.K. Does not seem to have any other countries supporting us, not one,

Bailouts and refunds (of which we were a huge beneficiary, remember the 'rebate'?) are an intra-EU matter. Of course they pull together over that.

WE are trying to be an ex-member state. Why would anyone expect the member states to support us in that aspiration?

The cartoon was just childish

What cartoon would that be, nelly? One that you clearly have not even seen....

Good article on Salzburg by Tom Connelly of RTE:

www.rte.ie/news/analysis-and-comment/2018/0921/995292-salzburg-chronic-misreading/

In the game of Jenga, competitors build a tower of identical wooden bricks, creating a new layer each time by deftly removing one block from below and placing it delicately on top.

The higher the tower rises, the more unstable it becomes, and the more skill is required to extract each new brick without bringing the whole structure down.

This aptly describes Theresa May’s Brexit strategy. Salzburg may well prove to be the clumsily extricated brick.

nigglynellie Sat 22-Sept-18 12:10:00

It was meant to have '....' round that word which didn't come out. Abject apologies MaisieD. Hope you'll forgive me!!

MaizieD Sat 22-Sept-18 12:16:44

That still doesn't make it a cartoon, nelly.

Have you seen it?

Jane10 Sat 22-Sept-18 12:23:49

Stop niggling!

MarthaBeck Sat 22-Sept-18 12:26:09

Sorry, but I totally disagree with Diana54. The referendum was a complete disaster. It has created bitterness right across the Country and we were not told the true facts. All this just to keep the RW Tory extremism at bay. Heads should roll but whoms?

We need to return to the status quo and be able to rebuild trust. I just cannot see May or Corbyn doing that unless the nation speaks. That is why I want a People’s vote.

varian Sat 22-Sept-18 12:33:00

I think it is high time that those who want to Remain in the EU, which includes the majority of MPs, stop saying "we must respect the result of the referendum".

I don't respect it. It was fraudulent, won by lies, millions of those most affected were disenfranchised, and it has now been clearly demonstrated that any kind of "delivery" of that result will cause irrevocable damage to our country.

Grandad1943 Sat 22-Sept-18 12:36:25

In the above posts the EU is accused of "bending the rules" as and when it suits them, and that is very true. It was true when the European Union allowed Britain to opt out of the Maximum Hours Regulations while all other member states signed up to the directive. Many have argued the opt-out has given Britain an unfair advantage in commercial competition within the EU.

As has also been pointed out the European Union had demonstrated flexibility in allowing Budget deficits to be greater than 3 per cent of GDP where member states have incurred financial difficulties and have requested such a facility. The foregoing demonstrates pragmatism within the EU Commission and Parliament to the credit of both bodies.

In allowing six member states to suspend the "free movement of Labour" then the crux of that situation is held in one word "SUSPEND". That allows for the freedom to be reinstated at any time should the EU commission or Parliament in consultation with the member state decide that it should be.

However, the above situation cannot be applied to the UK as we are leaving the European Union on a permanent basis, therefore, a suspension solution is impossible to apply. In that Britain wishes to withdraw from the EU while retaining the free movement of capital, goods and services but not the free movement of Labour. That is obviously unacceptable to the European Union on a permanent basis.

Many have asked why a free movement of labour suspension could not have been offered to Britain prior to the referendum? I believe that there is one answer to that, being David Cameron never stated the case for Britain being granted such a suspension.

Therefore the European Union is in the eyes of some dammed when they demonstrate flexibility in regard to member state treaty obligations and dammed when they do not as in the withdraw negotiations with Britain.

it may be a case of some on this forum wishing to have their cake and eat it, but perhaps finding there are no cherries on the top.

lemongrove Sat 22-Sept-18 12:43:33

They are doing all they can (EU) to make things as difficult as possible simply because they are scared of any other country trying to break free.Childish rhetoric and cartoons/tweets/ cherry picks etc from the EU side is just their games.All of which shows, for those who doubted it, that the EU aim is to become a vast State ruled by Brussels with Germany and France as top dogs and not as it’s original purpose just a trading bloc.
We can’t leave soon enough!

MawBroon Sat 22-Sept-18 13:02:41

it may be a case of some on this forum wishing to have their cake and eat it, but perhaps finding there are no cherries on the top

I fear Donald Tusk cracked that gag before you Grandad
#oldonesarethebestones