Galaxy
Only if you set higher standards for immigrants than you do for others which is what James o Brien did. It is I am afraid one of the dangers of identity politics. He saw everything she said through the prism of her identity so to speak. It makes some people very cross if people from certain groups wont behave in the way those people think they should.
He did, And it makes perfect sense to me.
Remember Arthur Miller's 'View from the Bridge'
about one wave of Italian immigrants turning against a later wave of italian immigrants. First lot had found a place in society, after a lot of pain, but didn't want that next wave to upset the apple-cart.
A large proportion of Lepen's supporters in France are 2nd, 3rd generation Italians, Spanish, Polish, etc, immigrants. Same reaction. And yes, their parents, grandparent's origins are relevant. Totally. Because they, fo all people, should know what it feels like.
Same for anyone whose family has been discriminated or abused.