Gransnet forums

Grandparenting

Taken for granted?

(106 Posts)
Literarylover Mon 14-Oct-24 19:05:37

My husband and I have been minding our three year old grandson one day per week since he was 6 months old. Now my daughter is expecting her second baby and, much as we love our only grandson, we were looking forward to a bit of respite while his mum is on maternity leave, especially as my husband has recently had health issues. It seems, however, that we are expected to continue with this arrangement. Obviously we are happy to help out, especially in the first few weeks after the new little one is born, but I feel it's a bit of a cheek for my daughter to ask us to continue to mind her son when she is not working. AIBU?

Grunty Tue 15-Oct-24 14:21:08

With the comment of maternity leave is: It is not a vacation! Just the opposite
It could be the hardest time of a woman's life! Recovering from birth, lack of sleep, taking care of a newborn plus other kids and rest of responsibilities, etc.

Then I refer you to "We have to assume that the expectant parents considered all angles of how they were going to cope with a 2nd child. If they didn't; that was irresponsible and is down to them to resolve by paying for child care."

This may possibly come as a shock to you but this isn't the first generation to ever have more than one child to care for! For many of our generation we didn't have the support of parents stepping in to help. Nor did we have husbands or partners who were entitled to paid paternity leave; we were lucky if they got a few days with us. The lack of sleep, taking care of a newborn plus other kids and rest of responsibilities, etc is nothing new; it's no more difficult now than it ever was! We just had to get on with it and be grateful if a grandparent could pop in from time to time. Deciding to expand your family is big decision and the responsibility for their ongoing care is your responsibility alone. If you can't cope; don't have more children. You have no entitlement to your parents taking over routine child care on a regular basis. Any assistance you do get is a bonus to be grateful for.

Patti46 Tue 15-Oct-24 14:34:54

I have been looking after my granddaughter who is almost three for one day a week and although it can feel like a chore at times I enjoy looking after her and miss her when I don't see her for a week. My advice is to cherish this time as it passes very quickly and before you know it they are starting nursery or school, but if you feel it is really too much then it is important to have that conversation with your daughter.

Hithere Tue 15-Oct-24 14:48:55

Some people seem to think parents are unable to manage without help - it goes both ways

How many threads are posted when help is rejected by new parents

keepingquiet Tue 15-Oct-24 14:49:19

Sometimes it seems GPs can't win. We moan if we don't see our GC and then moan if we spend too much time with them.

Yes, I also had little help with my two but expectations were different then and I didn't work for three years.

If one day a week is getting too much- bearing in mind the GC will be starting school in the near future- then why not speak to DD about it?

Maybe half day- or maybe offer to go there one day a week to help out with both kids and chores? Why do they have to come to you?

There are all kinds of solutions to this issue (I don't see it as a problem really).

I would have had a lot more sympathy but for your assuming she shouldn't need help whilst on mat leave? It isn't a holday a others have said.

MissAdventure Tue 15-Oct-24 14:51:50

I thought it was bonding time with baby she grew and birthed?
I also understood that it it is now advised not to have visitors?

All things I've read on here, of course.

62Granny Tue 15-Oct-24 14:59:41

Not sure when the baby is due but he will he be starting nursery? soon usually 1/2 day between age 3/4? So it will only be part of the day, also at 4 it is usually full time school. So may just mean collecting for a hour or two. If you can just give another few months I am sure he will enjoy the having the stability. Or as others have said perhaps the next couple of months you could just do half a day or a shorter day.

knspol Tue 15-Oct-24 14:59:55

You say your daughter has asked you to continue the present arrangement so you have the opportunity to say you don't want this.
Before you do that I think you should consider the effect this has on your grandson. It's part of the pattern of his life to be with you one day a week and presumably he enjoys this? His world is going to change quite a lot in the next few months and if he also no longer gets to spend a weekly visit with his Grandma & Grandad he might well feel rejected.

Grunty Tue 15-Oct-24 15:17:01

Some people seem to think parents are unable to manage without help - it goes both ways

Well judging from this thread alone; it would appear to be quite a few. And I believe I said in an earlier post that it did go both ways?

How many threads are posted when help is rejected by new parents

I don't know; tell me. More than when new parents are expecting help from grandparents? Or less?

Happilyretired123 Tue 15-Oct-24 15:28:30

grandtanteJE65

Bear in mind that the three year old will probably be jealous of the baby, and be happier to get away from him or her for his usual day with you and his grand-dad.

However, if it is getting to be too much for you, now is the time to discuss this with your daughter.

Why are so many British grandparents looking after their grandchildren? It seems so strange to me, as no-one expects this of grandparents in Denmark, and no-one ever explains whether there is a shortage of nurseries in Britain, or are they too expensive?

Yes childcare v expensive in UK. We look after our grandchild for 2 half days, and the other grandparents do the same, saving the parents around £800 a month! That is about half of their mortgage repayments. No they don’t live in a big house, just in the South East where houses are expensive, but that’s where their work is.

Happilyretired123 Tue 15-Oct-24 15:29:19

Happilyretired123

grandtanteJE65

Bear in mind that the three year old will probably be jealous of the baby, and be happier to get away from him or her for his usual day with you and his grand-dad.

However, if it is getting to be too much for you, now is the time to discuss this with your daughter.

Why are so many British grandparents looking after their grandchildren? It seems so strange to me, as no-one expects this of grandparents in Denmark, and no-one ever explains whether there is a shortage of nurseries in Britain, or are they too expensive?

Yes childcare v expensive in UK. We look after our grandchild for 2 half days, and the other grandparents do the same, saving the parents around £800 a month! That is about half of their mortgage repayments. No they don’t live in a big house, just in the South East where houses are expensive, but that’s where their work is.

Sorry forgot to say that’s 2 half days a week!

sharon103 Tue 15-Oct-24 15:31:26

flappergirl

LaCrepescule

On day a week doesn’t seem that much. Are you both unwell? Does your daughter not seem grateful?

I don't agree. This is a favour, not an obligation. The OP is talking about her daughter's children, not her own. One day is too much if the OP doesn't want to do it, or feels unable to. She says her DH has health issues. I think it's completely unreasonable to expect older parents to look after babies and toddlers. They've raised their own families, worked for years and years, gone through all sorts of hardships and shouldn't have to do it all again in retirement. Occasional babysitting and fun days out with grandkids is one thing but to be tied to permanent childcare for whatever remains of your life is quite another matter. If she can't look after 2 children at once she shouldn't have got pregnant again and assumed her mother would pick up the pieces.

Exactly. My thoughts too.

sharon103 Tue 15-Oct-24 15:39:22

Grunty

^With the comment of maternity leave is: It is not a vacation! Just the opposite^
It could be the hardest time of a woman's life! Recovering from birth, lack of sleep, taking care of a newborn plus other kids and rest of responsibilities, etc.

Then I refer you to "We have to assume that the expectant parents considered all angles of how they were going to cope with a 2nd child. If they didn't; that was irresponsible and is down to them to resolve by paying for child care."

This may possibly come as a shock to you but this isn't the first generation to ever have more than one child to care for! For many of our generation we didn't have the support of parents stepping in to help. Nor did we have husbands or partners who were entitled to paid paternity leave; we were lucky if they got a few days with us. The lack of sleep, taking care of a newborn plus other kids and rest of responsibilities, etc is nothing new; it's no more difficult now than it ever was! We just had to get on with it and be grateful if a grandparent could pop in from time to time. Deciding to expand your family is big decision and the responsibility for their ongoing care is your responsibility alone. If you can't cope; don't have more children. You have no entitlement to your parents taking over routine child care on a regular basis. Any assistance you do get is a bonus to be grateful for.

Well said. Same with me. I had 3 children
In fact I never assumed anyone would help me and no one volunteered anyway.
My husband had one day off of work and no pay.
I survived.

Msdaisy Tue 15-Oct-24 15:42:02

I’m going to put cat amongst the pigeons when I say I don’t actually enjoy looking after my 4 yr old gd. (Two days a week)
My son and dil believe the way to bring up children is to give them choices over everything. What she wants to eat, wear, going to park, play centre, shops etc. so even though I’ve tried gently to apply my ways ie lunch today is scrambled eggs on toast if she doesn’t want it, even though she’ll eat it sometimes, she’ll throw a tantrum. They allow her to walk around eating and snacking constantly. I think the word No does not exist in their home. She’s at pre school now and teacher has already mentioned she’s resistant to instructions. So baby number two is a year old and mum going back to work. I have been honest and told them I am not going to take care of her as my husband and I get very little pleasure from being with her. I’m told it’s how the Montessori ethos of learning is applied which she used to receive at a play group when she was 3?
So I think it’s not fair to assume all grandparents find the experience enjoyable.

Babs03 Tue 15-Oct-24 16:00:49

I was doing a lot of childcare until just recently, one of my daughters had post natal depression and my SiL had to go back to work soon after the birth so I practically lived with them for 6 months, looking after
the baby until my daughter felt recovered enough to do it. My OH came certain days to help but his health ruled out him being there as much as me. I was also looking after 2 other GCs from two other daughters as and when needed.
But a couple of months ago I stepped back having discussed how wiped I felt with them all, and how my life had been on hold for almost 2 years, I wondered if they’d get angry but they didn’t, and it doesn’t mean I don’t help, I still go to babysit but as and when I can do it. Tbh is usually not a week goes by without us seeing one or other of them, but not always in a babysitting capacity.
Is important not to pussyfoot around this, be honest and say how you feel. We are after all ‘people’ with our own lives before we are grandparents, and as others have said perhaps your daughter feels you would be upset if you stopped looking after your GS and might even be relieved you have brought it up.

DeeAitch56 Tue 15-Oct-24 16:17:46

When my son and his wife had their second baby I still gladly continued to have my granddaughter once a week whilst my daughter in law was on maternity leave, this gave mum and the new baby special time together without neglecting the elder child. Obviously if either myself or my husband were too ill to continue to do so then I would of course have to reconsider my commitments
Children grow so quickly so I cherish my time with them and I too didn’t receive any help from either of our families when my children were little, I’m succeeding in breaking the tradition of offering no help or love to my and my children’s children

Literarylover Tue 15-Oct-24 16:22:53

In answer to keepingquiet, I wasn't actually looking for " sympathy"- just other views. And to the person who wanted to know how how I wanted to be "thanked", I don't want thanks - just a bit of time for myself and DH in retirement before starting to mind the new baby.

Twig14 Tue 15-Oct-24 16:31:22

I understand that you want some time for yourself but you are fortunate your Dd includes you. Perhaps just a word to say you would love a little time for yourself when possible. My two grandchildren live at the other side of the world but sadly rarely get to see them.

silverlining48 Tue 15-Oct-24 16:36:50

If you want time with your dh before taking up the care of a second baby just say so. It’s certainly not unreasonable, in fact I think it’s important to have time free now, to do nothing or everything, particularly if you will be tied into child care for the next 5 or so years, just that really.
Your children’s children are their parents responsiblity not yours especially if their parent/s are at home.
You are not being unreasonable.

Kayteetay1 Tue 15-Oct-24 17:07:50

Will you also be child minding baby number 2 if or when mum returns to work?

GranMoo Tue 15-Oct-24 17:22:58

My Daughter and 9 month old Grandson have moved in with us as her partner is a heavy drinker and abusive( not physically but emotionally (although he did push her) which is why she left . It has totally disrupted our lives but we are obviously willing to make sacrifices to keep them safe. She is now saying that he is having therapy and is a different person and she wants to go back to him. This really scares me as I don’t believe he can change.I feel very strongly that she shouldn’t go back but I can’t really stop her as she is 39. I am very concerned and can’t sleep and feel totally exhausted and out of my depth. I have taken her to every baby group in the area hoping that she’d make some new friends and whenever she needs or wants anything we drive her there. However, she isn’t happy being with us as she’s used to living in a town and has lots of friends there. She doesn’t drive and we are very rural being 6 miles from the nearest shop, so we have to take her everywhere which she hates.

GB62 Tue 15-Oct-24 17:48:03

OMG, EXACTLY!!!

GB62 Tue 15-Oct-24 17:52:18

sharon103

Grunty

With the comment of maternity leave is: It is not a vacation! Just the opposite
It could be the hardest time of a woman's life! Recovering from birth, lack of sleep, taking care of a newborn plus other kids and rest of responsibilities, etc.

Then I refer you to "We have to assume that the expectant parents considered all angles of how they were going to cope with a 2nd child. If they didn't; that was irresponsible and is down to them to resolve by paying for child care."

This may possibly come as a shock to you but this isn't the first generation to ever have more than one child to care for! For many of our generation we didn't have the support of parents stepping in to help. Nor did we have husbands or partners who were entitled to paid paternity leave; we were lucky if they got a few days with us. The lack of sleep, taking care of a newborn plus other kids and rest of responsibilities, etc is nothing new; it's no more difficult now than it ever was! We just had to get on with it and be grateful if a grandparent could pop in from time to time. Deciding to expand your family is big decision and the responsibility for their ongoing care is your responsibility alone. If you can't cope; don't have more children. You have no entitlement to your parents taking over routine child care on a regular basis. Any assistance you do get is a bonus to be grateful for.

Well said. Same with me. I had 3 children
In fact I never assumed anyone would help me and no one volunteered anyway.
My husband had one day off of work and no pay.
I survived.

Exactly!!

GB62 Tue 15-Oct-24 17:53:45

Yep, exactly!!

Cambsnan Tue 15-Oct-24 17:58:35

How would you feel if she stopped needing you? Read a a few posts where grandparents never see their precious little one. Be grateful for what you have. Being needed is a gift.

Daisydaisydaisy Tue 15-Oct-24 18:00:05

I did the same however only one day a week with My first Grandchild then My Child had another and we more or less carried on as it was only one day ...3days a week is not on I feel .Do tell your Daughter that You need a break .
We now have both children one day a week each but I was happy to do this with the support of My Partner not My child's Dad .
My second grandchild is full of beans so it tiring but happy to do just the 2days with them both