Gransnet forums

News & politics

Why are "Leavers" so angry?

(606 Posts)
trisher Fri 27-Sept-19 09:48:09

Watching Question Time, reading GN and listening to others the anger and ire of those who voted leave astounds me. They are it seems prepared to dump everything to get what they want. A constitution, a legal system, parliamentary democracy mean nothing to them. There is only one small party which is actually campaigning to stop Brexit. One will offer a referendum on a deal and one will (so Johnson says) get a better deal or leave with No Deal. So why are they so aggressive? I can only think that they are actually really upset about what they have done. That they realise the Brexit they were sold and voted for never really existed. That the complications of N. Ireland, the prospect of No Deal and huge shortages and the very real economic strictures have just dawned on them. But rather than admit they were misled and possiby wrong they are reacting by blaming everyone else. It's like a toddler promised pudding who knows he has to eat the main course first but is looking at what is being served and screaming "That's too much and I want my pudding NOW!"

MaizieD Fri 27-Sept-19 20:26:02

The fear mongering is to ensure they retain the status quo. Fat cats getting fatter from the workers.

But, rightly or wrongly, Remainers fear that Brexit offers them (the 'fat cats' ) an opportunity to call for removal of workers' rights that are guaranteed by EU legislation.

What were all the EU regulations that Leavers were so keen to abolish, then?

abbey Fri 27-Sept-19 20:26:28

Just as you are entitled to your opinion growstuff - and of course, yours is an opinion and not worth much either is it?

You see , thats what really makes me angry - how some people want to diminish others with their comments. An opinion is an opinion. It may or may not be backed by some facts or correspondence to reality but it is still an opinion and as such worth as much as any other opinion.

grapefruitpip Fri 27-Sept-19 20:26:52

Oh, I dunno, it's all horrible the bickering. the hatred. I'm so afraid about the future. Where has kindness gone?

Must get off this damn thing tomorrow.

jura2 Fri 27-Sept-19 20:29:47

abbey, and yet, again - no-one answers questions- never.

So please, do:

'What were all the EU regulations that Leavers were so keen to abolish, then?'

we have had bent bananas- but can you please help us here with a list, or at least one- such Laws?

Thomas Cook's customers have all been repatriated and will be compensated by ATOL - they will NOT be after Brexit.

abbey Fri 27-Sept-19 20:30:16

What were all the EU regulations that Leavers were so keen to abolish, then?

One I would like to see abolished ( although I doubt it will be ) is the raising of the pension age and especially the raising of the pension age for women which was a direct result of the equalising of pension ages across the EU.
I bet a lot of WASPI women would like to see that too - taking their pension age back to 65 instead of 66 for many.

The fact is that there was never any comment made by any document I read that said any EU rules would be abolished in that way.

growstuff Fri 27-Sept-19 20:33:45

Try looking at Paula Sherriff's Wiki profile now Urmstongran and look at the edit history. It was hacked and the hack has now been deleted. Fake news and you fell for it.

abbey Fri 27-Sept-19 20:34:34

I ran a business for a number of year before I decided to sell it on. It was a moderately successful business but not wildly making money or anything.

The main reason I gave it up was because of the number of regulations and restrictive practices that iminged on my making more progress and growing my business. It simply was not worth the long hours and additional taxes I had to pay to the EU in order to trade with customers outside the EU.

As for customers inside the EU, well they were few and again, there were many rules which stopped me competing with EU counterparts. It was a cartel. Prices were fixed by the EU .

I believe in free trade and free competiton and market forces. The EU believes in some kind of EUtopia where everyone is kept the same.

Joelsnan Fri 27-Sept-19 20:34:46

MaizieD
I think you will find that EU employment legislation was mainly derived from UK employment law that was embedded as statute.
You will also find that UK far exceeds the minimum requirements for most benefits.
You must know that it was British unions that fought for these benefits. That it was potentially your and my grand or great grandparents who fought for these rights.
Are we now so weak and snowflakey that we could not either use the UK electoral system or other to retain or improve these conditions?

growstuff Fri 27-Sept-19 20:35:52

No abbey I wouldn't and I'm one of the first WASPI women to be affected. There was absolutely no argument that the pension ages for men and women should have been equalised. Why shouldn't they be equal?

MaizieD Fri 27-Sept-19 20:38:01

Actually, even the ancient Greeks ( the first democrats) acknowledged that those ticks in boxes ( or in their case balls in a jar) were the foundation of all democracy and needed to be honoured, even if they did not like it.

Nothing particularly perfect about ancient Greek democracy, abbey where women and slaves weren't allowed any part in decision making. Our concept of democracy has moved on a great deal since then to be more inclusive and more embracing of minority views.

What was appropriate for small populations in city states is not appropriate for entire countries comprising millions of people.

growstuff Fri 27-Sept-19 20:38:39

abbey I have a friend with a multi-million pound business, which imports/exports with the EU as well as trading with EU customers and it's not what she says. That's why she's relocated to Italy.

abbey Fri 27-Sept-19 20:39:32

I am not sure why you want me to answer Jura because I have never made a comment about wanting to abolish or expecting any existing rules of the EU to be abolished on Brexit.

I see it more as an opportunity to make deals outside of the EU restrictions - that means being competitive and making money in my business book...... but I say again, I am not having this conversation with you. I have never had it with you. You must be thinking of someone else.

I have many reasons for wanting to leave the EU ..... but you havent touched on any of them really yet. Just clipped one there with restrictive business rules and practices though and the way in which those rules can quickly asset strip a business and stop it being profitable.

MaizieD Fri 27-Sept-19 20:40:23

Joelsnan

I've heard all of that before but, in the face of 'leaders' who are determined to do away with much of it how do you propose to ensure that such rights are retained?

GracesGranMK3 Fri 27-Sept-19 20:41:07

Changes in pensions is not an EU regulation it is a Tory party policy Abbey. Where, oh where did you get the idea it was. The EU has nothing to do with this. Have you ever checked whether the things you don't like a actually had anything to do with the EU?

I could weep, really I could. You are taking away so much that is good based on false knowledge.

abbey Fri 27-Sept-19 20:41:17

growstuff - different business models have different needs. I was trying to work in markets outside of the EU - that was where the growth was. The EU had nothing to offer me or my business.

The EU are not good for all kinds of business. They are restrictive.

abbey Fri 27-Sept-19 20:46:42

I am sorry Graces GRan but you need to check your facts. the British government changed the pension rules to come into line with the EU .

You see, there are lots of rules you think were made by the Tories ( which they were ) but they were made because we were in the EU. Pensions is one of them

On a different note - vacuum cleaners. Restrictions on the power of vacuum cleaner motors were EU regs written into British law. Of course you might want to blame the great Saint Thunberg .

I could list tons of EU regs written into British law. You never realise how extensive the dictats have been .

One I came up against when I was trying to expand my business was that I was not allowed to buy from the cheapest supplier who could provide my quality spec because the EU said I had to buy from their preferred buyer ( one they had a "deal" with) . That meant I couldnt be competitive in the market place with my sale price.

MaizieD Fri 27-Sept-19 20:47:03

^ The EU had nothing to offer me or my business.^

Well, that's fair enough, abbey but why should your choice be imposed on businesses that thrive on trade within the EU and whose owners and employees are losing their livelihoods as a result of the Leave vote?

In what way is the EU restrictive for your business if you were trading outside it?

abbey Fri 27-Sept-19 20:50:08

I too could weep for all the nasty things that the EU have done to me personally across the last 40 years of my life. I havent found anything yet that the EU has done for me that was good. The ways it has impacted on me has been negative.

I looked at the potential for the future and realised that that any future in the EU was never going to be good. What are our children going to do in an EU which has too much surpluses and little need of them?

I do not think you have fully understood what the EU is really about. You certainly havent seen the side I have clearly.

abbey Fri 27-Sept-19 20:51:52

Far more businesses suffer under the EU than are doing well. Big business does well. Smaller ones do not. In the end it comes down to who is going to employ those who are not the business makers?

Out in the big world there are many opportunities. In the little EU world - comparatively - there is no real future.

Urmstongran Fri 27-Sept-19 20:52:00

Thanks growstuff

I only fell for it because I genuinely didn’t know Wikipedia could be hacked.

Who else knows this? Is it just me showing my ignorance here?

abbey Fri 27-Sept-19 20:53:34

In what way is the EU restrictive for your business if you were trading outside it?

I have answered this. Clearly you didnt bother reading it.
I am not going to keep on.

abbey Fri 27-Sept-19 20:59:44

Please Daisy, get an education. In the times of the ancient Greeks more than 60% of the population were slaves. Most of the " free population" were in fact little better off as they were classed as " Non Persons". You had to be elite to be part of the democratic process. But that has been the case for most of history.

Britain was one of the first countries to move from that model.

However I dont know why I am bothering because if you were to read your Greek you would know exactly how the EU would like to treat you in its new world "democracy" where no one votes for anything, leaders are appointed , not elected and any votes are a rubber stamp.

Talk about turkeys voting for Christmas? Clearly remainers want to live in the world of elites and serfs again anyway. Thats the model the EU is moving to and the one you seem to want.

abbey Fri 27-Sept-19 21:01:24

You keep talking about rights Maizie - what are those "rights" you so desperately want to sell your soul to keep?

You havent said what they are. You just keep saying how you will be robbed of them.

MamaCaz Fri 27-Sept-19 21:04:07

You are wrong abbey.

This quote is from an official Works and Pensions document:

8 Equality in State Pension Age, Cm 2420, December 1993 and HL Deb, 24 January 1995, col. 977. There is a misconception that state pension age equalisation was required under European law. In fact, there was a specific derogation for state pensions in Council Directive (EEC) 79/7 on the progressive implementation of the principle of equal treatment for men and women in matters of social security.

GracesGranMK3 Fri 27-Sept-19 21:04:41

Who is Daisy. Nice name; it was my grandmother's middle name.