Gransnet forums

Chat

Realism V Idealism

(85 Posts)
Cossy Thu 09-May-24 10:31:08

Lots of criticisms of “idealism” here, or as some liken it “pie in the sky”.

However, surely we all recognise that Idealists are just as important as Realists?

Nothing new would ever happen without Idealists.

Quote below, is one of many explaining very simply the difference

From a model perspective, the defining premise of idealism asserts that all manifest certainties emerge from conceivable possibilities; where realism contends that all manifestable possibilities emerge from preexisting certainties.1 Jun 2022

It’s even possible to be both an Idealist and a Realist.

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 10-May-24 12:42:39

Oreo

Glorianny

I was asked for evidence about employers wanting asylum seekers I googled it because although I have local knowledge I wanted country-wide info. And guess what it isn't just small employers. Big businesses want them as well
www.peoplemanagement.co.uk/article/1827229/hiring-refugees-businesses-need-know-does-hr-need-do#:~:text=Big%2Dname%20employers%20such%20as,

And a report
www.refugee-action.org.uk/lift-the-ban/

I read it.
Businesses don’t want asylum seekers they want those who they can actually employ who have been granted refugee status.
It makes this quite clear and says businesses must be aware of the difference between asylum seekers and refugees.
For instance Ukrainians have refugee status among others.

Exactly Oreo. Not sure Glorianny understands the difference.

zakouma66 Fri 10-May-24 13:25:26

Some people don't understand the difference between propaganda and news.

Namsnanny Fri 10-May-24 14:03:21

Now that I agree with.

Chocolatelovinggran Fri 10-May-24 14:06:33

We do need idealists/ dreamers/ eternal optimists to give us inspiration, even if it then requires practical folk to assist effective implementation. All of us are in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars.
Oh, and GSM, as a Headteacher I employed 90 people, appointed many, and put a few on disciplinary.

Katie590 Fri 10-May-24 14:08:42

maddyone

Does anyone actually believe that asylum seekers have undertaken that enormous journey to get here to go and be gardeners in our public parks?

YES, they want any job that will enable them to better themselves, prove themselves and build a new life, anything to get out of the poverty they left behind in their own country.

We have seen this in all migrant populations they will work twice as hard to make a start for themselves in a new country, with the second generation it’s different, but that’s another story.

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 10-May-24 14:28:44

This might be a small fly in the ointment. Fact, not propaganda.
crbdirect.org.uk/landscape-architect-or-gardener-dbs-check/#:~:text=Working%20in%20public%20spaces%20and,is%20a%20basic%20DBS%20check.

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 10-May-24 14:29:55

Chocolatelovinggran

We do need idealists/ dreamers/ eternal optimists to give us inspiration, even if it then requires practical folk to assist effective implementation. All of us are in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars.
Oh, and GSM, as a Headteacher I employed 90 people, appointed many, and put a few on disciplinary.

Were you the employer or was it the education authority/charity?

Katie590 Fri 10-May-24 14:46:19

If you are an employer at the top of the tree you have to be a visionary, you may only have a few or many thousands but you have to know your objectives. Along the way you will have some employees that do not share that vision and they have to go. It’s not nice but that’s what leadership is all about

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 10-May-24 14:49:41

Agreed.