Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

A pedant on Facebook - moi?

(154 Posts)
ferry23 Wed 03-Apr-24 16:52:43

I love this topic.

I've been tempted to post a comment on my village's Fb page along the lines of...

"I'm thinking of starting a Fb group for those who can string together a short sentence with no spelling mistakes and which is grammatically correct. I look forward to hearing from both of you".

Maybe I should of grin

I suspect fellow pedants also have to sit on their hands and zip their lips when it comes to social media.

JamesandJon33 Fri 05-Apr-24 13:15:36

Sorry didn’t check. Should have been, would of etc.

ferry23 Fri 05-Apr-24 14:47:48

MaizieD

JamesandJon33

English lit and language here too.
I dislike gotten, off of, youse, my bad, could have, would have, and many more I would think . …can I get, cool, like( sprinkled throughout a sentence) , f—k used as an adjective, , babe, hubby. ….I’ll stop now.

What is wrong with 'could have' and 'would have'?

This has to be one of the more odd pedants threads when the OP says 'should of' (😱 ) in their first post and isn't too sure about the use of 'I' and 'me' in a subsequent one...

Ah, I also love the use of irony . As mentioned, I used a laughing emoji to denote the skewed use of "should of" and merely made the "I am - "I" comment to add some humour.

Any good pedant should recognise irony.

Chocolatelovinggran Fri 05-Apr-24 21:19:18

Ooh yes vegansrockand Chardy- I have educated many people on the difference between less and fewer, including a number of television presenters. Mostly, they were not listening...

Greta Sat 06-Apr-24 07:15:43

I agree, sodapop, the use of "myself/yourself" is irritating. I guess people think they sound more intelligent if they use longer words. I also dislike the constant "journey" and "narrative".

MissAdventure Sat 06-Apr-24 13:30:42

I dislike "gifted".
No idea if it's grammatically correct, but it sounds very twee.

Calendargirl Sun 07-Apr-24 07:32:27

“Is anyone ‘gifting’ a …..”
In other words, “I’m ‘begging’ a …..”

MaizieD Sun 07-Apr-24 09:34:25

ferry23

MaizieD

JamesandJon33

English lit and language here too.
I dislike gotten, off of, youse, my bad, could have, would have, and many more I would think . …can I get, cool, like( sprinkled throughout a sentence) , f—k used as an adjective, , babe, hubby. ….I’ll stop now.

What is wrong with 'could have' and 'would have'?

This has to be one of the more odd pedants threads when the OP says 'should of' (😱 ) in their first post and isn't too sure about the use of 'I' and 'me' in a subsequent one...

Ah, I also love the use of irony . As mentioned, I used a laughing emoji to denote the skewed use of "should of" and merely made the "I am - "I" comment to add some humour.

Any good pedant should recognise irony.

Well, that's me telt, then.

MaizieD Sun 07-Apr-24 09:50:13

MissAdventure

I dislike "gifted".
No idea if it's grammatically correct, but it sounds very twee.

What always surprises me is that people, such as journalists, who have always written perfectly acceptable and correct English, seem to pick up these 'new' word usages and perpetuate them. Is it a keeping up with the fashion thing?

'Given' becomes 'gifted'
'Affected' becomes 'impacted'
'Most' becomes 'the vast majority'

Prepositions get changed, added, or misplaced; 'forbidden from', 'bored of', 'outside of'...

To name but a few of my peeves.

Who is driving previously literate people to the point of grammatical madness?

MissMellie Sun 07-Apr-24 11:13:53

I, too, am a pedant but choose not to expose other’s mistakes publicly. Often the mistakes are the result of autocorrect or a slip of the finger while typing.

Others (such as those in journalism) are frequently overlooked because there are few human editors anymore. What I do not understand is why the AI editors aren’t properly programmed to recognize correct grammar, the difference between possessive and plural and the proper use of verb tenses.

As it is, I am regularly amused by what I see.

SheepyIzzy Sun 07-Apr-24 11:19:07

Tooken!

"I tooken the children to school"

The first time I heard this word was a rather comical episode of Judge Judy. Even she complains about the education system and that's America, so it isn't just this country.

Quizzer Sun 07-Apr-24 11:33:43

Had an argument with my Essex senior civil servant boss that “we was” was not correct grammar. Luckily, his boss came to my aid and agreed that it was wrong.😂

JackyB Sun 07-Apr-24 11:36:59

Greta

I think poor spelling/grammar shows a lack of respect for one's language. Most Brits only speak one language but many seem to find it a challenge. I do know there are difficulties such as dyslexia for some.
An acquaintance once remarked " I'm hopeless at spelling but it doesn't matter now that we have spellcheckers."
I don't mind being corrected if I make mistakes.

* ++ * ++

As I live abroad and speak other languages most of the time, I am particularly aware of grammar and the correct use of cases, and since when I hear monolingual English speakers misusing them (and don't get me started on those reflexive pronouns scattered in the most inappropriate places)

JackyB Sun 07-Apr-24 11:38:08

Sorry "wince", not "since".

Better clean my glasses! 🕶️

2oaktrees Sun 07-Apr-24 11:38:11

Vegansrock One set of your inverted commas is facing the wrong way! Just playing. 😁

missdeke Sun 07-Apr-24 11:40:59

Should of!! Now that is my pet hate, it's should have or should've.

Rusume Sun 07-Apr-24 11:42:35

As an English lecturer "should of" is the equivalent to me of scraping fingernails down a blackboard! Aarrggg!!!angry

mabon1 Sun 07-Apr-24 11:49:32

Clearly, you are perfect in all respects.

JdotJ Sun 07-Apr-24 11:49:36

The amount of people who do not know how to use the word lose or the word loose in a sentence really annoys me.

Seems a fairly recent thing.

hicaz46 Sun 07-Apr-24 11:51:55

‘Should have’ not ‘should of’

knspol Sun 07-Apr-24 11:55:24

I was also taught never to end a sentence with a preposition but a current English teacher told me that now it's considered OK to do just that. Another dumbing down exercise?
Something that's really annoying me at the moment is people saying 'the amount of something or other' when they mean 'the number of something'.

Fae1 Sun 07-Apr-24 11:55:53

I took studied 'O' levels back in 1966 and subsequently won a scholarship to read English at university. Language evolves - annoying for pedants and 'know it alls' but hey ho - there are far more important things to worry about. Get over it!

Germanshepherdsmum Sun 07-Apr-24 11:57:23

There are some things over which the true pedant cannot get.

MissAdventure Sun 07-Apr-24 11:57:54

grin

sodapop Sun 07-Apr-24 11:58:46

Well at least it took 3 pages for the usual comment to appear on Pedants Corner

icanhandthemback Sun 07-Apr-24 12:06:28

knspol

I was also taught never to end a sentence with a preposition but a current English teacher told me that now it's considered OK to do just that. Another dumbing down exercise?
Something that's really annoying me at the moment is people saying 'the amount of something or other' when they mean 'the number of something'.

It is not "dumbing down", it is our language evolving. If language did not evolve, we would still be grunting!

If I am writing quickly on social media, I don't check my grammar and the way my brain jumps all over the place, I can write horrify myself. However, I do notice grammar errors when I am reading but recognise that not everybody has had the same level of education. I just consider myself lucky rather than looking down on the others who were not so lucky. I do shout at the tv regularly though!