Gransnet forums

News & politics

Oh just zip it Gary Neville!

(37 Posts)
Urmstongran Mon 19-Dec-22 20:58:18

You went to Qatar. You took the money. £££s.
Stop now, with your pontificating.
Using a sports platform to air your political views.

We all have a view. Fair enough.
But ... you were very highly paid to talk about ... ⚽️

Galaxy Tue 20-Dec-22 16:13:10

If Rashford was publically supporting the Tories whilst raising concerns about child poverty then I would ignore him, if JKR was talking about safe spaces for women whilst announcing that in some situations it was ok for men to hit women I would ignore her too. It reminds me of those organisations that display the pride flag in every country except those who have the death sentence for gay people.
It is nothing to do with his profession.

Fleurpepper Tue 20-Dec-22 16:15:34

Hif profession provides the platform- and he is paid very handsomely and more, for that.

What about Diana?

Galaxy Tue 20-Dec-22 16:29:12

No I mean I dont have any snobbery about his profession. I come from a family of football fans and have spent more time than I care to admit watching football matches both amateur and professional. And supporting a team that consistently lets me down. grin

Fleurpepper Wed 21-Dec-22 09:29:53

Alan Shearer and many others have been using their platform to ask for a compensation fund from Fifa and Qatar, Gary Neville and Lineker are not the only ones.

Fleurpepper Wed 21-Dec-22 09:31:07

We all have 'a view' Urmstongran- what is yours, about the treatment of migrant workers during the construction process?

Why would anyone not back all those who are highlighting their plight? I just don't get it.

MawtheMerrier Wed 21-Dec-22 13:51:21

Fleurpepper

Lady Diana always used her platform, didn't she?

Not until she was Princess of Wales, (AIDS, Centre Point and the Homeless ) and then also as Diana, Princess of Wales after her divorce when she campaigned actively for the clearing of minefields.
Why should a member of the RF who may well be Patron of myriad charities not use their position to highlight awareness?
Camilla and Domestic Abuse, also Battersea Dogs’’ Home, Sophie Wessex and the WI, Princess Alexandra and (I believe) Alzheimer’s etc.
But too many slebs- media, theatre, or sports seem to think their area of expertise entitles them to pontificate often on matters way beyond their experience.
Emma Thompson flying by private jet to instruct us plebs to reduce our carbon footprint, for example.

Fleurpepper Wed 21-Dec-22 14:49:49

Good on all of them, I say. As for Qatar, I think all those 'slebs' like the 2 Garys, and others, do know what they are talking about.

Gummie Wed 21-Dec-22 15:01:17

I don’t think he should zip it. Enough is enough and everyone should be able to use any platform to get important messages across. To often we rely on the media to deliver messages but they all seem to be in cahoots with this ridiculous government.
A lot of people would have heard what he had to say and agreed. Now he should use his status as a popular pundit to do more in a political arena away from sport.
This country is sick and getting sicker. The more people talk about it the better.

MawtheMerrier Wed 21-Dec-22 16:50:51

But Gary Neville was not just spouting forth on Qatar. It was wage claims in this country , the nurses’ strike amongst other things
From The Times
Gary Neville faces criticism for paying staff in his luxury hotel the minimum wage while condemning the government over nurses’ pay.
In his final broadcast from the World Cup in Qatar, the pundit and former footballer said the government was paying nurses a “pittance” and compared their treatment with the Gulf state’s abuse of migrant workers, many of whom died building the stadiums.
It has been pointed out that his five-star Stock Exchange Hotel in Manchester, which is co-owned with Ryan Giggs, is advertising for waiters and waitresses who would be paid £9.50 an hour, the minimum wage for adults. The staff are for the Bull & Bear restaurant, run by the celebrity chef Tom Kerridge, which charges up to £5,900 for a bottle of wine and £49.50 for steaks

Yes, by all means highlight the appalling abuse of human nights in Qatar, that absolutely justified. But when it comes to matters at “home”, people in glasshouses should think twice about throwing stones. .

Fleurpepper Wed 21-Dec-22 17:07:59

Ah yes, and thanks, was not aware of this re Hôtel ownership and staff.

Iam64 Sun 25-Dec-22 20:55:35

He and his co-owners let the hotel be used by Homeless people for a long winter before refurb started
Gary Neville lived near me for several years. He was friendly, helpful and seen as s good guy
I’m pleased to see him speaking out politically. Paying staff in leisure/hotels/bars the minimum wAge Doesn’t mean he’s living in a glass house
I’m not surprised you’re irritated urns- Gary and Rashford are following Sir Alex in having good politics 🌞