Gransnet forums

News & politics

Well that’s it. We’re not leaving the EU. The people in charge won’t allow it.

(184 Posts)
Kandinsky Wed 04-Sept-19 07:07:26

What the ‘people’ want counts for nothing.

I hope all the traitors & enemies of the people are happy. angry

gillybob Wed 04-Sept-19 08:10:35

I’m not sure Anja that the whole point behind all of this is to postpone, put off and not leave at all . If we can’t reach a perfect deal then we will not leave . Why don’t they just come out and say it ? “We want to remain so we will do everything in our powers to avoid leaving” There I said it for them . It really was quite easy.

Must dash now, the loos of industry won’t get cleaned while I play on Gransnet.

crystaltipps Wed 04-Sept-19 08:11:39

The country didn’t vote to leave with no deal. It’s arguable what is meant by “the country” or the sacred 17.4 m, what about the 55m of the population who didn’t vote for it? If it had been 75% population you might have a chance of persuading people it’s a good idea. As it is it’s a vocal minority of loud mouths with a hate message and war like rhetoric who are stirring people up and causing division.

crystaltipps Wed 04-Sept-19 08:12:28

It’s the extreme brexiteers who rejected the WA not the remainers btw.

Anja Wed 04-Sept-19 08:13:13

Arrogant Parliament? That would be funny if it wasn’t so far from the truth lemongrove. This recent chaos is due to Boris’s government trying to strip parliament of its powers. In any third work country that would be the way a dictator operates.

Well done those Tory rebels who sacrificed their political careers and livelihoods to stand up for democratic principles

crystaltipps Wed 04-Sept-19 08:13:52

I think most people would have gone with a Norway style deal as we were promised by the leave campaign as it is a compromise, but no it wasn’t Brexitty enough so the extremists rejected it. Don’t blame the remainers for all this mess.

notentirelyallhere Wed 04-Sept-19 08:17:35

If only people were taught more thoroughly about the English Civil War in the 17th century when Parliament fought for the people against the likes of Rees Mogg and his ilk. The latter want a no deal to boost their private income and investments.

Elected MPs are how democracy is organised in this country. How many times does it take for some to hear that referendums are ADVISORY. It's like imagining that instead of a local council we could organise bin day by a everyone having their say in a single vote! Thank god for Parliament and the ancient institutions of this country.

Whitewavemark2 Wed 04-Sept-19 08:17:36

crystal I think you are right. What has prevented us from leaving are about 40 extreme hard right politicians. Without their ultra- hard right stance I have no doubt that the U.K. would now be out on a moderate agreement.

notentirelyallhere Wed 04-Sept-19 08:19:35

I agree Whitewave, the ERG, the no deal hardliners have fought tooth and nail to avoid a deal.

Anja Wed 04-Sept-19 08:20:23

That’s exactly right WW2 and because of the slim majority held by May they were able to wield more power.

Whitewavemark2 Wed 04-Sept-19 08:20:39

Don’t forget, if this bill goes through IT WILL NEVER BE NEEDED IF JOHNSON GETS A DEAL BY 17th OCTOBER.

This is nothing about stopping Brexit but it is about stopping No Deal.

lemongrove Wed 04-Sept-19 08:21:24

Anja it’s pointless to quote what anybody said 3 years ago.
We are where we are, solely because MPs cannot accept leaving the EU.
They could have accepted T May’s ‘deal’ (WA) it was reasonable after all, but no, it was voted down three times.
Now they want another what? Six months, a year, extension after extension until they hope we all forget about it?
Taking no deal off the table means no better deal is forthcoming ( and MPs know this.)
It’s bad enough for everyone, but especially bad for
businesses.
An election soon would clear the way if Johnson wins it.

Whitewavemark2 Wed 04-Sept-19 08:23:47

I have absolutely no doubt whatsoever, that if we could take the extreme right cabal out of the equation we would be out if the EU

NanaandGrampy Wed 04-Sept-19 08:23:59

I wonder how it can be called democracy when the vote was made and yet we're not going anywhere ? If it had been the other way round it would have all been done and dusted by now.

Best of 3 anyone?

Grandad1943 Wed 04-Sept-19 08:24:23

Looking at the title of this thread it would seem that many believe that leaving the European Union with no-deal was no longer a prospect. However, nothing could be further from the facts.

It is today that having gained control of the order paper that MPs have to pass a bill through Parliament that will prevent Britain leaving without a deal. MPs will also have to agree on extending Britains leave date until the 31st of January to allow further leave agreement negotiations to take place.

In my view, today is far more crucial in its outcome for the United Kindom than any day in the last eighty years.

Anja Wed 04-Sept-19 08:27:23

Is there a statute of limitations on Boris’s lies then lemongrove ? How convenient for him!

lemongrove Wed 04-Sept-19 08:30:19

Anja there were lies all round 3 years ago on both sides,
It’s pointless anyone harking back to it.

Anja Wed 04-Sept-19 08:30:31

Exactly Grandad ...democracy in action.

Let us not forget that we do not have a written constitution so precedent is everything.

Anja Wed 04-Sept-19 08:31:12

I really cannot believe you wrote that lemongrass

Anja Wed 04-Sept-19 08:32:54

You are effectively saying that it is OK to have as our PM a habitual liar? That might be acceptable in the US but not here.,

lemongrove Wed 04-Sept-19 08:33:33

WWM2 I have no doubt that if the extreme left cabal were taken out of the LP (in Parliament,) that we would have an effective Opposition and one that voters felt able to actually vote for, but there you are, there are extremes now in both parties.

lemongrove Wed 04-Sept-19 08:34:22

That’s naive Anja.

BlueBelle Wed 04-Sept-19 08:34:43

OMG , it all beggars belief

Ginny42 Wed 04-Sept-19 08:35:06

Nothing said more about the contempt in which the Tories hold for the people of this country than Rees-Mogg looking so smug as he lounged on the front bench. What a disgraceful image of the Leader of the House. What is going on in that man's head?

BlueBelle Wed 04-Sept-19 08:36:23

Who EVER heard anyone complain about life within the EU before that bloody Cameron with his referendum that wasn’t even binding
As Will Self said not all leavers are racist but all racists are leavers

mcem Wed 04-Sept-19 08:36:36

In the midst of all the serious arguments about democracy I really wish there was some acknowledgment of the fact that they are speaking for some of the people - as crystal pointed out!
BJ, do not stand there and tell me I don't want a GE!
You neither know not care about what I want!

I take some comfort that there are still politicians who are prepared to put their careers on the line.
Removing the whip smacks of desperation!

Petulant child taking his toys home and not allowing his friends to play because they won't do as he tells them!