Gransnet forums

News & politics

Royalist is our post-Brexit religion

(109 Posts)
Blossoming Fri 21-May-21 11:19:25

Other viewpoints are available.

inews.co.uk/opinion/meghan-harry-mental-health-series-vicious-response-royalism-post-brexit-religion-1007433

Alegrias1 Fri 21-May-21 11:25:03

Excellent article Blossoming.

Hope you've got your hard hat on.

Oopsadaisy1 Fri 21-May-21 11:46:57

Well I guess that she is entitled to her opinion, but it isn’t mine.

Smileless2012 Fri 21-May-21 11:53:28

I second that Oopsadaisy.

Gannygangan Fri 21-May-21 11:55:51

Yasmin is a very vocal Republican and is entitled to her views. She was a regular on Jeremy Vine but hasn't been on very much recently. She had a row with the odious Laurence Fox. I agreed with her then.

Republicans will agree and repost articles like this.

I don't agree with this article but no need for a hard hat. I'm quite happy for people to have opposing views.

Buffybee Fri 21-May-21 11:57:23

Never heard of her but she’s entitled to her opinion.
Not mine though!

Smileless2012 Fri 21-May-21 11:58:28

"I don't agree with this article but no need for a hard hat. I'm quite happy for people to have opposing views" well said Gannygangan, a view shared by the majority I think.

eazybee Fri 21-May-21 11:59:47

I have heard of her and listened to her on occasion, but rarely share her views.

Anniebach Fri 21-May-21 12:02:03

She can recover from the death of a loved one in 40 days, good for her.

A child walking behind his mothers coffin is one of the saddest
things she has seen ,lucky her, the saddest thing I have seen is
mothers clawing through pit sludge to find the bodies of their
children.

Smileless2012 Fri 21-May-21 12:05:40

Your post certainly puts things into perspective Anniesmile.

3nanny6 Fri 21-May-21 12:08:16

Is that the lady that was often on the panel of Jeremy Vine? she
was often vocal on some of the discussions on his show and things at times became heated. I stopped watching that show now it was always about Covid. Yasmin is welcome to her opinions which are not shared by everyone else including myself.

Peasblossom Fri 21-May-21 12:08:32

I’m a bit non pluses by the connection with Brexit and religion.

Was European membership a religion?

What’s it called in literature when you link two entirely unconnected things to make an oddity?

Peasblossom Fri 21-May-21 12:08:49

nonplussed

EllanVannin Fri 21-May-21 12:18:41

I like Yasmin. Some things I've agreed with some I haven't but it's never put me off the woman whatever her views are.

However, * Annie* summed this up for me. People really do need something to think and worry about !

Grany Fri 21-May-21 20:40:31

@tompeck
We could just, like, not have the royal family you know. Then we wouldn’t have to have all this absolute madness all the time. It is an option. Just putting it out there.

@keith091270
Maybe the concept of one family being the peak of British society isn’t fit for purpose. Maybe that’s the problem.

Young British people want to abolish the monarchy in dramatic shift of public opinion, survey shows

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/british-abolish-monarchy-survey-queen-b1851243.html

Alegrias1 Fri 21-May-21 20:44:11

Hope springs eternal Grany. One day!

Callistemon Fri 21-May-21 20:48:44

I do enjoy her articles mostly.

But this one is a load of piffle or perhaps it's just that no-one I know relates to these views.

Smileless2012 Fri 21-May-21 20:49:05

With 53% of those aged 15 - 49 supporting the monarchy, it's unlikely to happen.

Alegrias1 Fri 21-May-21 20:53:03

I wouldn't pin my hopes to that Smileless2012.

A YouGov survey indicates that at least 41 per cent of people aged 18 to 24 preferred an elected head of the state as compared to 31 who wanted a king or a queen.

This is, in fact, a complete reversal of what the majority wanted two years ago. Back then, the survey had found that at least 46 per cent preferred the monarchy and only 26 per cent wanted it gone.

The YouGov survey of 4,870 adults – between the ages of 15 to 49 — also revealed that at least 53 per cent supported the monarchy. This is five percentage points down from a similar survey in 2019.

It's trends, not absolutes that are important here. The young are starting to see what the reality is and things are changing.

Gannygangan Fri 21-May-21 21:04:35

When I was young I didn't care about the Royals. No interest at all. Most of my peers would have felt the same.

However, now I'm getting on a bit I'm quite happy to have a monarchy.

The young are starting to see what the reality is and things are changing.

Just what I would have said in my late teens, early 20s, Alegrias1

Callistemon Fri 21-May-21 21:09:27

When I was very young I made a Princess Elizabeth and Pricess Margaret scrapbook.

Now I'm more mature I appreciate the relative stability of a Monarchy as Head of State and the continuity of the thread through the centuries, but I wish all the various superfluous parts of it would just disappear into the sunset and shut up.

Callistemon Fri 21-May-21 21:13:54

Princess Margaret!!

I must have been about 6 or 7.

Now I'm a bit older I do not have rose tinted spectacles but a more reasoned view of of the world and the cost effectiveness and stability of a Monarchy -v- an ever changing and possibly
politically-biased head of state.

Grany Fri 21-May-21 21:22:55

I will say this again. A president would cost a fraction of the monarchy which stands at £345 million and rising. But it's not just the cost it's the principle.

A president would have to be political neutral unlike the monarchy who has a veto on our laws.

Something like the president in Ireland or

Or like our Bundes President here in Germany. A very well respected figure head, whose sole purpose is to welcome foreign heads of state, represent Germany abroad and sign his/her name on bills which have passed both houses. The only difference between Michael D. Higgins and our president, Frank-Walther Steinmaier, is that MDH was elected by the electorate, whereas Steinmaier was nominated by and elected by our elected representatives in the Bundestag. The roles are the same though and both do an excellent job, IMO. The fact that they have limited terms of office is a good thing too. The Monarchie in the UK is a waste of space and money and is an anachronism in the 21st century.

lemongrove Fri 21-May-21 21:42:58

I always thought that you were a UK resident Grany as you were/are so fond of Jeremy Corbyn.

lemongrove Fri 21-May-21 21:49:38

Gannygangan

When I was young I didn't care about the Royals. No interest at all. Most of my peers would have felt the same.

However, now I'm getting on a bit I'm quite happy to have a monarchy.

The young are starting to see what the reality is and things are changing.

Just what I would have said in my late teens, early 20s, Alegrias1

The young Aleg are far more interested in texting each other, watching tv, reading blogs by airhead celebs, clothes shopping, eating take aways and screaming with laughter down their mobile phones at what their friends say.
And who can blame them??