Gransnet forums

Estrangement

Is there anyone here whose estranged adult child re-established contact?

(117 Posts)
Purpletinofpaint Tue 02-Jul-19 11:04:58

I'm not expecting anyone to answer yes to this. I'm wondering if there are any stories of estranged adult children that came back & successfully established a new relationship with their parents?

agnurse Tue 10-Dec-19 20:53:25

jenpax

There are two possibilities.

1) People are often told not to JADE - Justify, Argue, Defend, Explain. JADEing tells people that they have the option to disagree with you. It's easier just to say, "Here's what's going to happen. Here are the boundaries. End of."

2) It's possible in some cases that the reason for the estrangement was actually discussed, but the person didn't agree with it, didn't listen, or simply chose not to mention it.

Smileless2012 Tue 10-Dec-19 20:55:48

jenpax it is so sad that it took the death of your father to make your mother see that she needed help. How fortunate she was that you were able to be there for her and that you both enjoyed and no doubt benefited from the relationship you were able to have.

It's so refreshing to see a post from someone who having estranged their mother believes other EP's when they say they simply don't understand why they've been cut out, that they've never been told.

You did the right thing, you explained your reasons and were there for her if she managed to turn things around. She did and you wereflowers.

midnightschild Tue 10-Dec-19 22:04:24

I was estranged from my eldest son for 5 years following a family row. Tried several times to re-establish contact but DIL intercepted all attempts and told me I would never have contact with him again. After his marriage broke up he contacted me and we very slowly started to rebuild our relationship. We now get on very well. I think our long separation allowed us to heal from a really long-standing toxic relationship. He grew up and I perhaps saw some things about myself that I didn’t like. I went through some tough stuff during his childhood and it had a lot of repercussions.
Anyway, I am now very careful to treat him with respect and kindness and he, in return, is also thoughtful and respectful. I don’t think we would ever have reached this lovely way of being with each other without the long hiatus. We haven’t really discussed the events which led to the estrangement but I think we both tacitly feel that we would rather move on than dwell on the bad things that happened in the past.
I would urge people to never give up hope of restoring a family relationship if it can be done in a way which is healthy for all involved - but I do acknowledge that some relationships are so entrenched in toxicity that they can never be mended.

Smileless2012 Tue 10-Dec-19 22:50:42

midnightschild another uplifting postsmile.

endlessstrife Wed 11-Dec-19 08:14:21

One thing I later realised after we’d reconciled, was the whole thing coincided with my menopause getting going! Not sure if it’s a reason, but certainly wouldn’t have helped. During the absence, we emailed all the time, and tried very hard to sort it out. In our case, we knew what we’d “ done”. I agree, discussions absolutely need to be had if possible.

Smileless2012 Wed 11-Dec-19 08:42:43

It must have helped having email contact during that time endlessstrife, when there's no communication whatsoever, it's impossible to try and find a solution.

endlessstrife Wed 11-Dec-19 09:13:34

Yes, smileless, it did help, but at the time, there was animosity in the correspondence, which we worried would damage things further if you know what I mean. Luckily, it took an about turn, and we met up. I’m not sure it’ll ever be perfect, but at least she’s with us. We do only borrow our children, and can only pray we’ll always have them, but of course, as you know, it’s not always the case. Never give up though Smileless, You never know what’s round the corner.

PetitFromage Wed 11-Dec-19 09:48:33

I am just going through this process at present after a semi-estrangement from my eldest DD of several years. I say 'semi-estrangement', because she would still send birthday cards etc - although they were quite impersonal and 'cold' - but blocked us entirely for six months, moved house without telling us her new address, got married without telling us, and had a baby without telling us. She literally hugged us and said goodbye after we visited her (she lived about 200 miles away at the time and now even further away) but then cut us off. I have seen her once in the last three years for lunch at a restaurant with our now SIL.

She is expecting another baby any day now and there has been a rapprochement to the extent where she is now in almost daily contact and sends lots of photos etc of DGD. We are scheduled to visit in January when we will meet both children for the first time. I have mixed feelings, to be honest, as I was so hurt that she would treat us in that way, especially not telling us of DGD's existence until she was 14 months old.

I am proceeding cautiously, as I don't want to be hurt again, so it is heartening to read some positive stories. DD was in her early 20s when the semi-estrangement began - it was a relationship which went from being close and loving to more and more distant - so hopefully time and maturity will have made a difference.

Smileless2012 Wed 11-Dec-19 11:07:18

Still waiting PF; still waiting with you xx

Fennel Wed 11-Dec-19 12:29:53

I've just realised that our family saga involved a kind of estrangement.
We married both for the 2nd time with 4 children aged 5-9.
It was hard. Then 2 of them, one mine, one his rebelled around age 17-18 and went back to the other parent. It was an awful few years.
Very little contact for some years though we always left the door open.
As they got older and now have families of their own we've slowly rebuilt the relationships, though the 2 who stayed are closer.

Yogagirl Tue 18-Feb-20 09:43:47

^Purpletinofpaint Tue 02-Jul-19 11:04:58
I'm not expecting anyone to answer yes to this. I'm wondering if there are any stories of estranged adult children that came back & successfully established a new relationship with their parents?^

My DD estranged herself 7.5yrs ago, taking my beloved GC out of my life, due to brainwashing by her H. About a year later my DS joined them. Just before Xmas this year I got an email from DS, out of the blue after 6.5yrs of silence. He is now living with me, we get on really well, as we did before. He said that the change was from him maturing and realising that his friends were not the most important thing in ones life, but family are. His sister, my estD, has now cut him out too, no surprise to me & his other sister though [also cut out, same time as me].

Smileless2012 Tue 18-Feb-20 14:25:00

It's good to know that things are going so well with you and your son Yogagirl[smile}

Smileless2012 Tue 18-Feb-20 14:25:35

oops smile x

Yogagirl Wed 19-Feb-20 08:43:18

Thank you Smileless flowers

Starlady Thu 20-Feb-20 22:28:47

Yes, it is good to hear about you and DS, Yoga! Sorry that ED has not cut him out of her life, too, but not surprised, since in her mind, I suppose he "switched sides" (NOT defending her). I hope you, DS, ND and family continue to have a good relationship. And that ED comes around eventually.

Yogagirl Fri 21-Feb-20 08:39:25

Thank you Starlady x