Gransnet forums

News & politics

This government has me puzzled

(180 Posts)
Cabowich Mon 22-Dec-25 12:43:43

On the one hand we have headlines such as 'Government rolls back nature protection to boost housing' next to the wonderful headlines on banning trail hunting, banning electric shock collars, chicken cages, banning shooting of hares during breeding season, etc, etc.

If Labour's plans for the extra animal welfare measures actually come to fruition that would be so, so good. But I fear they'll have a battle on their hands from sick people who either put profits first, or who love to kill for sport.

StoneofDestiny Wed 24-Dec-25 14:39:40

So you didn’t experience the Thatcher years when none of us knew from one month to the next if we were going to lose our jobs?

We are still trying to sort out Thatchers mess and attitude. Selling off the council houses to buy votes for Tories - a huge affordable housing shortage and exploring in buy to let. The growth of privatisation, with shareholder profits over investment in essential public services. The shutting of industrial plants with no new replacement industries located in the areas. Her attitude to Europe - how that hostility grew and we all suffer from the fall out of Brexit.

Mollygo Wed 24-Dec-25 15:01:38

Allira

^The far-right currently feed people's feelings.^

Why assume anyone who is against some of the unwise policies of this Government is far-right? They might even be Labour MPs, members of the public with common sense and can see the potentially disastrous consequences of such policies.

Some may even have voted for this Government.
Some even stood for Parliament to represent the Labour Party but are watching some of the decisions the Government makes with a clearer eye and common sense and can see how wrong they are.

All your paragraphs are so true.
Far right (according to some posters on here and elsewhere in the media) is anyone who disagrees with them, or with Labour.

Some did vote for this government, but it doesn’t make them blind to the errors.

There are Labour members of Parliament who don’t agree with the decisions being made and make their feelings known.

Deciding to look into it does sound better than being compelled to back down, but it’s a U turn just the same.
That the flip has been brought about by party members is the most impressive thing .

Allira Wed 24-Dec-25 15:01:51

an improved NHS

Good grief!!

Does the NHS prescribe rose-tinted spectacles under Labour now?

Allira Wed 24-Dec-25 15:03:33

Some did vote for this government, but it doesn’t make them blind to the errors.

Mea culpa, Mollygo

Allira Wed 24-Dec-25 15:04:52

That the flip has been brought about by party members is the most impressive thing

Yes, absolutely.
I presume the ones who know about farming and rural affairs. Not all Labour MPs are members of the metropolitan elite.

DaisyAnneReturns Wed 24-Dec-25 15:10:57

David49

Allira

I can't remember if putting IHT on farms was in the Manifesto or not and don't have time to trawl through atm.

Can anyone remember?

It wasn’t in the agenda nor was increasing employers NI and many other changes.

No. It was a Buget Policy.

Allira Wed 24-Dec-25 15:17:07

Thanks!

DaisyAnneReturns Wed 24-Dec-25 15:55:55

I think you misunderstand the general definition of far-right politics Mollygo. This may help:

EXTREME NATIONALISM
Far-right politics strongly emphasizes the nation, often defining it in ethnic, cultural, or religious terms rather than civic ones. This can include ideas that some groups “belong” more than others.
AUTHORITARIAN TENDENCIES
Far-right movements often support strong leaders, strict law-and-order policies, and limits on democratic checks and balances, civil liberties, or independent institutions (like courts or the press).
EXCLUSIONARY OR HIERARCHICAL VIEWS
They commonly promote the idea that society should be organized hierarchically, opposing equality based on race, ethnicity, religion, gender, or sexuality. This can show up as racism, xenophobia, or anti-immigrant attitudes.
OPPOSITION TO LIBERAL DEMOCRACY
Many far-right ideologies reject key elements of liberal democracy, such as pluralism, minority rights, and protections for dissent. Some seek to replace democracy with authoritarian or ethnocratic systems.
POPULISM (often present, but not always)
Far-right groups often frame politics as a struggle between “the real people” and corrupt elites, media, or institutions, claiming to represent the nation’s “true will.”
TRADITIONALISM
They frequently advocate for strict social norms, opposing progressive changes related to gender roles, LGBTQ+ rights, or multiculturalism.

IMPORTANT DISTINCTION
Right-wing politics broadly supports free markets, limited government, tradition. Far-right politics goes beyond this by rejecting equality, pluralism, or democratic norms and promoting exclusion or authoritarianism.

So no, personally I don't see it as "anyone who disagrees" and I am sure Labour, and their supporters, can look after themselves.

Greciangirl Wed 24-Dec-25 15:59:11

Please just try and remember that labour have inherited a corrupt Tory government.

They can’t just wave a magic wand as you are all aware.

Ok, some decisions don’t or won’t suit everyone.
I personally don’t agree with the lifting of the two child benefit.

But I’m prepared to stick with this government rather than see a Tory or reform government getting in.

fancythat Wed 24-Dec-25 16:12:40

Please just try and remember that labour have inherited a corrupt Tory government.

All governments "inherit" from the previous one.
They cant all get off the hook that way!

Mollygo Wed 24-Dec-25 16:29:54

DaisyAnneReturns

I think you misunderstand the general definition of far-right politics Mollygo. This may help:

EXTREME NATIONALISM
Far-right politics strongly emphasizes the nation, often defining it in ethnic, cultural, or religious terms rather than civic ones. This can include ideas that some groups “belong” more than others.
AUTHORITARIAN TENDENCIES
Far-right movements often support strong leaders, strict law-and-order policies, and limits on democratic checks and balances, civil liberties, or independent institutions (like courts or the press).
EXCLUSIONARY OR HIERARCHICAL VIEWS
They commonly promote the idea that society should be organized hierarchically, opposing equality based on race, ethnicity, religion, gender, or sexuality. This can show up as racism, xenophobia, or anti-immigrant attitudes.
OPPOSITION TO LIBERAL DEMOCRACY
Many far-right ideologies reject key elements of liberal democracy, such as pluralism, minority rights, and protections for dissent. Some seek to replace democracy with authoritarian or ethnocratic systems.
POPULISM (often present, but not always)
Far-right groups often frame politics as a struggle between “the real people” and corrupt elites, media, or institutions, claiming to represent the nation’s “true will.”
TRADITIONALISM
They frequently advocate for strict social norms, opposing progressive changes related to gender roles, LGBTQ+ rights, or multiculturalism.

IMPORTANT DISTINCTION
Right-wing politics broadly supports free markets, limited government, tradition. Far-right politics goes beyond this by rejecting equality, pluralism, or democratic norms and promoting exclusion or authoritarianism.

So no, personally I don't see it as "anyone who disagrees" and I am sure Labour, and their supporters, can look after themselves.

Love your very wordy non-explanation DEAR. The fact that on GN and other media far right is instantly used to describe anyone who disagrees with something Labour does or disagrees with certain posters is indisputable.
As exemplified on here. 🤣🤣🤣

Mollygo Wed 24-Dec-25 16:31:47

Will I get another message from GNHQ for daring to point that out. 🤔

Etoile2701 Wed 24-Dec-25 16:34:14

Hear hear!

Barbadosbelle Wed 24-Dec-25 16:44:18

.

I would think that the Government should be concentrating on the more important matters that they have on their plate.
..

Allira Wed 24-Dec-25 16:48:27

fancythat

^Please just try and remember that labour have inherited a corrupt Tory government.^

All governments "inherit" from the previous one.
They cant all get off the hook that way!

😁

Barbadosbelle Wed 24-Dec-25 16:51:06

Nanna8

One does wonder.

David49 Wed 24-Dec-25 16:51:09

“I think you misunderstand the general definition of far-right politics Mollygo. This may help:

EXTREME NATIONALISM” Etc. Etc Ect

That equally applies to Extreme Left wing politics and any other intolerant regime

Susieq62 Wed 24-Dec-25 16:51:34

Mollygo well done
This exemplifies our tabloid press so succinctly!

Nanacool Wed 24-Dec-25 16:55:19

Usual uninformed rubbish. Hunts follow an artificial scent, either dragged by a runner or quad. Perhaps you should attend a meet, as I have many times and have never seen anything killed. Hundreds of animals are killed by cars, perhaps we should ban them and just don't jet me on the subject of halal meat, but of course they are liebers core voters.

Allira Wed 24-Dec-25 16:59:10

I think you misunderstand the general definition of far-right politics Mollygo

I think we do understand the general definition of far-right politics, DAR and we can all Google, copy and paste too.

But those definitions in your post do not always coincide with some of the claims made on GN.

Even those who generally vote Liberal Democratic, occasionally straying to Labour or the Tories, have been accusing of peddling far-right views.

Allira Wed 24-Dec-25 17:03:02

Nanacool

Usual uninformed rubbish. Hunts follow an artificial scent, either dragged by a runner or quad. Perhaps you should attend a meet, as I have many times and have never seen anything killed. Hundreds of animals are killed by cars, perhaps we should ban them and just don't jet me on the subject of halal meat, but of course they are liebers core voters.

The Government claims that trail hunting is just a smokescreen for the hunting of wild animals and plans to ban that too.
I'm not sure how much illegal hunting still goes on.

Perhaps stopping people galloping on horses across the countryside in gatherings of more than two might be the only answer.

leeds22 Wed 24-Dec-25 17:13:50

Whilst it is good news that cruel faming practices are to be banned but will imports of food still being produced using same cruel practices be banned. Or will our farmers find themselves being undercut by 'cruel' imports.

Having watched a a few hunt gatherings, the words of Oscar Wilde always spring to mind - the unspeakable in pursuit of the uneatable'.

Doodledog Wed 24-Dec-25 17:35:58

I certainly don't see anyone who disagrees with the government, or with the LP in opposition as far right. I criticise them myself, and am further to the left than to the right.

I do, however, see much of the media as far right, and I despair when I hear parroted phrases that have clearly come from the tabloids/Telegraph (which is as bad) and/or the right wing TV. I'm thinking of 'rabbit in the headlights', 'Two Tier Keir', 'on its knees', 'off a cliff' and many many more. It's even worse when the parroters seem to think they are being witty when they repeat others' terms to 'make points' that don't really exist.

Facile terms like those are a gift to propaganda, and are often used to peddle misinformation, and to prevent nuanced debate.

I also find it disconcerting when people claim to have voted Labour, but disagree with fundamentally Labour policies such as universal free school meals or increased minimum wages. What did these voters expect? I wouldn't vote Tory then moan when services are cut along with taxes for the well-off.

From day one Starmer has failed to grasp the Communication nettle. It was always going to be difficult to govern with centre left policies when the media is so far to the right, but he doesn't appear to have considered that this would be the case.

I think he has made mistakes, but agree with those who see a willingness to reconsider as strength rather than weakness. Sticking to one's guns and being 'not for turning' is, IMO, lazy, and reminds me of parents who refuse to 'back down' when they have said things to their children but then realise they were too harsh or simply ill-advised. Those families are rarely close when the children grow up. We all make mistakes, but when they are pointed out if we have the sense and humility to admit it and make changes it is far better, IMO than doubling down and being intransigent.

Transcend Wed 24-Dec-25 18:16:44

Be grateful your leader does not think he is God. I live in the US. Everything good that we worked so hard for is being destroyed.

Peaseblossom Wed 24-Dec-25 18:38:38

leeds22 but they refuse to ban halal slaughter! Need to ban kosher too. No excuse for cruelty to animals.