Gransnet forums

News & politics

Braverman's behaviour in parliament today proves nothing has changed.

(337 Posts)
Normandygirl Wed 26-Oct-22 22:14:18

Suella Braverman scuttling out of the commons today to avoid scrutiny is a clear indication that nothing has changed with the Tories. The question from Yvette Cooper was tabled in plenty of time so she has no excuses. The fact that she walked out in full view of the speaker doesn't enhance his reputation either.

Ladyleftfieldlover Mon 31-Oct-22 18:49:23

I watched the debate too with Ms Braverman. I knew she’d blame Labour at some point, even though the Tories have been power for 12 years. Then when I thought it couldn’t get any worse, up popped the lunatic right wing swivel-eyed fringe. Chope etc. These are the bunch who Sunak had to appease to become PM. One thing I have always found disturbing about Braverman is the fact she can’t seem to distinguish between economic migrants (Albanians) and those fleeing from war torn countries (Syria, Afghanistan). The woman has no empathy or humanity.

DaisyAnne Mon 31-Oct-22 18:50:56

Bias bias

varian Mon 31-Oct-22 18:59:19

Tory MP sir Roger Gale tells the truth about Manston

news.sky.com/story/conservative-mp-sir-roger-gale-says-situation-at-manston-migrant-centre-a-breach-of-humane-conditions-12734816

Urmstongran Mon 31-Oct-22 19:22:49

Suella Braverman speaks fluent French. I’m hoping she and Macron and can work together well. Something different needs to be worked out because the present system is spinning out of control. I feel sorry for anyone living in Kent bearing the brunt of all this mismanagement.

At almost £7 million per DAY housing and sifting through the migrant claims I bet the average taxpayer hopes for a workable solution soon.

How did we ever get to this point? It’s crazy. We’ve become pretty much immune to the numbers now when we watch the rubber dinghies arriving daily. We seem powerless as a country to get a grip.

DaisyAnne Mon 31-Oct-22 19:28:00

It's appalling. The worst is that it didn't need to be like this. There is a problem worldwide, and we have to to talk to other European countries to find solutions.

People may say Sunak should not have employed Braverman, but he won't have to sack her; she is working very hard at sacking herself. The irrational right is still trying to appeal to the brainless popularity trolls who are only at home on social media, but it will change.

DaisyAnne Mon 31-Oct-22 19:28:36

My last post was in reply to varian.

volver Mon 31-Oct-22 19:30:09

From twitter:

Feel furious to hear that ... Braverman speaks fluent French after benefitting from studying in France on the Erasmus Scheme which she & her horrible Brexit have prevented our children & grandchildren from doing.

varian Mon 31-Oct-22 19:32:49

Suella Braverman had the opportunity to study in France as an Erasmus student, an opportunity denied to our children and grandchildren because of the disastrous brexit the she and her fellow ultra right wing ERG members promoted.

Casdon Mon 31-Oct-22 19:33:40

It’s no use Suella Braverman speaking French if she doesn’t speak sense, and she isn’t capable of doing that. She won’t be in post long enough to make any difference, hoist by her own petard.

Lucca Mon 31-Oct-22 19:40:20

Her fluent French is totally irrelevant. Macron speaks English and interpreters are always available. It’s what she says and does that matters not the language spoken.

Wyllow3 Mon 31-Oct-22 20:24:15

I hope she goes. She is a thoroughly nasty and manipulative person. From the BJ administration willing to break law, manipulate. she is seriously scary and her connections in the ERG I believe going to lead us into attitudes that do not care for those in greatest need, our own deprived, disabled and sick.

Yes, I do recognise there are massive problems but I don't want Braverman solutions.

She is openly appealing to the worst anti-immigration feelings in the public. the backlog of asylum seekers have been accruing for years and years of inadequate processing as well as the total lack of being able to fast forward those who come who are trained in the very skills we need in our work force.

Maybe she is useful to Sunak for a bit as she can be the convenient "baddie" to do the dirty work.

Luckygirl3 Mon 31-Oct-22 20:43:12

www.facebook.com/watch?v=839640700563580

DaisyAnne Mon 31-Oct-22 22:14:05

Suella Braverman is a barrister. She knows exactly how to use words. It's interesting that she said, today she "never ignored legal advice". That is not the same as following it.

DaisyAnne Mon 31-Oct-22 22:19:31

Wyllow3

I hope she goes. She is a thoroughly nasty and manipulative person. From the BJ administration willing to break law, manipulate. she is seriously scary and her connections in the ERG I believe going to lead us into attitudes that do not care for those in greatest need, our own deprived, disabled and sick.

Yes, I do recognise there are massive problems but I don't want Braverman solutions.

She is openly appealing to the worst anti-immigration feelings in the public. the backlog of asylum seekers have been accruing for years and years of inadequate processing as well as the total lack of being able to fast forward those who come who are trained in the very skills we need in our work force.

Maybe she is useful to Sunak for a bit as she can be the convenient "baddie" to do the dirty work.

Listening to her today we could have been listening to pre-war comments about the Jews. The use of the word "invasion".

How can people not see what this group are or would they have supported such language, aimed at others, pre-war and during the war. Some had no alternative then but that is not the case now.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 01-Nov-22 06:22:55

There is neither “illegal immigrants” nor is there an invasion.

What there is, -

People fleeing from war, famine and torture and arriving on our shores BY WHICHEVER ROUTE seeking asylum under the UN 1967 protocol, which all countries are signed up to.
It is an international agreement and law.

These people are legally entitled to seek asylum in their chosen country, which in this case happens to be the U.K.

Now if the government had acted with intelligence and empathy, it would have taken control of the situation from the beginning, instead of all the “othering” and nonsense rhetoric aimed at the unthinking.

Set up centres as offered by France and in France, providing sufficient staff etc.
Ensure all that asylum seekers who arrive on our shores by any other route are swiftly and sensibly appraised, giving sanctuary to refugees and returning those simply migrating for economic purposes, - although remember that is exactly why most of the those in the government of immigrant parentage arrived in the U.K.

None of this has happened and as a result the Tories are doing what they do best which is to waste tax payers money by forking out for hotel bills plus payments etc to the asylum seekers.

It is incompetence purely and simply.

However much those amongst us want all immigration to cease

It won’t. - ever. In fact it will almost certainly increase as war and climate change continues its ceaseless onslaught on the human race.

Unless we, as a country face this fact we will continue with the lies, rhetoric, and division alongside the appalling treatment of human beings, and never get control.

Lucca Tue 01-Nov-22 07:45:29

Good post WWM

MaizieD Tue 01-Nov-22 07:58:44

In case anyone agrees with Braverman that the UK is being subject to an 'invasion' of what she (disgustingly) calls 'illegal migrants', they should understand that the numbers of refugees/asylum seekers coming to the UK have changed very little over the past 20 years.

What has happened is that the rate at which their applications for asylum are dealt with has slowed considerably over the past decade. As can be seen very clearly in the graphic. Tory cutbacks in public spending have resulted in a Home Office which is completely ineffective and inefficient.

This will never be sorted while they remain in office. It's even suggested that Braverman is deliberately exacerbating the problem in order to keep the racist anti-immigration voters close to the tory party...

Lucca Tue 01-Nov-22 08:00:13

From the Times

Urmstongran Tue 01-Nov-22 08:05:42

Would those on here be willing to accept there are ‘economic migrants’? Not all these men are fleeing war torn countries! That much we do know. Many Albanian men are coming over here to pursue nefarious lifestyle choices as has been verified by UK Border Force officials.

volver Tue 01-Nov-22 08:10:02

Urmstongran

Would those on here be willing to accept there are ‘economic migrants’? Not all these men are fleeing war torn countries! That much we do know. Many Albanian men are coming over here to pursue nefarious lifestyle choices as has been verified by UK Border Force officials.

So? Does that justify making families live in overcrowded conditions where there are outbreaks of deadly diseases?

Lucca Tue 01-Nov-22 08:10:34

Yes. But the point is if the processing were done competently then many economic migrants would not get in.

volver Tue 01-Nov-22 08:10:57

Good post MaizieD

Urmstongran Tue 01-Nov-22 08:16:04

But MaizieD surely when there were less thousands of migrants arriving daily in their rubber dinghies (the sizes of which have grown exponentially to accommodate the demand) it was easier back in the day to deal with all the necessary paperwork and checks? Now the numbers have increased (verified by numerous sources if you Google) the very least we need is so many more personnel to deal with their applications.

This whole situation is a shambles. The Times article confirms this situation is costing the UK taxpayers £7 million a DAY Lucca.

This cannot and should not be thought an acceptable way of spending our money. I’m horrified by the gross sums of money involved especially as Sunak announces today big increases in taxation is planned.

Chocolatelovinggran Tue 01-Nov-22 08:19:34

Good posts WWM and MaizieD. I emailed Roger Gale to applaud him as the voice of compassion and integrity. I said that he might feel somewhat alone in his party just now. He thanked me, but didn't respond to my second comment..

MaizieD Tue 01-Nov-22 08:22:22

volver

Urmstongran

Would those on here be willing to accept there are ‘economic migrants’? Not all these men are fleeing war torn countries! That much we do know. Many Albanian men are coming over here to pursue nefarious lifestyle choices as has been verified by UK Border Force officials.

So? Does that justify making families live in overcrowded conditions where there are outbreaks of deadly diseases?

Not just overcrowded conditions but illegally detained there apparently. UK law apparently stipulates that they should only be there for 24 hours.

You are precisely the voter that Braverman is targeting, Ug. There are solutions available but they would involve the 'problem' fading into the background, which doesn't suit the tory agenda at all.