Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

Why are people so spiteful?

(114 Posts)
Astitchintime Tue 24-Sept-24 07:56:49

Not sure if this is I the correct forum but here goes.

I am part of a crafting group, we all live quite locally and we got together to help and support local charities - this has not only helped those charities but also, in some cases, our own mental health too.

Everything has been 'ticking along' nicely, or so I thought. We had a social media group chat for sharing ideas and planning projects to raise money and we were all part of that.

Just yesterday I bumped into one of our members who is the admin for the group page. I will refer to her as Susan (not her real name). We chatted for a few minutes and then Susan announced that she was creating a fresh group message page and I was to look out for it later in the day but to not mention it to any one else. Wanting to get the shopping done and get out of the rain I just said 'Ok, I will take a look this afternoon'. We went our separate ways and I thought nothing of it until last evening.

On opening the new group forum I found that one of the members was not included, I will call her Jenny (again, not her real name). Jenny is a really lovely person, lives close to me with her OH and they would both do anything to help anyone and do a great deal to help Susan who lives alone - they give her lifts when her car is off the road, take her bins in, help with heavy gardening jobs, done her shopping when she's unwell etc. I also believe they have lent Susan money.

I phoned Susan as I though it was an oversight and perhaps she had forgotten to add Jenny but she claimed that she had not forgotten her, she simply didn't want her in the new group which she had created exclusively for planning lunches, day trips, visits to exhibitions, coffee & chat meet-ups etc.

I could see that others in the group were 'chatting' online and creating car-share rotas and setting a timetable for events well into the new year. They had even added my name to the rota without my specific agreement.

This does not sit right with me and I am now in the dreadful position of knowing that one of our group is being singled out and excluded. I know Jenny very well and I also know how much it would hurt her to know about the second group and the way Susan, and I suspect some others, have spitefully engineered all this.

I am beginning to feel like I no longer want to be part of the group but if I do I'll lose contact with the wider community. The toxic element that is emerging is tainting everything.

Why are people so spiteful?

MissAdventure Tue 24-Sept-24 12:10:15

I hope the woman who has started the new group will be declining any help from Jenny (?) in future.

Allira Tue 24-Sept-24 12:12:56

Babs03

Whatever the reason it seems unfair on Jenny. If Susan has fallen out with her or other group members have it needs to be dealt with openly and not so sneakily.

Yes.

If Susan has a problem with Jenny she should not involve others and needs to deal with it separately from the craft group.

Calendargirl Tue 24-Sept-24 12:22:11

I would be keen to know why Susan has excluded Jenny.

If, as you think, J has lent S money in the past and has divulged this information to someone, then perhaps that is the cause of the trouble? S would not be keen to admit that she has borrowed money probably, and is upset by this.

How do you know this? If J has told you this, (in confidence of course) who else has she told? 🤷‍♀️

I’m not trying to excuse S’s behaviour, but there might be more to it than what appears on the surface.

loopyloo Tue 24-Sept-24 12:22:39

I wonder if the money is the issue?

pascal30 Tue 24-Sept-24 12:35:51

I would put a message on the new What's app group saying that Jenny is not on the list and can they please include her. If no-one responds positively I would leave the Whattsapp.. I can't bear non-inclusivity.. then continue attending the creativity group with Jenny and whichever members choose to turn up. You could invite other people, you don't need a whattsapp group really...

Astitchintime Tue 24-Sept-24 15:46:33

Thank you all for your comments and advice, I truly appreciate you all taking the time to respond.

I suspected that Jenny had loaned Susan money when her car was in for MOT and required significant work to get it through. Susan said she would struggle to find the money - around £200 - and couldn't get her car back until she'd paid up. Then Jenny's OH took Susan to collect her car as she had 'found the cash' ; just seemed too much of a coincidence to me, perhaps I am wrong but Susan does have history of being a bit of a sponger; the sort of person who never has her purse when we go in a cafe, can't order supplies on line because her internet is down - get my drift?

Anyway, as the new group had created a car share rota which included me I have responded to the new group and stated that I did not agree to be part of the car share scheme devised by the second group which is seemingly supplementary to the original one, I would NOT be joining them on any outings and events and I find it very unfair that Jenny has been excluded. I have no way of knowing exactly who was privy to that decision.
Looking online recently I can see that not many of the group have actually seen my message so only time will tell.

I intend to carry on with current projects as we have several on the go in preparation for Christmas. If I do withdraw after the New Year I will still be able to support local charities with my creations as I keep getting asked for repeat orders on specific items.

Calendargirl Tue 24-Sept-24 15:49:20

Thanks for update Astitchintime.

Would be interested to know the eventual outcome of it all.

MissAdventure Tue 24-Sept-24 15:56:50

Very brave of you, AStitch.
Glad you have made your feelings clear.

Doodledog Tue 24-Sept-24 16:00:48

Hear hear!

Do let us know what happens, but whatever it is your conscience is clear.

Astitchintime Tue 24-Sept-24 16:04:03

Thanks Doodledog, Miss A and CG.......I have to admit that I was a bit narked that they assumed I was prepared to car share and didn't directly ask me before creating their spreadsheet thingy.

Lovetopaint037 Tue 24-Sept-24 16:10:06

I would ask on the group why she had been missed out? Must be a mistake which needs sorting out. Ask for an explanation.if this is not available then say well I need to be with Jenny’s group anyone else is welcome.

Harris27 Tue 24-Sept-24 16:15:29

Awful for you but i personally would have second thoughts who your mixing with. This has obviously upset you give yourself time but I think it’s time to evaluate. Sorry for the spiteful people in this world.

Smileless2012 Tue 24-Sept-24 16:21:01

Good for you Astitchintime.

Jaxjacky Tue 24-Sept-24 16:27:56

Well done Astitchintime now see who comes forward.

Babs03 Tue 24-Sept-24 16:39:46

@Astitchintime,
You did the right thing. Whatever happens now you know you did what you could to right a wrong. Let’s see how what you said lands with the group. You might be surprised how others now chime in with support of you and Jenny, sometimes it just takes one brave person to take the lead.
Well done 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽

Allsorts Tue 24-Sept-24 16:39:51

This is what I would do. Post on the new group, I see x has not been invited and wondered why as she is so nice and has done lot to help out in the past.Then await the answers. I personally wouldn't want to be with such people if they exclude a nice decent person, your turn might be next.

J52 Tue 24-Sept-24 16:41:58

Thanks for the update. Susan sounds like someone who, whilst being polite to, deserves a bit of a wide berth.

HowVeryDareYou2 Tue 24-Sept-24 18:21:07

Astitchintime Good for you. Susan sounds quite unpleasant.

Lisaangel10 Tue 24-Sept-24 20:24:11

My old schoolfriend messaged me to say she and another of our friends has been blocked from a WhatsApp group and unfriended on Facebook.

She used to say the WA group was boring as it was all about the woman who started it and everybody else had to tell her how nice she looked all the time. She said it was pinging all day long and got on her nerves.

I don’t do WA groups. This one sounded very nasty and cliquey.

Allira Tue 24-Sept-24 20:34:15

Astitchintime

Well done. Sometimes it just takes one person to stand up for what is right. I hope some of the others respond.

Chardy Tue 24-Sept-24 21:24:52

Before you leave the group, I think I'd ask a general question to all, asking why Jenny wasn't invited to join the group, especially as she'd been particularly kind and generous to several members of the group.

And a reminder that if you're in a WhatsApp group, you can mute the ping just for that group, and then just check it a couple of times a day.

OldFrill Tue 24-Sept-24 23:02:56

Well done!

CocoPops Wed 25-Sept-24 04:28:00

Astitchintime Your use of the word "narked" made me smile because it reminded me of my father who used the word too.
I was also narked when a friend added me to a WhatsApp group without my permission. After umpteen unwanted messages the following day I simply blocked the calls.
In my 1960's student days I shared a house with 5 other girls. One evening I returned home to be informed by 4 of them that they'd asked Fiona (not her real name) to move out "because she's not like the rest of us ". Fiona came from a working class family .It was snobbery. I had no idea that this was brewing and poor Fiona had been booted out earlier in the day. I was shocked that they, my so-called friends, could be so cruel. It was tricky because I thought if I moved out, thereby making a stand, it would result in lost friendships. I decided to move out but oddly enough I remained friends with all but on a different level if you know what I mean. One of life's lessons eh?

Mt61 Wed 25-Sept-24 08:39:25

It’s nothing short of bullying.
I wouldn’t want to associated with people like her- I would tell her what I thought about it, ( just calmly, don’t want a slanging match) & maybe do it at your next meet so the others can see her for what she is- a spiteful B

Mt61 Wed 25-Sept-24 08:43:09

CocoPops

Astitchintime Your use of the word "narked" made me smile because it reminded me of my father who used the word too.
I was also narked when a friend added me to a WhatsApp group without my permission. After umpteen unwanted messages the following day I simply blocked the calls.
In my 1960's student days I shared a house with 5 other girls. One evening I returned home to be informed by 4 of them that they'd asked Fiona (not her real name) to move out "because she's not like the rest of us ". Fiona came from a working class family .It was snobbery. I had no idea that this was brewing and poor Fiona had been booted out earlier in the day. I was shocked that they, my so-called friends, could be so cruel. It was tricky because I thought if I moved out, thereby making a stand, it would result in lost friendships. I decided to move out but oddly enough I remained friends with all but on a different level if you know what I mean. One of life's lessons eh?

What great friends eh! I would have got shut of them all- you don’t need friends like these, once I had moved out