Gransnet forums

News & politics

Another ‘oh Jeremy Corbyn’ movement? ?

(116 Posts)
Urmstongran Mon 10-Jan-22 10:34:01

Jeremy Corbyn is considering establishing his own political party after privately accepting he will never be reinstated as a Labour MP, The Telegraph understands.

The former Labour leader has been urged by many in his inner circle, including his wife Laura Alvarez, to upgrade his charity into a political party, and run under its banner at the next election.

M0nica Mon 10-Jan-22 19:41:52

I think it will be a damp squib. The number of people, who will vote for him will be few. General elections are not byelections. Very few will vote for a party hung round an ex leader of any party who has been soundly trounced in the previous general election.

Most of his supporters were fair weather friends, carried away in the excitement of him leading the Labour party. Any way there were still not enough of them at any point to swing even one seat. He just might keep his own, but I doubt it.

I have lost count of the number of parties that have been set up over the last 50 years, in a froth of excitement and belief that THEY were the way forward - and have lasted a year at the most.

There is of course UKIP and the Green party, but Jeremy Corbyn lacks the chutzpa, and charismatic nastiness that made Nigel Farage such a hit - and even he never won a seat in Parliament, in fact UKIP never had one elected MP, only one who changed parties, and the the Green's have only had 1.

MaizieD Mon 10-Jan-22 21:04:07

^ The Corbyn Monentum gang don’t accept this country will never elect a party run by someone the believe to be ‘extreme’ left ie communist.^

I really think it's time that people were aware of what 'communism' actually is. Because nothing about Labour under the leadership of Corbyn was remotely 'communist'.

M0nica Mon 10-Jan-22 22:33:06

I quite agree with you Maizie. Communism is quite different to socialism.

Iam64 Tue 11-Jan-22 07:40:56

MaizieD - I agree the LP under Corbyn’s leadership was in no way communist.

GagaJo Tue 11-Jan-22 08:16:45

MaizieD

^ The Corbyn Monentum gang don’t accept this country will never elect a party run by someone the believe to be ‘extreme’ left ie communist.^

I really think it's time that people were aware of what 'communism' actually is. Because nothing about Labour under the leadership of Corbyn was remotely 'communist'.

Exactly MaizieD. But it's a lazy way of insulting those of us on the left isn't it? It would be equalled by a left-winger called right-wingers Nazis.

Neither is true.

love0c Tue 11-Jan-22 08:47:32

I think Corbyn is one very deluded man.

GagaJo Tue 11-Jan-22 10:13:41

Idealistic rather than deluded.

What are Boris' ideals? Personal gain.

I know which I prefer.

MaizieD Tue 11-Jan-22 10:21:21

GagaJo

MaizieD

^ The Corbyn Monentum gang don’t accept this country will never elect a party run by someone the believe to be ‘extreme’ left ie communist.^

I really think it's time that people were aware of what 'communism' actually is. Because nothing about Labour under the leadership of Corbyn was remotely 'communist'.

Exactly MaizieD. But it's a lazy way of insulting those of us on the left isn't it? It would be equalled by a left-winger called right-wingers Nazis.

Neither is true.

I don't really read it as an insult, GagaJo. After all the communist ideas and ideals were aspirational initially; it was their execution that inevitably failed because they failed to take account of human nature and the immensity (and futility) of the task of revolutionising a whole social order and economy.

I think it's a scare label used by people wo are actually ignorant of what communism actually is. Picked up from McCarthyism, I suspect, and never questioned.

GagaJo Tue 11-Jan-22 15:36:54

I take your point MaizieD. But it's intended as an insult. I really just wish the right-wing on here could pick an actual real fault of the left wing and use that, instead of lazily resorting to completely untrue stereotypes. Lack of thought. Does that mean lack of political understanding?

Grany Tue 11-Jan-22 16:04:54

Several of Keir Starmer’s advisors have confessed that the Labour Party is now on the verge of bankruptcy.

After less than two years in office, Keir Starmer has turned a bank account of around £13 million into bankruptcy.

And he was the Great White Hope of neoliberal right-wing Labour – the “any other leader” who was going to revitalise the party’s popularity and put it 20 points ahead of the Tories in the polls.

Labour is ahead of the Tories in some polls (just!) – but only because corrupt Conservative prime minister Boris Johnson has disgraced himself by breaking the rules he himself imposed on the people of the UK.

How did Starmer drag Labour to this new low?

Partly by launching a wrong-headed crusade against left-wingers/socialist party members, under the guise of attacking anti-Semitism. We all know it’s a false flag because he has been expelling left-wing Jews.

Court cases both by and against Labour, due to this outrageous behaviour, have cost the party millions.

And ordinary members have been deserting the party, having realised that Starmer is turning it back into a tepid version of the Tories that they simply won’t support.

What better example of this behaviour could we have than Starmer’s response to a vote on the Tory Welfare Cap on Monday (January 10)?

There was a vote last night on capping Govt spending on welfare .Most Labour MPs (183 ) abstained
Only 14 Labour MPs voted against.

Only 14 Labour MPs voted against the Wefare Bill.
The main changes in the Bill are reducing the household welfare cap from £26,000 to £23,000, abolishing legally binding child poverty targets, cuts to child tax credits, cuts to ESA, and cuts to housing benefit for young people

What a shocking indictment against Labour – the party that was set up to stand up for common people everywhere!

You can probably work out most of the Labour MPs who voted against the plan to restrict benefits to poverty levels and increase child poverty, but here’s the list:

Apsana Begum, Richard Burgon, Ian Byrne, Dan Carden, Margaret Greenwood, Kate Hollern, Kim Johnson, Ian Lavery, Andy McDonald, John McDonnell, Bell Ribeiro-Addy, Marie Rimmer, Zarah Sultana, and Beth Winter.

Jeremy Corbyn and Claudia Webbe also voted against it but of course Starmer has thrown them out of his Parliamentary party for no good reason.

183 Labour MPs abstained, including Starmer himself and his Shadow Work and Pensions Secretary Jonathan Ashworth – indicating tacit support for the harm the Tory measures will inflict on vulnerable people across the UK.

That is why Labour is nearly bankrupt: if Starmer won’t stand up for us, we can’t support him.

MaizieD Tue 11-Jan-22 16:05:02

It's tribalism I think, GagaJo.

Devorgilla Tue 11-Jan-22 16:32:22

Take heart, Grany. At least JC can probably count on those 14 current Labour MPs standing under his banner at the next election.
One of the main reasons Labour is low in funding is that we lost out on the 'short' money given to the Opposition for every seat they win to help them be an effective opposition. Unfortunately the 2019 election didn't deliver for Labour.
I am waiting to see who will join JC's party from the Parliamentary ranks. Personally, I believe very, very few. It's hard to give up a safe seat and fight under a new banner. You just never know which way that bloody minded electorate will vote.

lemongrove Tue 11-Jan-22 17:22:04

Calistemon

I'm quite excited and we should be helping by thinking of names for the new party!

Suggestions on a postcard please

Here is my suggestion on a postcard:

The Raving Loony Turnip Party

Germanshepherdsmum Tue 11-Jan-22 17:25:52

I’ll second that Lemon. Excellent suggestion.

Calistemon Tue 11-Jan-22 17:31:00

lemongrove

Calistemon

I'm quite excited and we should be helping by thinking of names for the new party!

Suggestions on a postcard please

Here is my suggestion on a postcard:

The Raving Loony Turnip Party

?
Too close to the Official Monster Raving Loony Party, I'm afraid.
And there would be too many heated discussions about when is a turnip not a turnip, when is it a swede?

More suggestions please.

GillT57 Tue 11-Jan-22 17:32:51

Why turnips?

Peasblossom Tue 11-Jan-22 17:33:49

The Contempt for the “Bloody-minded Electorate” Party.

That’s how I feel about it anyway.

Yes, and the other party too. Nothing to choose between them in that respect

GagaJo Tue 11-Jan-22 17:35:09

As I said MaizieD, no actual thought going on.

Peasblossom Tue 11-Jan-22 17:35:23

Calistemon

lemongrove

Calistemon

I'm quite excited and we should be helping by thinking of names for the new party!

Suggestions on a postcard please

Here is my suggestion on a postcard:

The Raving Loony Turnip Party

?
Too close to the Official Monster Raving Loony Party, I'm afraid.
And there would be too many heated discussions about when is a turnip not a turnip, when is it a swede?

More suggestions please.

Turnips are brassicas and swedes are roots,

Quite different.

I thought everyone knew that?

Calistemon Tue 11-Jan-22 17:37:49

Turnips are brassicas and swedes are roots

Try arguing that down in Devon!!

Lincslass Tue 11-Jan-22 18:10:23

ˋJeremy Corbyn and Claudia Webbe also voted against it but of course Starmer has thrown them out of his Parliamentary party for no good reason.´
Claudia Webbe convicted of harassment, criminal
Corbyn, accused of anti semetism, asked to apologise
www.thelondoneconomic.com/news/sarwar-calls-on-corbyn-to-apologise-to-jewish-community-as-one-msps-calls-for-whip-to-be-restored-307742/ Two good reasons why Starmer got rid of them.

Lincslass Tue 11-Jan-22 18:19:13

GagaJo

I take your point MaizieD. But it's intended as an insult. I really just wish the right-wing on here could pick an actual real fault of the left wing and use that, instead of lazily resorting to completely untrue stereotypes. Lack of thought. Does that mean lack of political understanding?

How is this for a story then, apart from the antisemetism rumours that still circulate
apple.news/AyGbJmLxBRYGDq5c3KbhGzg

Germanshepherdsmum Tue 11-Jan-22 18:27:23

I assume his Marxist friend John (Bleed 'em all dry) McDonnell will continue to be his best friend in this new party. God help us if we have a penny to our names.

GagaJo Tue 11-Jan-22 18:30:00

Germanshepherdsmum

I assume his Marxist friend John (Bleed 'em all dry) McDonnell will continue to be his best friend in this new party. God help us if we have a penny to our names.

We don't now. So no difference there then.

JaneJudge Tue 11-Jan-22 18:34:42

Will it be the jam and allotment party v's the cheese, wine and biscuits party and she had a gin
confused