Gransnet forums

Site stuff

Reading the thread (with our without the “f”)

(95 Posts)
RosiesMaw Mon 06-Nov-23 12:20:13

We have had three or four instances recently of cheerful uplifting “keep positive” type comments addressed to an OP on the Bereavement forum who initially flagged up a serious cancer diagnosis but has very recently shared her DH’s passing with us when that sad event occurred.
It is clear that the “keep your chin up, enjoy every day” etc comments, while kindly meant, were entirely inappropriate to somebody who had just been bereaved.

So a plea from me (and others)
Please, please, read the thread, think and then post - in that order. It saves hurt to the recipient, mortification to the writer, and, frankly embarrassment all round

kittylester Tue 07-Nov-23 06:42:30

I'm on a Samsung Galaxy, using the mobile site. I think that if I use the desktop site, the different colours appear.

kittylester Tue 07-Nov-23 06:43:53

No it doesn't!! blush

Marydoll Tue 07-Nov-23 07:03:41

I also use a Samsung Galaxy tablet, but on my tablet ALL the OP's posts are coloured green and mine are coloured pink. All others are white..

That is so strange, I am also using a Galaxy tablet and that doesn't happen for me! 🤣

Parsley3 Tue 07-Nov-23 08:10:15

Or me. ???

Baggs Tue 07-Nov-23 10:44:58

Just checking: does RTFT mean Read the Full Thread?

Not that always will but it's good to know what acronyms that might be rude actually mean. TYIA (thank you in anticipation) 🙂

Baggs Tue 07-Nov-23 10:52:33

Not that I....

When I used to be on Mumsnet (never much but did go over there a few times), it seemed to me to be very common for subsequent posters to simply answer the opening post.

I do understand rosiesmaw's particular point that this thread has talked about but I don't agree that reading the whole thread is always necessary. Apart from anything else, sometimes it would take all day and anyway threads ramble and what's in the last hundred posts may well be about something completely unrelated to the opening post.

Like this one.

Baggs Tue 07-Nov-23 10:54:55

Also.... what bellasnana said holds in this instance, I think. So this should all be deleted.

Callistemon21 Tue 07-Nov-23 10:59:04

Marydoll

*I also use a Samsung Galaxy tablet, but on my tablet ALL the OP's posts are coloured green and mine are coloured pink. All others are white.*.

That is so strange, I am also using a Galaxy tablet and that doesn't happen for me! 🤣

It doesn't happen for me either Marydoll.
I tried the mobile and desktop sites but no!

Millie22 Tue 07-Nov-23 11:17:11

Baggs
No it's not full it's the other word beginning with f.

The opposite of queen. Sort of!!

MaizieD Tue 07-Nov-23 11:20:50

Millie22

Baggs
No it's not full it's the other word beginning with f.

The opposite of queen. Sort of!!

I think you could interpret it either way.

dragonfly46 Tue 07-Nov-23 11:23:08

I am reporting this thread as I think it should be deleted before it causes any more distress!

Theexwife Tue 07-Nov-23 11:54:58

Some people, myself included, go on this site for a few minutes at a time and do not have the time or inclination to read every reply to a post.

There is no need to tell people how they should use this forum, some want to read every post and reply, many do not, some want to reply some just read and go.

I also do not like it when anyone new posts, especially a man or younger person, and there is speculation as to who it really is or that they should not be on here at all. There is often the ridiculous suggestion that it is a teen posting, as if they would be interested in winding old people up or they would even be aware of this forum.

Why report this thread dragonfly46? I cannot see any rule breaking.

nanna8 Tue 07-Nov-23 11:58:29

Oh there’s a few precious little petals around. I can’t be stuffed with this thread anymore, going back to the sane ones.

Callistemon21 Tue 07-Nov-23 12:12:16

I also do not like it when anyone new posts, especially a man or younger person, and there is speculation as to who it really is or that they should not be on here at all. There is often the ridiculous suggestion that it is a teen posting, as if they would be interested in winding old people up or they would even be aware of this forum

Not sure how long you've been on GN Theexwife but we've had a few trolls suspect posters over the years and many posters can sense a fake poster a mile off. Best to report suspicions to GNHQ, though.

Onesies and plimsolls anyone?

Theexwife Tue 07-Nov-23 12:24:10

Callistemon21 I agree there have been a few suspect posters, however new people are jumped on straight away by some and in many cases have been wrong.

The person you mention was obviously a member with a double identity, who did it a few times,thankfully she seems to have left, although when her name is mentioned she appears within minutes so is still reading.

eazybee Tue 07-Nov-23 12:30:54

Baggs
No it's not full it's the other word beginning with f.

The opposite of queen. Sort of!!

I am completely lost.The opposite of Queen is King.?

LucyAnna Tue 07-Nov-23 12:38:08

eazybee

Baggs
No it's not full it's the other word beginning with f.

The opposite of queen. Sort of!!

I am completely lost.The opposite of Queen is King.?

It’s a swear word, ending in king, starting with f

dragonfly46 Tue 07-Nov-23 12:39:51

Theexwife no no rules have been broken but I feel certain people reading it will feel extremely distressed.

Ziplok Tue 07-Nov-23 12:48:27

Ideally, reading the whole thread is the thing to do, but when it runs to many pages, that’s quite difficult, unless you have lots of time to read them. I agree with the posters who say that the OP’s comments should be highlighted throughout, so that you can scan them all before replying. If it can be done on mumsnet, why not gransnet - it’s the same company.

Germanshepherdsmum Tue 07-Nov-23 12:53:24

I don’t know who the ‘certain people’ are but it’s ironic that you feel they will feel extremely distressed when this thread was started because of the likelihood of distress having been caused to someone who posted that her husband had received a devastating diagnosis and even after she posted that he had died people who hadn’t RTFT were posting their advice on coping with the diagnosis - even on the day of his funeral.

Baggs Tue 07-Nov-23 12:58:19

LucyAnna

eazybee

Baggs
No it's not full it's the other word beginning with f.

The opposite of queen. Sort of!!

I am completely lost.The opposite of Queen is King.?

It’s a swear word, ending in king, starting with f

LucyAnna and eazybee: Chuckle McChuckle 😂

Doodledog Tue 07-Nov-23 13:12:48

Theexwife

Some people, myself included, go on this site for a few minutes at a time and do not have the time or inclination to read every reply to a post.

There is no need to tell people how they should use this forum, some want to read every post and reply, many do not, some want to reply some just read and go.

I also do not like it when anyone new posts, especially a man or younger person, and there is speculation as to who it really is or that they should not be on here at all. There is often the ridiculous suggestion that it is a teen posting, as if they would be interested in winding old people up or they would even be aware of this forum.

Why report this thread dragonfly46? I cannot see any rule breaking.

I don't think anyone is telling others what to do though. The OP is asking people to be considerate because of a particular incident that caused distress, and after that people have simply said whether they personally prefer it when others read the thread or not. Nobody has said it bothers them particularly, just expressed a preference.

There seems to be a lot of angst on her just now. Whenever people express an opinion they are told they are being dictatorial. It's a discussion site, and people are discussing - what's wrong with that?

eazybee Tue 07-Nov-23 13:15:30

Thank you, Lucy Anna; genuinely had no idea; thought it was 'full'!
(Now can you explain the title: Reading the thread
(with our ???without the “f”) ?

I would think that if the comments were kindly meant, which they all seemed to be, the recipient would not be too distressed by the fact that some posters had not read her latest bulletin.

JackyB Tue 07-Nov-23 17:55:01

As this is a TAAT (thread about a thread) it shouldn't have been allowed to gather momentum and not so long ago such threads were deleted post haste.

LucyAnna Tue 07-Nov-23 18:15:21

eazybee

Thank you, Lucy Anna; genuinely had no idea; thought it was 'full'!
(Now can you explain the title: Reading the thread
(with our ???without the “f”) ?

I would think that if the comments were kindly meant, which they all seemed to be, the recipient would not be too distressed by the fact that some posters had not read her latest bulletin.

I imagine it was meant to be with OR without the “f”, but far be it from me to challenge anyone’s grammar or spelling…..