Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

Hopeless dilemma

(215 Posts)
Luckygirl Wed 01-Jul-15 20:56:29

Let me first say that I have changed my username to Luckygirl, and many of you will realise that this is something of a joke, given my previous name, and will be able to use that hint to work out who I am.

But seriously - my poor DD and her OH are in a terrible dilemma. My DD rang me yesterday in a very tearful state to tell me that her children were being babysat by her in-laws and when she returned FIL (who is not an easy character - this is an understatement) was playing a very rough game with one of her sons, aged 3. The little lad was being teased and goaded, and eventually hit his FIL, who responded by walloping him hard 4 times on the bum. My DD just swept the child up and took him from the room. Needless to say we are all very distressed by this.

DD's OH is away at present and will be for most of the summer (although DD and children will join him for brief periods during that time). FIL is integral to the business they run, so the possibility of just giving him hell is not an option. They are also aware that if they say anything about it, he is such a stubborn man that he would just fold the business and cut off all communication. Their livelihood would be at risk.

SIL is livid and very distressed - he is away from his family and DD is in fact ill - I have just returned from taking care of her. It is a dreadful muddle and I am beyond knowing how to respond. I am just giving DD and her children as much support and love as I can.

What do others feel about FIL's action? I am so angry and upset that I not sure I can look at this in a rational way.

Tegan Sat 11-Jul-15 20:26:25

If you mean winners I don't get them at all these days sad. Lost £2 on George the other day; will have a serious word with him if I see him next week grin#nopolosfor'im

jinglbellsfrocks Sat 11-Jul-15 19:53:45

Do you get many come through like that Tegan?

jinglbellsfrocks Sat 11-Jul-15 19:35:54

Ok. Twenty quid each way on Gaia it is then. Thanks Tegan.

annsixty Sat 11-Jul-15 19:29:55

Didn't Emma Thompson call her Daughter Gaia? Totally irrevelant of course.

Marelli Sat 11-Jul-15 19:08:10

smile One of the kindest women I've ever met was Pagan. She named herself 'S..... de Gaia'. I think you and I share the same sentiments, Tegan.

Tegan Sat 11-Jul-15 18:49:40

Yes; can't say I can explain/understand it but feel it's right [if that makes sense confused].

Marelli Sat 11-Jul-15 18:38:41

'Of the Earth', Tegan? Is that right?

Tegan Sat 11-Jul-15 18:17:13

Gaia....

jinglbellsfrocks Sat 11-Jul-15 18:07:43

What the flip has world peace got to do with Gransnet?! Come on! hmm

annodomini Sat 11-Jul-15 13:42:15

So true, SuzieB.

Bellanonna Sat 11-Jul-15 13:41:45

The voice of reason SuzieB. There are others who feel like you do, and who express these feelings from time to time. I find the sniping and point scoring pathetic, And this from an older generation who should have learnt by now to be polite in disagreement. I think on balance, though, it is a small minority who indulge in that behaviour and people for the most part are kind and compassionate, being aware that it is the OP who has raised the initial point, and showing sympathy to her/him and avoiding getting embroiled in other people's pops at one another.

SuzieB Sat 11-Jul-15 13:12:59

The second saddest thing about this thread is the way some people have been intolerant - and I don't just mean those that 'tell it like it is'! Stand back a minute and ask yourself what you want from GN. It surely can't be arguing your corner no matter what. Be kind to each other - even to people you violently disagree with and, no, I'm not a bleeding heart soppy goody-goody. But as I get older I feel, more and more, that if a group of people on here (and on Ravelry, to which I belong) can't agree to disagree, whilst still holding their own views, there's not much change of World Peace, is there?!

Ana Thu 09-Jul-15 13:46:23

I don't think Luckygirl is going to post again on this thread, according to her post of 11.47 on Monday.

Alea Thu 09-Jul-15 13:41:33

Wondering if there has been any progress here?
Not a thing you would want to have hanging over the family.

jinglbellsfrocks Thu 09-Jul-15 13:32:37

#bloodyGransnet hmm

and I don't include petallus in that

Katek Thu 09-Jul-15 10:08:36

Posted too quickly - am also about to follow own advice

Katek Thu 09-Jul-15 10:07:20

It was only by commenting in the first place that you associated yourself Petallus! As I say, no comment would have achieved the same result.

Off out as well on a greyish but dry day. Hope you enjoy your exhibition. smile

petallus Thu 09-Jul-15 08:36:47

I don't remember many distressed people, maybe one. I certainly don't find the posts distressing. I actually like reading them. It's horses for courses isn't it.

I just wanted to disassociate myself from your original post.

It's a lovely day and I'm off to an exhibition and the seaside. I an going to follow your advice and not give this thread any more oxygen.

Katek Wed 08-Jul-15 23:04:57

There have been numerous references to the poster in question and many direct responses to her by those who have been distressed by her posts. Their name is not a secret! ( I have reverted to slightly more veiled language as you seem to prefer it. )

Are you assuming I'm talking about a vendetta Petallus? If so, you are incorrect. Those who are being hurt should disengage as there is no point in any further conversation with the poster in question. Anybody else is free to do exactly what they want.

petallus Wed 08-Jul-15 22:51:34

Then why mention the person you do not wish to communicate with in your post?

If I have interpreted your post correctly, I consider it to be totally unfair.

Katek Wed 08-Jul-15 22:44:34

I don't see any other workable solution. Sorry if you don't agree Petallus. If we wouldn't tolerate certain behaviours in RL then the same applies here. We don't have to communicate with those we don't want to.

petallus Wed 08-Jul-15 22:39:49

Uncalled for!

Katek Wed 08-Jul-15 22:27:03

Oh dear me....not again! We all know about the oxygen of publicity so why are we still providing it for STB? The answer is in our own hands, no comment whatsoever......

Luckygirl, I so hope that this dreadful situation can be resolved with the least amount of damage.

sassy60 Wed 08-Jul-15 15:42:54

Hey Luckygirl, I have no idea who you are or what has gone on before but would just like to say that you are not over reacting at all. In fact you are being very restrained, fair enough given the circumstances, and I accept that things are difficult for your DD. The nasty bully cannot be allowed to be so controlling and to deliberately goad a 3 year old in order to get a reaction. He is abusive and luckily he does not have me or my daughter to deal with or he would not be standing up straight now I can tell you!
I am seething because my grandson is also 3 and does get carried away sometimes but is spoken to not hit.
I wish you luck with this awful situation but I think a word with this nasty man has to be had.

LesleyC Wed 08-Jul-15 13:27:15

How very distressing for you all Luckygirl. Has discipline ever been discussed with the family? I know my daughter has always made it quite plain that smacking was never acceptable. I don't think I would have ever considered smacking my grandchildren anyway, but I will always go by her rules, even ones I don't agree with. This chap doesn't sound a very likeable character and may not listen but I think your DD should state her own rules.