Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

A grammar lesson needed.

(50 Posts)
Nelliemoser Tue 08-Jul-14 10:06:20

Pedantic help please
This was on a menu I was looking at earlier.
"Buffet A £6.95
Selection of Sandwiches
Warm Sausage Rolls
Warm Vegetarian Quiche

Mixed "Leave" Salad Further down the menu was
Mixed Leaves Salad!

They both screamed wrong grammar at me, I know it was not right. I know this could have been " A mixed leaf salad" or A salad of mixed leaves.

I think it's something to do with how the individual words are used in the sentence as in nouns, verbs or adjectives, but my grammar is not good enough to be able to explain why.
Or is that "mixed" and "salad" are in a category of words that imply more than one of whatever it is.
Is it something like the difference between "Two bags full" or "Two bag fulls."
I sort of know when something is glaringly wrong but not why.
Please can someone explain to me. confused

Terrafirma1 Sun 27-Jul-14 18:43:01

Or cross breads ? Or roll playing then either.

Ana Sun 27-Jul-14 18:23:11

Definitely no Tiger bread! grin

MrsPickle Sun 27-Jul-14 18:18:47

Not quite grammar, but we were reading the rules of a new camp site. We have 3 dogs and were interested to see that 'no dangerous breads' were allowed.
No sourdogs, then?

Terrafirma1 Sun 27-Jul-14 10:48:32

<Pats on the head>

"There, their, they're, dear"

<Ducks for cover>tbgrin

EEJit Sun 27-Jul-14 10:33:55

I get really annoyed by those who can't tell the difference between, there; their; and they're.

Makes me want to pull out my remaining hairs.

mrsmopp Sun 13-Jul-14 23:13:57

Unreadable but not illegible..

feetlebaum Wed 09-Jul-14 15:06:38

jinglebellsfrocks - nice to know Tolkien got something right...

I have found him to be unreadable...

jinglbellsfrocks Wed 09-Jul-14 14:04:15

Bags being a person.

Aka Wed 09-Jul-14 14:01:19

This is 'doing my head in' - I've a Spider-Man cake to make so will leave all you pedants, academics, scholars people to it.

jinglbellsfrocks Wed 09-Jul-14 14:00:04

(Sorry Aka)

jinglbellsfrocks Wed 09-Jul-14 13:59:11

I just checked. Apparently Tolkien brought in "dwarves" for his books.

Aka Wed 09-Jul-14 13:55:54

___________________________________________________

Aka Wed 09-Jul-14 13:41:10

Doggy woofs (wooves) that is.

Aka Wed 09-Jul-14 13:40:30

True.

Woof woof?

Ana Wed 09-Jul-14 13:36:41

Ah, but presumably that's only one toof! grin

Aka Wed 09-Jul-14 13:31:50

How about 'nana my toofs fallen out!'?

Aka Wed 09-Jul-14 13:30:41

Rooves grin

Hoof?

Ana Wed 09-Jul-14 13:28:44

Roofs.

Aka Wed 09-Jul-14 13:27:14

Scarfs v scarves

feetlebaum Wed 09-Jul-14 13:13:27

The -fs ending is hard to pronounce, hence dwarves...

Aka Wed 09-Jul-14 12:45:50

It is dwarfs usually but the rule for changing 'f' to 'ves' is complicated. It's the Kaiser Chiefs for example not the Kaiser Chieves.

Aka Wed 09-Jul-14 12:44:38

It is dwarfs, but the rule for changing 'f' to 'ves' is complicated. It's the Kaiser Chiefs for example not the Kaiser Chieves.

Ana Wed 09-Jul-14 12:36:01

Just double-checked and it can actually be either, but dwarfs is more usual.

HollyDaze Wed 09-Jul-14 12:33:48

Ana

I thought it was Dwarves?

Aka Wed 09-Jul-14 12:29:07

That was to Mishap