Gransnet forums

Estrangement

Overcomplicated

(495 Posts)
FriendlyGhost Mon 20-Jul-20 10:26:58

My goodness there are a lot of interesting articles posted here. However intelligent and informative they are, they do rather overcomplicate the issue. Do people suit all these traits? Do they tick all the boxes on this checklist?

Really there is only one question. Do you have a bully in your life?

A bully is a person who continues to engage in behaviour that they are aware hurts you, that would not harm you or them to stop

That may seem like a rather broad statement. It is not. It is very simple.

If the focus is being placed on your reaction to their bullying behaviour it detracts from the real issue. The bully in your life.

Bullies are online, in friendship circles, in the workplace and in families.

Most bullies will tell you they have a right to their behaviour {insert justification} and believe they are entitled to treat you as they wish. Whether this is someone in a position of power over you like an employer or an older family member, or simply by rote of a strong personality, bullying is not acceptable.

A bully is a person that continues to engage in behaviour that they are aware hurts you, that would not harm you or them to stop

If a person continues to engage in behaviour that hurts you and has a detramental impact on your ability to enjoy your life (not including habits or mental illness you have that ignoring would harm you) then you are within your rights to take steps to remove that person from it.

Bullies are often shocked when it is pointed out to them that it is their behaviour causing all the issues. Not because they are unaware but because they believe they have the right to behave that way and asking them to stop is a personal attack on them.

This is not true. No one has the right to be a bully for the sake of their enjoyment of life.

A bully is a person who continues to engage in behaviour that they are aware hurts you, that would not harm you or them to stop

You have the right to be free from bullying no matter who the bully is and to take measures to protect yourself. Even if the result is estrangement from a family member.

Smileless2012 Wed 22-Jul-20 20:59:24

You were responsible for your H's eyes being opened MamaBear. I firmly believe we were estranged before we were able to open our son's eyes to the true nature of the woman he married and with whom he had children.

MamaBear20 Wed 22-Jul-20 21:01:19

HolyHannah I can’t imagine how difficult and hurtful your childhood must have been being raised by a narcissistic mother. I’m so sorry you didn’t get the parents you deserved. It’s common for other members of a family to develop narcissistic traits without being full blown narcissists. I’ve seen it called “narcissistic fleas”.

Starblaze Wed 22-Jul-20 21:05:18

I too have been told by a professional that my symptoms are those of someone abused by a narcissist. If already estranged at that point. Before estranging a different professional said my family were toxic, not me which I had come to believe because for me there was no other logical reason why a mother wouldn't love her child.

I now see the much bigger, sadder picture for me and many others

rosecarmel Wed 22-Jul-20 21:21:23

Comfort, empathy and support continue to be offerd along with a variety of resources and personal growth experiences to glean insight from-

The greatest problem might be simply not recognizing that all the information being shared is dependent upon compassion- Not liking the way the information is presented or the individual presenting it doesn't cancel out the fact that the information being shared is an act of compassion-

HolyHannah Wed 22-Jul-20 21:27:59

Thank you MamaBear. What would have been worse is never coming to recognize what I grew up with and continued the cycle.

Starblaze Wed 22-Jul-20 21:28:49

rosecarmel

Comfort, empathy and support continue to be offerd along with a variety of resources and personal growth experiences to glean insight from-

The greatest problem might be simply not recognizing that all the information being shared is dependent upon compassion- Not liking the way the information is presented or the individual presenting it doesn't cancel out the fact that the information being shared is an act of compassion-

❤️

Chewbacca Wed 22-Jul-20 22:57:32

Those posters who have said that their mothers/families are narcissistic; were any of them actually seen by a mental healthcare professional and diagnosed as such? I appreciate that some here have received professional advice and support for their own difficulties that they feel have been triggered by their pasts, but how can a diagnosis of any psychological abnormality be given by any professional, for people that they've never met or spoken to?

HolyHannah Wed 22-Jul-20 23:08:54

Chewbacca -- In my case, it is quite simple... Since all the symptoms I have can be linked to Narcissistic abuse and through thorough therapy, it became very clear where the damage came from.

Narcissistic abuse has very predictable results on child victims which can be diagnosed, as it was in my case.

Bridie22 Wed 22-Jul-20 23:17:27

HolyHannah
Unless your parent was professionally diagnosed you cannot be the victim of narcissistic abuse.

Hetty58 Wed 22-Jul-20 23:18:25

FriendlyGhost, with the exception of my late mother, I can honestly say that I've never, ever had a bully in my life. I wouldn't allow it. A bully needs a victim - and I wouldn't be one.

rosecarmel Wed 22-Jul-20 23:20:07

In my case "assessments" of others were made based on my symptoms and description of family dynamics and individual members-

The assessments were outlined so that I could learn to recognize "behavioral markers" and navigate them or avoid them altogether going forward-

HolyHannah Wed 22-Jul-20 23:26:12

Bridie -- If that belief makes you feel better... Okay.

A doctor doesn't need to be a gun expert to know when a victim has been shot...

A 'head doctor' doesn't need to meet "the gun" (my 'mom') to see/diagnose the damage she produced.

Chewbacca Wed 22-Jul-20 23:27:22

Thanks for your reply HolyHannah. I suppose I'm just curious that, as is currently being discussed on another thread, a person who is narcissistic is normally seen and diagnosed by a qualified mental health professional, after many months of interviews and tests; it's not a diagnosis that's given lightly; and certainly not "3rd hand" via someone else. And that got me wondering why labels are given to people, who haven't actually ever been met in person?

But I'm derailing FriendlyGhost's thread as this wasn't supposed to be about unofficial psychological labelling! Apologies FriendlyGhost.

Bridie22 Wed 22-Jul-20 23:30:30

A head doctor does need to diagnose your parent if you are saying the information you give is because of a true medical condition,
Else you are the victim of abuse of a suspected person with a disorder.

Starblaze Wed 22-Jul-20 23:32:36

I am an absolute expert on my mums behaviour. I had half a lifetime of experience. I have spent a great deal of time educating myself and understanding it, I have been to see professionals and have listened to professional advice. I've become a master at managing anxiety and not letting it slow me down and a talking myself out of depression is now a super power

If anyone wants to tell me I cannot be the victim of a narcissist.

I'd say you are right. I stopped being a victim of a narcissist years ago and I never will be again.

Not that it matters, I can call her a narcissist or the wicked witch of the west or that mad bitch from hell... The only person I would be insulting is her and she deserves it.

My mum will never be a unicorn, no matter how much I want her to be. Time has run out. Its too late for her to ever come to any kind of realisation before one of us dies.

I accept that now.

Bridie22 Wed 22-Jul-20 23:35:08

Starblaze.
I'm sorry to hear that, sad situation.

Starblaze Wed 22-Jul-20 23:37:08

It has a happy ending Bridie

Chewbacca Wed 22-Jul-20 23:38:45

My mum will never be a unicorn

What does that mean?

HolyHannah Wed 22-Jul-20 23:43:08

Bridie -- I think I will stick with the long term medical advice/therapy I have gone through with experts.

You are free to believe whatever you want of my situation. It's called invalidation. You are not the first to try to invalidate me, my diagnosis etc.

If it makes you feel better to think that my Doctor is wrong, okay...

Bridie22 Wed 22-Jul-20 23:47:45

HolyHannah
No invalidation going on here, my doctor told me I had gallstones... he was wrong, if I had passed this information to others I would have been guilty of misinforming people.

Chewbacca Wed 22-Jul-20 23:51:48

Is FriendlyGhost coming back?

Bridie22 Wed 22-Jul-20 23:54:25

Chewbacca
Think she has gone to bed .

Starblaze Wed 22-Jul-20 23:54:59

Bridie if you had been treated for gallstones you would not have gotten any better as your doctor was wrong.

My treatment worked.

HolyHannah Wed 22-Jul-20 23:55:28

Bridie -- I have no idea how you think those two things relate to each other...

I am talking from my personal experience... PERIOD.

My Doctor diagnosed Me with C-PTSD related to child-hood abuse. He then narrowed down the type of abuse -- Narcissistic. It wasn't difficult to figure out who with the NPD caused the damage. My 'mom'.

MissAdventure Wed 22-Jul-20 23:57:25

Imagine if bridies doc diagnosed someone else who he had never met with gallstones. grin